HomeMy WebLinkAboutminutes.council.19930222Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Mayor Pro Tem Peters called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. with
Councilmembers Pendleton, Reno and Richards present.
OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEE BONUS AWARDS
Mayor Pro Tem Peters and Council presented outstanding employee
bonus awards and checks to Glenn Schaffer, police department; Gary
Kalkman, police department; Kathy Tolle, police department; Tom
Dunlop, environmental health department and the finance department.
PROCLAMATION - Roxanne Eflin
Mayor Pro Tem Peters read a proclamation to commend Roxanne Eflin
for her exemplary service to the city for the past 5 years in
protecting and preserving the historic resources of Aspen. Ms.
Eflin accepted the proclamation and told Council the city received
another grant today.
CITIZEN COMMENTS
1. Ray Patch, Rocky Mountain Natural Gas, presented the city with
a check for $80,454.22; the franchise tax covering residential gas
sales for 1992.
2. Barry Siegel i nvited Council and staff to an open house
Wednesday, February 24 at 4:30 p.m. to view the private sector
affordable housing, Aspen Electric Subdivision. Siegel offered
his expertise in developing affordable housing. Mayor Pro Tem
Peters suggested Siegel approach the housing office with his help.
COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS
1. Councilwoman Richards thanked the streets and water depart-
ments for their extra help over the weekend and the community for
pitching in, shoveling sidewalks, and keeping pedestrian walkways
open.
2. Councilwoman Richards said she has received some comments
about truck loading zones that have been added to town. This is a
recommendation from CCLC and may not be satisfactory to the
businesses the city was hoping to help. Councilwoman Richards
suggested working with the ACRA on the loading zones. Mayor Pro
Tem Peters suggested a member from ACRA attend the CCLC meeting
when loading zones are discussed. Amy Margerum, city manager, said
this loading zone recommendation came out of a series of meetings
with delivery truck drivers, businesses and the CCLC. Mayor Pro
Tem Peters proposed staff accumulate the complaints about loading
zones and forward them to CCLC.
1
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
3. Councilwoman Richards respo nded to articles in the paper
regarding transportation work done by this Council and work being
done on highway 82. Councilwoman Richards said she empathizes with
frustration of everyone driving highway 82 without safety improve-
ments. Councilwoman Richards said there has been no attempt by the
city to hold up the highway or the four laning. Councilwoman
Richards said the newspaper implies the city has not been diligent-
ly pursuing funding for the highway. Councilwoman Richards pointed
out the city has been sending staff to Grand Junction and to Denver
working toward funding for the highway. The city has been told it
will take 15 years to get the funding to build the highway.
Councilwoman Richards said the city has been pursuing HOV lanes and
valley-wide mass transit in an attempt to work towards money that
does exist for road improvements, which is inter-modal transporta-
tion systems. Councilwoman Richards said Ralph Tripani has been
reassigned to this area and CDOT is taking this seriously as a
result of the efforts of Council and the Commissioners. Council-
woman Richards said it is important that the community continue to
pull together on the highway and transportation rather than
pointing fingers and creating anger. Councilwoman Richards said
when the EIS was not completed for this end of the highway, those
highway funds were used to build the Blue Lake and El Jebel
portions of the highway.
Councilwoman Richards said the entire funding changed when the
ISTEA legislation was passed. Without an EIS to cover inter-modal
transportation and PM 10, there will not be federal money spent on
this highway corridor. Councilwoman Richards suggested the city
communicate more about the work that has been done so far.
4. Councilwoman Pendleton said the mail-in letter in the
newspaper brings attention to four-laning of highway 82. Council-
woman Pendleton said a lot of things have happened since the city
voted in February 1990 to use city-owned open space across the
Marolt property for the direct connection of the highway. There
have been some stumbling blocks like the Clean Air Act and ISTEA
legislation, which was enacted December 1991. The ISTEA legisla-
tion changed the way funding was looked at for anything with
asphalt on it. Without that legislation, the EIS and record of
decision would have been completed in 1992.
Councilwoman Pendleton said a number of circumstances have lead to
the EIS being dropped. There were weight limit problems on Maroon
Creek bridge; there was a memorandum of understanding with the CDOT
relating to the entrance of Aspen. Council went to Denver to hear
what was going on first hand. The CDOT told Aspen they need a
transportation plan for the entire valley. Council then started
building relationships with other governments up and down the
2
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
valley. In order to get funding, the valley will have to look at
multi-modal systems in a partnership forum. There is a coalition
of 17 elected officials Aspen to Snowmass to come up with a plan of
things to be done in this area.
