HomeMy WebLinkAboutFile Documents.533 E Main St.0004.2017 (55).ACBK 1
HealthSafe Inspections Inc
1052 Vine St
Aspen CO 81611
970-920-2100
Jim Baker
CDPHE Asbestos Building Inspector Certification #13437
ASBESTOS REPORT
DATE:
11/11/2016
CLIENT:
Saint Mary Catholic Church
c/o Charles Cunniffe & Associates Architects
610 E Hyman Ave
Aspen CO 81611
Attn: Marina Skiles
PROJECT PROPERTY ADDRESS:
533 East Main Street, Aspen, Colorado 81611
CLIENT BACKGROUND:
Charles Cunniffe & Associates Architects hired HealthSafe Inspections, Inc. (hereinafter,
HealthSafe) to perform the required asbestos building inspection, bulk sampling and
reporting for an extensive interior demolition and remodel of the church building. An
asbestos inspection is required prior to the demolition and remodel/renovation of this
structure. Charles Cunniffe & Associates Architects was hired by the Saint Mary Catholic
Church, the Client, to create the architectural plans and submit remodel/renovation
project to the City of Aspen for a building permit.
Received
1/19/17
2
VISUAL INSPECTION & LABORATORY FINDINGS:
An inspection was conducted by Jim Baker of HealthSafe on Monday, November 7,
2016. A pre-survey of the remodel plans was conducted with Marina Skiles of Charles
Cunniffe & Associates Architects on Wednesday, November 2nd to become familiar with
the architectural plans for the remodel in order to understand the building materials which
will be impacted by the slated demolition and remodel. Suspect ACM/ACBM were
identified and sampled. Those materials are the following:
1. Kitchen sheet vinyl flooring, a homogeneous miscellaneous material requiring at
least one sample [KIT-V]. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE
DETECTED.
2. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [CONF-J; ORGAN-J].
These composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on
ceilings and walls of the pipe organ and confession room with a surfacing
material/texture plaster-like troweled application. The estimated surface area of
this section and office is more than 160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a
minimum of at least one composite core samples of all drywall layers (“…number
of samples sufficient to determine” …if asbestos is present or not). The PLM
analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
3. A homogeneous trowel-applied plaster-like knobby surfacing material/texture
[CONF-T-1,2,3]. This surfacing material/texture is on ceilings and walls of the
confession and organ area of the church. The estimated surface area is more than
160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a minimum of at least three
surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE
DETECTED.
4. Attic vermiculite insulation, a homogeneous miscellaneous material requiring at
least one sample [ATC-VERM]. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE
DETECTED.
5. A homogeneous trowel-applied surfacing material/texture (“plaster”) [CLG-
STUC-1,2,3,4,5,6,7]. This surfacing material/texture is on the sanctuary ceiling.
The estimated surface area is estimated to be more than 5,000 sf requiring a
minimum of at least seven surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM
analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
6. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [SANCT-J-1,2]. These
composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on the
sanctuary north and south walls of the sanctuary with a stucco-like plaster
surfacing material. The estimated surface area is more than 160 sf, but less than
1,000 sf, requiring a minimum of at least two composite core samples of all
drywall layers (“…number of samples sufficient to determine” …if asbestos is
present or not). The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
7. A homogeneous trowel-applied surfacing material/texture (“stucco-like plaster”)
[SANCT-1,2,3,4,5,6,7]. This surfacing material/texture is on the sanctuary walls,
a more recently applied finish. The estimated surface area is estimated to be more
Received
1/19/17
3
than 5,000 sf requiring a minimum of at least seven surfacing/texture material
samples. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
8. A homogeneous trowel-applied surfacing material/texture (“stucco-like plaster”)
[SAN-LYR-1-1,2,3,4,5,6,7]. This surfacing material/texture is on the sanctuary
walls over the original lath and plaster walls, the primary layer underneath the
secondary application in paragraph 7 above. The estimated surface area is
estimated to be more than 5,000 sf requiring a minimum of at least seven
surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE
DETECTED.
9. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [OP-KIT-J-1,2]; these
composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on ceilings
and walls of the kitchen with a surfacing material/texture known as “orange peel“.
The estimated surface area is more than 160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a
minimum of at least two composite core samples of all drywall layers (“…number
of samples sufficient to determine” …if asbestos is present or not). The PLM
analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
10. A homogeneous spray-applied surfacing material/texture (“orange peel”) [OP-
KIT-T-1,2,3]. This surfacing material/texture is on ceilings and walls of the
kitchen with a different spray pattern than the rest of this ground floor area. The
estimated surface area is more than 160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a
minimum of at least three surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM
analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
11. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [OP-OFC-J-1,2,3]; these
composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on ceilings
and walls of the main ground floor offices, restrooms and classrooms with a
surfacing material/texture known as “orange peel“. The estimated surface area is
more than 5,000 sf requiring a minimum of at least three composite core samples
of all drywall layers (“…number of samples sufficient to determine” …if asbestos
is present or not). The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE DETECTED.
12. A homogeneous spray-applied surfacing material/texture (“orange peel”) [OP-
OFC-T-1,2,3,4,5,6,7]. This surfacing material/texture is on ceilings and walls of
the []. The estimated surface area is more than 5,000 sf requiring a minimum of
at least seven surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM analytical estimated
results: NONE DETECTED.
13. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [ELEV-FLT-J-1,2]; these
composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on ceilings
and walls of the elevator pop-out section of the building without an applied
surfacing material/texture. The estimated surface area is more than 160 sf, but
less than 1,000 sf, requiring a minimum of at least two composite core samples of
all drywall layers, one from each floor (“…number of samples sufficient to
determine” …if asbestos is present or not). The PLM analytical estimated results:
NONE DETECTED.
Received
1/19/17
4
14. A homogeneous taped and joint compounded drywall system (classified as a
miscellaneous material as a complete integral system) [ST-MECH-J]; these
composite layered taped and joint compounded drywall materials are on ceilings
and walls of the basement mechanical and storage area with a partially covered
surfacing material/texture known as “skip-trowel“. The estimated surface area is
more than 160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a minimum of at least two
composite core samples of all drywall layers (“…number of samples sufficient to
determine” …if asbestos is present or not). The PLM analytical estimated results:
NONE DETECTED.
15. A homogeneous trowel-applied surfacing material/texture (“skip-trowel”) [ST-
MECH-T-1,2,3]. This surfacing material/texture is on ceilings and walls of the
basement mechanical and storage area. The estimated surface area is more than
160 sf, but less than 1,000 sf, requiring a minimum of at least three
surfacing/texture material samples. The PLM analytical estimated results: NONE
DETECTED.
There were no other additional suspect asbestos building materials to sample which were
slated to be disturbed, removed or disposed of without being invasive and destructive to
hidden interstitial areas possibly hidden or inaccessible at the time of inspection. A total
of 52 suspect homogeneous ACM/ACBM bulk samples were collected and 52 samples
were analyzed. The bulk samples were analyzed by PLM by a NVLAP accredited
laboratory in accordance with Colorado State Regulation 8 for the presence of asbestos
mineral fibers. There is NO asbestos in all 52 samples analyzed.
See supporting Hayes Microbial Consulting, Inc. data report #16031954
HEALTHSAFE CONCLUSIONS:
There is NO asbestos in any of the suspect building materials slated to be impacted by the
remodel/renovation of the church building. NO asbestos abatement will be required. All
building materials needing to be removed or disturbed can be dealt with without the
concerns for asbestos fibers. All building waste and debris can be disposed of in any
landfill which accepts normal, non-hazardous building waste. However, if there are areas
of the church building which are cavities or interstitial spaces which were not available at
the time of the inspection, please contact HealthSafe to inspect and possibly sample
additional suspect materials prior to demolition and disposal if found.
