HomeMy WebLinkAboutFile Documents.993 Moore Dr.0192.2019 (52).ARBK
TREE INVENTORY & MITIGATION REPORT
993 MOORE DRIVE, ASPEN, CO
PREPARED BY: ANDREW PLENINGER
ANDY@MYASPENTREE.COM (970) 963‐3070
1111 Vlillage Road Carbondale, CO 81623
OCTOBER 4, 2017
1 | Page
PURPOSE & SUMMARY
Lift Studios, Inc is working on a site improvement plan for the property at 993 Moore Drive in Aspen, CO
(See Attachment 1 – Site Map). We were contracted to inventory and evaluate the trees on the site for
planning and tree removal mitigation purposes. Each tree as required by the City of Aspen tree removal
code located within a tree survey area as defined by Lift Studios was evaluated and location and
condition of each tree was completed
A total of 190 trees meeting the City of Aspens tree removal permitting requirements were inventoried
located within the designated tree survey area.
METHODOLOGY
INVENTORY
Working from a survey map provided by Lift Studio and staking on the site (See Attachment 1 – Site Map
& Tree Survey Area), each tree, as required by the City of Aspen tree removal code, located within the
tree survey area was inventoried. The City of Aspen code Chapter 13.20 requires a permit for the
removal of a deciduous tree 6 inches or larger in diameter at breast height, conifers 4 inches diameter or
larger and select native trees 3 inches in diameter or larger.
Data collected included; the number of stems, the Diameter at Breast Height (DBH) to the lowest ½ inch
at approximately 4.5 feet above ground level, tree species and condition rating. Each deciduous tree or
conifer was tagged with an aluminum numbered tag backed with orange flagging corresponding to the
ID/Tag # noted on the survey map and in the Tree Inventory Mitigation Worksheet (Attachment 2).
Trees meeting the deciduous and conifer requirements and not found on the survey map were double
tagged and backed with blue flagging with the two tag numbers corresponding to the Mitigation
Worksheet. Native trees inventoried were not tagged or flagged however they were marked with red
wax marking crayon. The approximate location of any additional trees and field notes were also noted
on Field Map Notes (Attachments 3 & 4). In addition, 9 trees located on the property to the west (991
Moore Drive) were inventoried for planning purposes but not tagged or marked (Attachment 5).
Condition ratings (1 to 5) were assigned as a result of visual indicators of the tree health and structure
such as the presence of dead limbs, signs or symptoms of disease/insects, or structural defects. The
definitions of the condition rating are as follows:
1 ‐ Excellent ‐ A healthy, vigorous tree, reasonably free of signs and symptoms of disease, with good
structure and form typical of the species.
2 ‐ Good ‐ Tree with slight decline in vigor, small amount of twig dieback, minor structural defects that
could be corrected.
3 ‐ Fair ‐ Tree with moderate vigor, moderate twig and small branch dieback, thinning of crown, poor leaf
color, moderate structural defects that might be mitigated by regular care.
4 ‐ Poor ‐ Tree in decline, epicormic growth, extensive dieback of medium to large branches, significant
pathogen activity or structural defects that cannot be abated.
2 | Page
5 ‐ Very Poor/Dead ‐ Tree is in severe decline, hazardous or is dead.
MITIGATION CALCULATION
We understand the purpose and objectives of City of Aspen’s Tree Removal and Mitigation
requirements. Healthy trees are an asset to the property owner and the community. However, trees
that are in poor health or structurally defect can present a safety and forest health liability for the
property owner and the community. Therefore, we believe it is reasonable and appropriate to account
for this liability by adjusting the mitigation value of a specific tree based on the condition of the tree.
This adjustment is made by multiplying the City of Aspen Tree Mitigation Value (as defined by the City
code) by a percentage based on the tree condition. The result is an Adjusted Mitigation Value. The
following narrative details our mitigation adjustment calculation.
Each tree inventoried was entered into a tree mitigation worksheet noting the DBH, the tree condition
rating, the Aspen Mitigation Value, the Assigned Mitigation Adjustment %, and the Adjusted Mitigation
Value is calculated for each tree (See Attachment 2 – Tree Mitigation Worksheet – All Trees). The
Adjusted Mitigation Value was calculated by multiplying the Aspen Mitigation Value ($42 x 3.14 x
(DBH/2)^2 x) by the Assigned Mitigation Adjustment %.