Councilwoman Pendleton said the more people participate in this
process, the faster it will get done. Councilwoman Pendleton said
Aspen did not delay the EIS; there are a lot of reasons it was
delayed. The Council has insisted the EIS get going again.
Councilwoman Pendleton said the environmental impact study for
Basalt to the airport should be out in May of 1993 and a record of
decision in November 1993. Councilwoman Pendleton said the
Snowmass/Aspen coalition is working on getting money out of the
CDOT for needed improvements in the interim. Councilwoman
Pendleton encouraged everyone to work together on this problem.
5. Councilman Reno agreed and said it is not his intention to put
any stops to four-laning highway 82. Councilman Reno said he feels
there will be other solutions along the way which will make
transportation easier.
6. Councilman Reno noted that the recently adopted water policy
did not address natural disasters. Councilman Reno requested staff
look into adding something about natural disaster to the water
policy.
7. Mayor Pro Tem Peters requested an executive session to discuss
potential litigation of MCDC and the city's water service agree-
ment. Council scheduled this for March 3 at 5 p.m.
8. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said the department of transp ortation has
a plan to four-lane highway 82; it is not clear that they have the
money to pay for it. The highway relief may be a long time in
coming. There are also consequences of highway construction.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters said the taxpayers are spending $2 million of
sales tax funding a $4 million budget for the Roaring Fork Transit
Agency. The citizens have built a $7.25 million parking garage.
There are parking problems and a four-lane will make this worse.
Councilwoman Richards said the local governments have been trying
to find the common issues. Much of the work force lives down
valley. There are developments approved down valley that will add
traffic to the highway and add to parking problems in Aspen. There
are over 12,000 people riding RFTA buses daily at this time.
9. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he would like the financial policies
removed from the consent calendar and put on the next regular
agenda.
10. Amy Margerum, city manager, said during the recent threat to
3
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
the city's water system, the city staff pulled together, worked
with the county and did an excellent job. Bob Gish, public works
director, told Council this incident was handled very professional-
ly by the sheriff's department. Both Castle and Maroon creek
inlets to the water plant were simultaneously cut off. Gish said
staff should put together a disaster plan for the city's water
system. Larry Ballenger, water department director, told Council
the headgate is turned on at Castle creek and the crews are working
on Maroon creek.
Tom Stephenson, police chief, told Council there were additional
concerns about the water being held behind ice dams. Stephenson
said there are also skiers missing in the Taylor Pass area.
Stephenson told Council the police department is providing
assistance to the sheriff's office in responding to routine calls.
11. Amy Margerum, city manager, told Council Pioneer park is being
renamed Copland/Twining Pioneer Park. This has been researched and
the names have historic significance.
12. Amy Margerum, city manager, said the county has scheduled a
date with Cleary and Mosten to discuss funding the priority
projects outlined in the Snowmass to Aspen transportation plan.
This is February 25th at 2:30 in the library.
13. Amy Margerum, city manager, point ed out staff has recommended
changes in the right-of-way vacation policies; exhibit A regarding
the public notice procedure be deleted and the reference to
publishin g be deleted.
14. Amy Margerum, city manager, requested Ordinance #72, 1992,
Mocklin rezoning be tabled at the request of the applicant.
Councilman Reno moved to table Ordinance #72, Series of 1992, to
March 8; seconded by Councilwoman Pendleton. All in favor, motion
carried.
15. Amy Margerum, city manager, told Council the only change in
the housing guidelines is an increase in payment-in-lieu. This
will be on the next regular agenda.
16. Amy Margerum, city manager, requested a work session with the
arts groups be scheduled April 19. When Council gave the annual
grants to the arts groups, Council asked the arts groups to come up
with suggestions on how that process might be improved. Council
agreed.
CONSENT CALENDAR
Councilman Reno stepped down due to a conflict of interest.
4
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Councilwoman Pendleton moved to approve the consent calendar as
amended; seconded by Councilwoman Richards. The consent calendar
is:
A . Minutes - February 2
B . Resolution #11, 1993 - Johnson Hockey Camp
C . Design Contract Approval Phase II City Shop Master Plan
D . Resolution #12, 1993 - 1992 Budget Transfers
E . Vacation Policies - Public Rights-of way
F . Resoluti on #13, 1993 - Filter Media Removal and Replace
ment Contract
ORDINANCE #23, SERIES OF 1992 - Berger Annexation
Kim Johnson, planning office, reminded Council the first reading of
this ordinance was in December at which time staff pointed out the
need to incorporate a fisherman's easement. This language has been
inserted in the ordinance. Staff and P & Z recommend approval,
finding it is in the city's best interest to have planning control
over development and land uses on the parcel, which may be the
entrance to town one day. Ms. Johnson told Council any historic
landmark designation of the structure would not effect the state's
plan for the highway into town. Scott Harper, representing the
applicant, noted this application has met all the statutory
criteria for annexation. This parcel has been surrounded on 3
sides by city land and a community of interests exists.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing.