Sincerely Submitted,
Jim Baker
Received
1/19/17
5
COLORADO ASBESTOS REGULATIONS SUMMARY:
Colorado State Regulation 8 requires a State certified Asbestos Building Inspector to
inspect and sample for suspect asbestos containing materials (ACM) or suspect asbestos
containing building materials (ACBM) prior to the disturbance, removal or demolition.
In residential buildings of four or fewer units if more than 32 square feet of any surface
coverage (e.g., gypsum wallboard or drywall and associated applied surfacing
materials/textures, acoustic sprays, joint compounds, plaster, etc.), 50 feet of asbestos
covered or asbestos insulated pipe or any material which would fill a 55-gallon drum—if
these materials are going to be disturbed or removed—an asbestos inspection is required
by a state certified asbestos building inspector. For buildings with more than four
residential units (considered public), including commercial, public (including public
access areas to a residential building), civic or industrial buildings, if more than 160
square feet of surfacing materials, 260 linear feet or more than 35 cubic feet of suspect
ACM/ACBM is going to be disturbed, an asbestos inspection is required under NESHAP.
County or City regulations may be more stringent. The regulations require an absolute
minimum of 3 samples (EPA suggests 9) per homogeneous suspect surfacing and TSI
materials and an absolute minimum of 1 sample of homogeneous miscellaneous materials
or any number of “samples sufficient to determine whether a material is ACM”
(Reg8.IV.D.3). More samples are required based on surface area or volume. In order for
the contractor to proceed with restoration, renovation or demolition the suspect materials
have to be sampled and analyzed by a NVLAP accredited laboratory by polarized light
microscopy (PLM) methods. OSHA compliance is required for all employers/employees
no matter the quantity of asbestos present.
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
contact@hayesmicrobial.com
http://hayesmicrobial.com/
Analysis Report prepared for
HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Name: St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Sampled: 11-07-2016
Date Analyzed: 11-10-2016
Report Date: 11-10-2016
EPA Laboratory ID# VA01419
NVLAP Lab Code: 500096-0 NY ELAP Lab ID#12015 Asbestos License: 300435 License: #PH-0198
Page 1 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
November 10, 2016
Client Job Number:
Client Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Dear HealthSafe Inspections,
We would like to thank you for trusting Hayes Microbial for your analytical needs. On November 8, 2016 we received 52 samples by FedEx for the job
referenced above. 58 samples were received in good condition.
The results in this analysis pertain only to this job, collected on the stated date and should not be used in the interpretation of any other job. This report
may not be duplicated, except in full, without the written consent of Hayes Microbial Consulting, LLC.
This laboratory bears no responsibility for sample collection activities, analytical method limitations, or your use of the test results. Interpretation and
use of test results are your responsibility. Any reference to health effects or interpretation of mold levels is strictly the opinion of Hayes Microbial
Consulting. In no event, shall Hayes Microbial Consulting or any of its employees be liable for lost profits or any special, incidental or consequential
damages arising out of your use of the test results.
Steve Hayes, BSMT(ASCP)
Laboratory Director
Hayes Microbial Consulting, LLC
Page 2 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
1 1 KIT-V Vinyl / Gray
(None Detected)
15 % Cellulose fibers
85 %
2 2 CONF-J Drywall / White
(None Detected)
15 % Cellulose fibers
85 %
Layer 2 CONF-J Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
<1 % Cellulose fibers
<1 % Fibrous Other
100 %
3 3 CONF-T-1 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
4 4 CONF-T-2 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
5 5 CONF-T-3 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
6 6 ORGAN -J Drywall / White
(None Detected)
12 % Cellulose fibers
88 %
Layer 2 ORGAN -J Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
7 7 ATC-VERM Vermiculite / Silver
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Notes: Vermiculite Present in Sample. Vermiculite is a Known Problematic Material.