The Assigned Mitigation Adjustment % ranges from 0 to 100%. This percentage was assigned based on
the condition of the tree and forest health risks the tree poses to the site and area. Structurally
defective trees can present a safety risk to people and/or property. Dead or declining trees pose a threat
to forest health, hosting and attracting insect pests and disease becoming a point source for the spread
of these pest and disease problems. The following are the definitions of the Assigned Mitigation
Adjustment % used is used to quantify all of these risks. We believe this results in a reasonable method
to maintain the City’s tree removal mitigation objectives and not unnecessary burden the property
owner with unreasonable mitigation costs.
1. 100% Mitigation – A tree scoring a 1 or 2 condition value.
2. 50% Mitigation – A tree scoring a 3 ‐ condition value.
3. 0% Mitigation – A tree scoring a 4 or 5 condition value.
LIMITS OF THE ASSIGNMENT
This investigation is based solely upon the information noted from my visits to the site in July & August
2017. We have not performed any professional surveying, laboratory examinations, studied soil
composition or employ any other diagnostic techniques beyond visual examination of the trees and the
site. We have developed general conclusions on observations of tree health and structure and provided
recommendations based upon these observations.
FINDINGS & OBSERVATIONS
SITE DESCRITION
The site a wooded natural area located on the southern slopes above Aspen at the end of Moore Drive.
The trees on the site are mix of aspen, Douglas‐fir, gamble oak, serviceberry, spruce, and sub alpine fir.
3 | Page
FINDINGS
Tree qualifying for mitigation total 192 (See Attachment 2 – Tree Mitigation Worksheet – All Trees). There
are 72 deciduous trees, all are quaking aspen. Conifers total 59 trees including 9 Douglas‐fir and 50 sub alpine fir.
The native trees 3 inches in diameter or larger are all gambel oak and total 61 trees. Condition ratings are; 16% are
1‐Excellent or 2‐Good, 25% are Fair, and 59% are 4‐Poor or 5‐Very Poor/Dead.
There were discrepancies between the surveyor’s inventory of the mitigatable trees and our findings. Trees did not
meet the City of Aspen size requirements are not included in the Tree Mitigation Worksheets and additional trees
found that do meet the requirements were added. Inventory notes were made on two tree inventory map note
maps (Attachments 3 & 4).
A total of 9 trees were inventoried on the west boarding property, 991 Moore Drive; 3 aspen, 3 Douglas‐fir and 3
blue spruce (See Attachment 5). The aspen are over‐mature and in poor condition. The Douglas‐fir and spruce are
relatively large and recent transplants in good condition and transplantable.
TREE CONDITION OBSERVATIONS
DECIDUOUS TREES
All of the deciduous trees are aspen. They are over‐mature and declining in health and structure. Over 86% score a
condition of 4 or five (See Attachment 6). Insect pests and disease common to aspen are widespread throughout
the stand.
Photo 1. Site overview. Driveway on the right is the property to the
west referenced regarding inventorying trees on that property.
4 | Page
Photo 2 (above). Typical aspen.
Photo 3 (above). Poplar borer on aspen.
Photo 4 (above). Serious cytospora canker disease
on aspen.
5 | Page
CONIFERS
As a group the conifers are in the best condition, 47% score a 1 or 2, 47% score a 3 and ~8% score a 4 or 5 (See
Attachment 7). There are 53 sub alpine fir and 6 Douglas‐fir. The Douglas‐fir are in declining condition with thin
and off‐color crowns and signs of bark beetle infestation.
Photos 5 & 6. Declining Douglas‐fir. Signs of bark
beetle infestation were observed including pitching,
wood pecker activity and the declining crown
density and color.
6 | Page
NATIVE TREES
All the native trees of mitigatable size are gambel oak. Approximately 87% of the gambel oak score a 4 or 5
condition rating (See Attachment 8).
Photo 7 (Left). Typical decline/dieback on gambel
oak.
Photo 8 (above). Witches broom on gambel oak.
Photo 9 (left). Sprouting on stagheaded and
heading cuts gambel oak.
7 | Page
MITIGATION TOTALS & CLOSING
The total City of Aspen Mitigation Value of all the trees inventoried is $461,914.49 (See Attachment 2). Condition
ratings for all trees are; 16% are 1‐Excellent or 2‐Good, 25% are Fair, and 59% are 4‐Poor or 5‐Very Poor/Dead.
Adjusting the Aspen Mitigation Value for the condition of the trees results in an Adjusted Mitigation Value of
$129,078.21.
The total City of Aspen Mitigation Value of all the deciduous trees inventoried is $256,836.30 (See Attachment 6).