Les Holst said from a historic perspective it is valuable to bring
this into the city and will be an asset to the community kept in
its present state, if possible. Sy Coleman agreed.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
Councilman Reno brought up a January 20, 1992, letter from the
county manager relating to an article in which the applicant
described using historic designation as a way of obstructing the
entrance to town. Harper said Berger's intention are incorrect
from a legal point of view. Councilman Reno said he favors this
annexation because of the proximity; however, he is concerned about
what may happen if the highway were to come forward. Councilman
Reno said he will not let this annexation stop the highway.
Councilwoman Richards said she does not believe the annexation will
have any bearing on the highway work. Councilwoman Richards agreed
it is important to be able to plan this as the entrance to Aspen.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters concurred this will have little effect on the
highway. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said the applicant deserves his
rights as a voting citizen in Aspen. Councilwoman Pendleton said
5
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
she does not believe the motives for annexation are honest.
Councilwoman Richards moved to table Ordinance #23, Series of 1992,
until March 22, 1993. Motion DIES for lack of a second.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters moved to adopt Ordinance #23, Series of 1992,
on second reading; seconded by Councilwoman Richards.
Councilman Reno said he would like to see language added to the
ordinance noticing the applicant of the planning process and
transportation issues and potential for a highway coming through
this property. Jed Caswall, city attorney, said based on the
status of the law, there is nothing the applicant can do to stop
the highway.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters noted that this Council is not fully consti-
tuted and withdrew his motion.
Councilwoman Richards moved to continue this issue to March 22,
1993; seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Peters. Mayor Pro Tem Peters and
Councilwoman Richards in favor; Councilmember Reno and Pendleton
opposed. Motion NOT carried.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters said it is inappropriate to rely on procedure
to kill an issue. Mayor Pro Tem Peters requested Council table
this so that it can be heard with the entire Council.
Councilwoman Richards moved to continue Ordinance #23, Series of
1992, to the March 22 meeting; seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Peters.
All in favor, with the exception of Councilwoman Pendleton. Motion
carried.
Councilwoman Richards moved to continue Ordinance #24, Series of
1992, to the March 22 meeting; seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Peters.
All in favor, with the exception of Councilwoman Pendleton. Motion
carried.
ORDINANCE #83, SERIES OF 1992 - Child Care Investment Fund
Cindy Wilson, assistant city manager, told Council requested
changes have been made in this ordinance since they saw it last.
Jed Caswall, city attorney, noted he amended the section in order
to allow out of city residents serve on the investment committee.
Caswall asked if Council felt that was too narrow. Council agreed
they wanted these members to be Pitkin County residents. The
finance director will make final determinations on all investments.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing. There were no
comments. Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
6
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Councilman Reno moved to adopt Ordinance #83, Series of 1992, on
second reading; seconded by Councilwoman Pendleton. Roll call
vote; Councilmembers Richards, yes; Reno, yes; Pendleton, yes;
Mayor Pro Tem Peters, yes. Motion carried.
Councilwoman Pendleton moved to consider Ordinance #4, Series of
1993, in front of Ordinance #3; seconded by Councilwoman Richards.
All in favor, motion carried.
ORDINANCE #4, SERIES OF 1993 - Code Amendment for Parking in LP
Zone
Kim Johnson, planning office, reminded Council this code amendment
lowers the parking requirements in the LP zone from 1 to .7 parking
space per lodge unit. The .7 is consistent with other lodge zones,
CL and LTR. This proposed amendment also allows a reduction to .5
space by special review of the P & Z.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing. There were no
comments. Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
Councilwoman Pendleton moved to adopt Ordinance #4, Series of 1993,
on second reading; seconded by Councilman Reno. Roll call vote;
Councilmembers Pendleton, yes; Reno, yes; Richards, yes; Mayor Pro
Tem Peters, yes. Motion carried.
ORDINANCE #3, SERIES OF 1993 - Bell Mountain GMQS Allotments and
Exemption for Affordable Housing
Kim Johnson, planning office, reminded Council this ordinance
grants growth management allocations for 1992 of 10 lodge units,
future allocations of 10 units in 1993 and 2 units in 1994, total
22 lodge units. This will bring Bell Mountain Lodge up to 40
units. The site plan includes a parking garage for all parking
required by the newly adopted text amendment. Ms. Johnson said at
first reading Council discussed the resident occupancy for the 3
bedroom affordable housing unit was not sufficient to meet the
requirement of the code.