8 8 CLG-STUC-1 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 3 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
9 9 CLG-STUC-2 Granular / Green/White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
10 10 CLG-STUC-3 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
11 11 CLG-STUC-4 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
12 12 CLG-STUC-5 Drywall / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
13 13 CLG-STUC-6 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
14 14 CLG-STUC-7 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
15 15 CLG-STUC-8 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
16 16 SANCT-J-1 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
17 17 SANCT-J-2 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
18 18 SANCT-T-1 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
19 19 SANCT-T-2 Granular / Blue/White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 4 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
20 20 SANCT-T-3 Granular / Blue/White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
21 21 SANCT-T-4 Brittle / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
22 22 SANCT-T-5 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
23 23 SANCT-T-6 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
24 24 SANCT-T-7 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
25 25 SAN-LYR-1-T-1 Granular / Blue/White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
26 26 SAN-LYR-1-T-2 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
27 27 SAN-LYR-1-T-3 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
28 28 SAN-LYR-1-T-4 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
29 29 SAN-LYR-1-T-5 Debris / Gray
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
30 30 SAN-LYR-1-T-6 Granular / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 5 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
31 31 SAN-LYR-1-T-7 Texture / White
(None Detected)
12 % Cellulose fibers
88 %
32 32 OP-KIT-J-1 Drywall / White
(None Detected)
15 % Cellulose fibers
85 %
33 33 OP-KIT-J-2 Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
34 34 OP-KIT-T-1 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
35 35 OP-KIT-T-2 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
36 36 OP-KIT-T-3 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
37 37 OP-OFC-J-1 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
38 38 OP-OFC-J-2 Brittle / White
(None Detected)
20 % Cellulose fibers
80 %
39 39 OP-OFC-J-3 Drywall / White/Brown
(None Detected)
30 % Cellulose fibers
70 %
Layer 2 OP-OFC-J-3 Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
40 40 OP-OFC-T-1 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 6 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
41 41 OP-OFC-T-2 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
42 42 OP-OFC-T-3 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
43 43 OP-OFC-T-4 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
44 44 OP-OFC-T-5 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
45 45 OP-OFC-T-6 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
46 46 OP-OFC-T-7 Texture / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
47 47 ELEV-FLT-J-1 Drywall / White
(None Detected)
15 % Cellulose fibers
85 %
Layer 2 ELEV-FLT-J-1 Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
<1 % Cellulose fibers
100 %
48 48 ELEV-FLT-J-2 Drywall / White
(None Detected)
15 % Cellulose fibers
85 %
Layer 2 ELEV-FLT-J-2 Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
49 49 ST-MECH-J Drywall / White
(None Detected)
8 % Cellulose fibers
92 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 7 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
EPA 600/R-93, M-4/82-020 (PLM)HealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
Job Number:
Collected by:
Email:
Jim Baker
healthsafeinspections@gmail.com
Job Name:St Mary Catholic Church
Aspen, CO 81611
Date Collected:
Date Received:
Date Reported:
11/07/2016
11/08/2016
11/10/2016
#Sample Name Description Asbestos Fibers Other Fibers Non- Fibers
Layer 2 ST-MECH-J Joint Compound / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
50 50 ST-MECH-T-1 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
51 51 ST-MECH-T-2 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
52 52 ST-MECH-T-3 Debris / White
(None Detected)
(None Detected)
100 %
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 8 of 9
Received
1/19/17
HMC #16031954
Asbestos - Additional InformationHealthSafe Inspections
390 Apple Drive
Basalt, CO 81621 USA
Phone: 970-920-2100
All samples were received in acceptable condition unless otherwise noted on the report. The Report must not be used by the client to claim product certification, approval, or
endorsement by: AIHA, NIST, NVLAP NY ELAP, or any agency. The results relate only to the items tested. The results include an inherent uncertainty of measurement associated with
estimating percentages by polarized light microscopy. Measurement uncertainty data can be provided when requested. None detected: Below the detected reporting limit of 1% unless
point counting is performed, then the detected, reporting limit is .25%. Per NY ELAP198.6 (NOB) TEM is the only reliable method to declare an NOB material as Non-Asbestos
Containing. Hayes Microbial Consulting reserves the right to dispose of all samples after a period of 60 days in compliance with state and federal guidelines.
Signature: Date:11/10/2016 Reviewed by: Date:11/10/2016
Page 9 of 9
Received
1/19/17
Received 1/19/17
Received
1/19/17