Condition ratings for all trees are; 47% score a 1 or 2, 47% score a 3 and ~8% score a 4 or 5. Adjusting the Aspen
Mitigation Value for the condition of the trees results in an Adjusted Mitigation Value of $30,093.37.
The total City of Aspen Mitigation Value of all the conifer trees inventoried is $183,339.25 (See Attachment 7).
Condition ratings for all trees are; 47% score a 1 or 2, 47% score a 3 and ~8% score a 4 or 5. Adjusting the Aspen
Mitigation Value for the condition of the trees results in an Adjusted Mitigation Value of $96,986.04.
The total City of Aspen Mitigation Value of all the native trees inventoried is $24,991.26 (See Attachment 8).
Condition ratings for all trees are; 47% score a 1 or 2, 47% score a 3 and ~8% score a 4 or 5. Adjusting the Aspen
Mitigation Value for the condition of the trees results in an Adjusted Mitigation Value of $1,998.81.
TREE PRESERVATION & PROTECTION
A tree preservation plan should be developed for trees to be preserved throughout construction. Pre‐construction
plant health care treatments may be recommended for select trees and other physical tree protection measures
should be taken for on site. Tree preservation/protection measures are listed below.
Pre‐construction Plant Health Care Treatments
o Pruning for under tree canopy clearance
o Growth regulator treatments of notable trees that will suffer root zone disturbance
Tree Protection
o Tree Protection fencing
o Root zone protection measures for equipment access and material storage areas
0' 10' 20'Tree Removal Plan2017-05-19 Draft DRB Submittal2017-05-22 DRB SubmittalNOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONIssuanceNORTH WINGSOUTH WINGAttachment 1 - Site Map & Tree Survey Area
Attachment 2
993 Moore Drive, Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
All Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
2 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0% $0.00
3 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0% $0.00
5 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,975.54 0% $0.00
6 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0% $0.00
7 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0% $0.00
8 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00
9 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0% $0.00 DEAD
11 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,110.08 0% $0.00 DEAD
12 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,670.57 0% $0.00 DEAD
15 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,670.57 0% $0.00 DEAD
16 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00 DEAD
17 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,747.68 0% $0.00 8' staghead
19 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
20 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
22 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50% $2,373.84
23 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0% $0.00
24 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0% $0.00
25 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0% $0.00 BORER
26 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,297.00 0% $0.00
27 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0% $0.00 DEAD
28 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0% $0.00 DEAD
29 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0% $0.00 DEAD
30 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,297.00 50% $1,648.50
31 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,360.28 0% $0.00
33 1 10.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,634.94 0% $0.00 DEAD
34 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,975.54 0% $0.00 DEAD
35 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0% $0.00 DEAD
36 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0% $0.00 DEAD STAGHEAD
38 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0% $0.00
39 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,747.68 0% $0.00
41 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
42 1 15 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $7,418.25 50% $3,709.13
43 1 13.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,008.78 0% $0.00
44 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,747.68 0% $0.00
45 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0% $0.00
47 1 14 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,462.12 0% $0.00
48 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0% $0.00 DEAD
49 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0% $0.00 DEAD
50 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50% $2,373.84
51 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0% $0.00 DEAD
52 1 14 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,462.12 0% $0.00
53 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0% $0.00
54 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,989.37 0% $0.00 TRUNK WOUND
55 1 14.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,931.94 0% $0.00
56 1 12.5 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $5,151.56 50% $2,575.78
57 1 13.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,008.78 0% $0.00
58 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0% $0.00 DEAD
59 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0% $0.00
60 1 15 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $7,418.25 0% $0.00 DEAD
67 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
Page 1 of 4
Attachment 2
993 Moore Drive, Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
All Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
81 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $997.34 0% $0.00
83 1 6 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $1,186.92 100% $1,186.92
86 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0% $0.00 DEAD
89 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0% $0.00 DEAD
91 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00 DEAD
92 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0% $0.00 DEAD
93 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $2,382.08 100% $2,382.08
95 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0% $0.00
96 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0% $0.00
97 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00 DEAD
98 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,110.08 0% $0.00 DEAD
99 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00
101 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $1,854.56 0% $0.00
103 1 7 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,615.53 0% $0.00 DEAD
104 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0% $0.00 DEAD
105 1 10.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $3,634.94 50% $1,817.47
106 1 9 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $2,670.57 50% $1,335.29
108 1 8.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $2,382.08 50% $1,191.04
111 1 10.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $3,634.94 50% $1,817.47
114 1 12.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $5,151.56 50% $2,575.78
116 1 9.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $2,975.54 50% $1,487.77
117 1 10.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $3,634.94 100% $3,634.94
118 1 11 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
119 1 12.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 4 $5,151.56 0% $0.00
120 1 11.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $4,360.28 50% $2,180.14
121 1 13 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,571.93 50% $2,785.97
122 1 13 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,571.93 50% $2,785.97
123 1 12 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $4,747.68 0% $0.00 DEAD
124 1 17 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $9,528.33 100% $9,528.33
125 1 15 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $7,418.25 50% $3,709.13
127 1 13.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $6,008.78 50% $3,004.39
128 1 11 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
129 1 15 DOUGLAS FIR 2 $7,418.25 100% $7,418.25
130 1 17.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $10,097.06 50% $5,048.53
131 1 16.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $8,976.08 50% $4,488.04
132 1 16.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $8,976.08 50% $4,488.04
134 1 18 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $10,682.28 50% $5,341.14
136 1 23 DOUGLAS FIR 4 $17,441.13 0% $0.00
141 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
144 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
147 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
148 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
150 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $667.64 50% $333.82
151 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $527.52 100% $527.52
152 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
155 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $667.64 100% $667.64
157 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $667.64 50% $333.82
162 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
163 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
164 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
Page 2 of 4
Attachment 2
993 Moore Drive, Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
All Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
166 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $527.52 100% $527.52
171 2 5.2 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $891.51 50% $445.75
178 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
179 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
181 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
182 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $997.34 100% $997.34
183 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
184 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
185 1 7 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $1,615.53 0% $0.00 DEAD
186 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $997.34 100% $997.34
190 1 6.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $1,392.98 100% $1,392.98
191 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
192 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
193 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
196 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
197 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
198 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
199 1 8 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $2,110.08 0% $0.00 DEAD STAGHEAD
202 1 8 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $2,110.08 50% $1,055.04
206 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
207 1 5 OAK, Gambel 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
208 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
209 1 5 OAK, Gambel 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
210 1 5 OAK, Gambel 4 $824.25 0% $0.00
211 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
212 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
214 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00 Dead
215 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00 Dead
216 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
219 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
220 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
221 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
222 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
223 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
232 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
234 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
235 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
240 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
244 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
246 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
248 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
249 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
251 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
252 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
253 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
254 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
258 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
260 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
263 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
264 2 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
Page 3 of 4
Attachment 2
993 Moore Drive, Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
All Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
266 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
267 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
268 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
269 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
271 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
272 1 4 OAK, Gambel 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
274 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
275 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
276 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
277 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 3 $403.88 50% $201.94
278 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
288 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
289 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
290 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
291 1 4 OAK, Gambel 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
292 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
293 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
294 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
296 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
297 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
301 1 4 OAK, Gambel 5 $527.52 0% $0.00
302 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
303 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
304 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
306 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
307 1 4 OAK, Gambel 5 $527.52 0% $0.00
308 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
310 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
311 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
461 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $2,975.54 50% $1,487.77 Not on Survey
1032 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0% $0.00 Not on Survey
1337 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52 Not on Survey
1439 1 12.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,151.56 50% $2,575.78 Not on Survey
1734 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50% $2,373.84 Not on Survey
1848 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,360.28 0% $0.00 Not on Survey
3550 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,989.37 0% $0.00 Not on Survey
3621 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56 Not on Survey
4047 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0% $0.00 Not on Survey, DEAD
4638 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $2,670.57 50% $1,335.29 Not on Survey
4937 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0% $0.00 Not on Survey
6468 1 7 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $1,615.53 50% $807.77 Not on Survey
7370 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56 Not on Survey
Totals $469,914.49 $129,078.21
Page 4 of 4
993 Moore Drive
Tree Inventory Notes Map ATS‐A
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/04/17
1734
1848
3550
1337 1032 1439
#21 does
not exist
#185 does
not exist
New tree. Tree
tagged with 2 tags &
blue ribbon, #s
correspond to noted
993 Moore Drive
Tree Inventory Notes Map ATS‐B
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/04/17
#13 & 174 do
not exist
3621
6468
7370
4937
461
4638
4047
New tree. Tree
tagged with 2 tags &
blue ribbon, #s
correspond to noted
270 & 309
do not exist Could not ID 4
oak. Numerous
additional gambel
oak greater than
3 inches and in
fair condition
Could not ID
3 aspen
Attachment 5 Trees Inventoried at 991 Moore Drive
Bording 993
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID ## of
Stems DBH Species Condition Comments
10 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING DEAD
18 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING Very Poor
37 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING Poor
138 1 5 SPRUCE COLORADO BLUE Good Transplantable
140 1 5 DOUGLAS FIR Good Transplantable
175 1 5 DOUGLAS FIR Good Transplantable
176 1 3 DOUGLAS FIR Good Transplantable
194 1 8 SPRUCE COLORADO BLUE Fair Transplantable
201 1 9 SPRUCE COLORADO BLUE Good Transplantable
Page 1 of 1
Attachment 6
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Deciduous Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen
Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
2 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0%$0.00
3 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0%$0.00
5 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,975.54 0%$0.00
6 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0%$0.00
7 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,670.57 0%$0.00
8 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00
9 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0%$0.00 DEAD
11 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,110.08 0%$0.00 DEAD
12 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,670.57 0%$0.00 DEAD
15 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,670.57 0%$0.00 DEAD
16 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00 DEAD
19 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50%$1,994.69
20 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50%$1,994.69
22 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50%$2,373.84
23 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0%$0.00
24 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0%$0.00
25 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0%$0.00 BORER
26 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,297.00 0%$0.00
27 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0%$0.00 DEAD
28 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0%$0.00 DEAD
29 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0%$0.00 DEAD
30 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,297.00 50%$1,648.50
31 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,360.28 0%$0.00
33 1 10.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,634.94 0%$0.00 DEAD
34 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,975.54 0%$0.00 DEAD
35 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0%$0.00 DEAD
36 1 10 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,297.00 0%$0.00 DEAD STAGHEAD
38 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0%$0.00
39 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,747.68 0%$0.00
41 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $3,989.37 50%$1,994.69
42 1 15 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $7,418.25 50%$3,709.13
43 1 13.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,008.78 0%$0.00
44 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,747.68 0%$0.00
45 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0%$0.00
47 1 14 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,462.12 0%$0.00
48 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $3,989.37 0%$0.00 DEAD
49 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0%$0.00 DEAD
50 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50%$2,373.84
51 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $4,360.28 0%$0.00 DEAD
52 1 14 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,462.12 0%$0.00
53 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0%$0.00
54 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,989.37 0%$0.00 TRUNK WOUND
55 1 14.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,931.94 0%$0.00
56 1 12.5 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $5,151.56 50%$2,575.78
57 1 13.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $6,008.78 0%$0.00
58 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0%$0.00 DEAD
59 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0%$0.00
60 1 15 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $7,418.25 0%$0.00 DEAD
83 1 6 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $1,186.92 100%$1,186.92
86 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,382.08 0%$0.00 DEAD
Page 1 of 2
Attachment 6
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Deciduous Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
89 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0%$0.00 DEAD
91 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00 DEAD
92 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0%$0.00 DEAD
93 1 8.5 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $2,382.08 100%$2,382.08
95 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0%$0.00
96 1 6.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,392.98 0%$0.00
97 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00 DEAD
98 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $2,110.08 0%$0.00 DEAD
99 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00
101 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $1,854.56 0%$0.00
103 1 7 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,615.53 0%$0.00 DEAD
104 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $1,854.56 0%$0.00 DEAD
461 1 9.5 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $2,975.54 50%$1,487.77 Not on Survey
1032 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,747.68 0%$0.00 Not on Survey
1734 1 12 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $4,747.68 50%$2,373.84 Not on Survey
1848 1 11.5 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $4,360.28 0%$0.00 Not on Survey
3550 1 11 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $3,989.37 0%$0.00 Not on Survey
3621 1 7.5 ASPEN QUAKING 2 $1,854.56 100%$1,854.56 Not on Survey
4047 1 13 ASPEN QUAKING 5 $5,571.93 0%$0.00 Not on Survey, DEAD
4638 1 9 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $2,670.57 50%$1,335.29 Not on Survey
4937 1 8 ASPEN QUAKING 4 $2,110.08 0%$0.00 Not on Survey
6468 1 7 ASPEN QUAKING 3 $1,615.53 50%$807.77 Not on Survey
Totals $256,836.30 $30,093.37
Page 2 of 2
Attachment 7
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Conifers
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen
Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
67 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
81 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $997.34 0% $0.00
105 1 10.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $3,634.94 50% $1,817.47
106 1 9 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $2,670.57 50% $1,335.29
108 1 8.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $2,382.08 50% $1,191.04
111 1 10.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $3,634.94 50% $1,817.47
114 1 12.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $5,151.56 50% $2,575.78
116 1 9.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $2,975.54 50% $1,487.77
117 1 10.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $3,634.94 100% $3,634.94
118 1 11 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
119 1 12.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 4 $5,151.56 0% $0.00
120 1 11.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $4,360.28 50% $2,180.14
121 1 13 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,571.93 50% $2,785.97
122 1 13 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,571.93 50% $2,785.97
123 1 12 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $4,747.68 0% $0.00 DEAD
124 1 17 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $9,528.33 100% $9,528.33
125 1 15 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $7,418.25 50% $3,709.13
127 1 13.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $6,008.78 50% $3,004.39
128 1 11 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $3,989.37 50% $1,994.69
129 1 15 DOUGLAS FIR 2 $7,418.25 100% $7,418.25
130 1 17.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $10,097.06 50% $5,048.53
131 1 16.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $8,976.08 50% $4,488.04
132 1 16.5 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $8,976.08 50% $4,488.04
134 1 18 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $10,682.28 50% $5,341.14
136 1 23 DOUGLAS FIR 4 $17,441.13 0% $0.00
141 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
144 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
147 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
148 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
150 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $667.64 50% $333.82
151 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $527.52 100% $527.52
152 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
155 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $667.64 100% $667.64
157 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $667.64 50% $333.82
162 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
163 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
164 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
166 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $527.52 100% $527.52
171 2 5.2 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $891.51 50% $445.75
178 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
179 1 4.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $667.64 100% $667.64
181 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
182 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $997.34 100% $997.34
183 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
Page 1 of 2
Attachment 7
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Conifers
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: 10/4/2017
ID/Tag
#
# of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen
Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
184 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
185 1 7 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $1,615.53 0% $0.00 DEAD
186 1 5.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $997.34 100% $997.34
190 1 6.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $1,392.98 100% $1,392.98
191 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
192 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
193 1 5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $824.25 100% $824.25
196 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
197 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
198 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 1 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
199 1 8 FIR SUBAPLINE 5 $2,110.08 0% $0.00 DEAD STAGHEAD
202 1 8 DOUGLAS FIR 3 $2,110.08 50% $1,055.04
1337 1 4 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $527.52 100% $527.52
1439 1 12.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 3 $5,151.56 50% $2,575.78
7370 1 7.5 FIR SUBAPLINE 2 $1,854.56 100% $1,854.56
Totals $183,339.25 $96,986.04
Page 2 of 2
Attachment 8
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Native Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: August 16, 2017
ID ## of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen
Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
203 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 3 $667.64 50% $333.82
206 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
207 1 5 OAK, Gambel 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
208 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
209 1 5 OAK, Gambel 3 $824.25 50% $412.13
210 1 5 OAK, Gambel 4 $824.25 0% $0.00
211 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
212 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
214 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00 Dead
215 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00 Dead
216 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
219 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
220 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
221 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
222 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
223 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
232 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
234 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
235 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
240 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
244 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
246 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
248 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
249 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
251 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
252 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
253 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
254 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
258 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
260 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
263 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
264 2 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
266 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
267 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
268 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
269 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
271 1 3 OAK, Gambel 3 $296.73 50% $148.37
272 1 4 OAK, Gambel 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
Page 1 of 2
Attachment 8
993 Moore Drive Aspen
Tree Mitigation Worksheet
Native Trees
Condition Rating
1 - Excellent
2 Good
3 - Fair
4 - Poor
5 - Very Poor/Dead
Aspen Tree Service
As of: August 16, 2017
ID ## of
Stems DBH Species
Condition
Rating
Aspen
Mitigation
Value
Assigned
Mitigation
Adjustment
%
Adjusted
Mitigation
Value
Comments
274 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
275 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
276 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
277 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 3 $403.88 50% $201.94
278 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
288 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
289 1 3 OAK, Gambel 5 $296.73 0% $0.00
290 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
291 1 4 OAK, Gambel 3 $527.52 50% $263.76
292 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
293 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
294 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
296 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
297 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
301 1 4 OAK, Gambel 5 $527.52 0% $0.00
302 1 4.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $667.64 0% $0.00
303 1 4 OAK, Gambel 4 $527.52 0% $0.00
304 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
306 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
307 1 4 OAK, Gambel 5 $527.52 0% $0.00
308 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 5 $403.88 0% $0.00
310 1 3 OAK, Gambel 4 $296.73 0% $0.00
311 1 3.5 OAK, Gambel 4 $403.88 0% $0.00
Totals $24,991.26 $1,998.81
Page 2 of 2