Staff met with the applicant and housing office to change the
restriction to category 4 with the caveat a manager could exceed
the income and assets of category 4. Ms. Johnson said the
applicants feel this will allow them to continue to operate the
lodge. This project meets minimum threshold scoring for GMQS for
the new development. Staff supports future allocations. There
have been no applications in the LP zone in the past 4 years that a
project of this kind warrants future allotments.
7
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Gary Wright, representing the applicant, noted LP stands for lodge
preservation and the application has tried to preserve this family
lodge. Wright reported the applicants have been involved with the
superblock and have made a financial commitment for the study of
this superblock. Wright said the category 4 three-bedroom unit
will be exempt from category 4 guidelines for an owner/manager.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing.
Sy Coleman asked if the passage of this ordinance will facilitate
underground parking in this area. Wright said it is a requirement
for the Bell Mountain Lodge to meet its parking and it will have to
construct underground parking.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
Councilman Reno asked if there is a good LP project next year,
could the city go back and utilize quota. Ms. Johnson said at the
time of allocation of projects, the staff would have to forward a
resolu tion to continue any unused allocations. Ms. Johnson said
staff has not done this in the past. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said
this is the first lodge project the city has seen in a long time.
Councilwoman Pendleton thanked the applicants for cooperating in
the superblock.
Councilwoman Richards moved to adopt Ordinance #4, Series of 1993,
on second reading; seconded by Councilwoman Pendleton. Roll call
vote; Councilmembers Reno, yes; Pendleton,yes; Richards, yes; Mayor
Pro Tem Peters, yes. Motion carried.
ORDINANCE #5, SERIES OF 1993 - 111 W. Hyman Residential GMQS
Allocation and Exemption for Affordable Housing
Kim Johnson, planning office, told Council this is the only
application for 1992 in the residential category and is only 1 free
market unit. There is also a one-bedroom deed restricted unit
proposed to be category 1.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing.
Sy Coleman asked about parking. William Griffith, representing the
applicant Snare, said there is a garage and parking on the rear of
the property and there will be a space for each bedroom.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
Councilman Reno moved to adopt Ordinance #5, Series of 1993, on
second reading; seconded by Councilwoman Pendleton. Roll call
vote; Councilmembers Richards, yes; Pendleton, yes; Reno, yes;
8
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Mayor Pro Tem Peters, yes. Motion carried.
ORDINANCE #6, SERIES OF 1993 - Appropriations
Dallas Everhart, finance director, told Council the ordinance was
amended to add an expenditure of $10,000 for the Aspen Snowmass
transportation. Another carry forward item is title search work
for the parking garage of $2,000. Everhart requested the ordinance
be amended to include $6800 for Kraut property, an addition of
$1800, and the carry forward funds for the Cemetery Lane under-
ground project.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters opened the public hearing. There were no
comments. Mayor Pro Tem Peters closed the public hearing.
Councilwoman Richards moved to adopt Ordinance #6, Series of 1993,
as amended on second reading; seconded by Councilwoman Pendleton.
Roll call vote; Councilmembers Reno, yes; Pendleton, yes; Richards,
yes; Mayor Pro Tem Peters, yes. Motion carried.
MAROLT & TRUSCOTT REFINANCING
Jim Curtis, housing board, told Council the housing board has done
long range planning on both Marolt and Truscott. The Board feels
it would be beneficial to refinance and buy-down some existing debt
to put these projects on a stable foundation. Curtis told Council
in 1992 Marolt was budgeted for a $20,000 deficit; it appears there
will be a $30,000 profit. Truscott was budgeted for a $5,000
deficit; there may be an $8,000 profit.
Steve Jeffers, Kirchner Moore, told Council if the city refinances
both Marolt and Truscott, they will be bumping up against the $10
million bank qualification criteria. A municipality can issue up
to $10 million of debt in one year; under that the bonds are bank
qualified. The bank can buy those investments and get a better
treatment of tax exempt income. Over $10 million, the bonds are no
longer bank qualified and the interest rate in the first 10 years
will escalate some. Jeffers said in order to keep this at $10
million, the city will have to pay into one of the plans. The city
would issue new advanced refunding bonds of $4,085,000 and pay in
the July 1 and part of the January 1 bond payments in order to
reduce the debt service $292,000.
Jeffers presented the refinancing, showing it through 2008, same as
the present debt. Interest rates are 2.54 to 5.65 percent. The
savings in the first year would be about $303,000; however, this
should be weighed against the $292,000 that would be paid in. The
city would save overall $525,000 with this program on a future
value basis and $226,000 on a present value basis. This is net of
9
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
all issuance costs. Jeffers pointed out there would be an 11
percent per year reduction in debt service.
Jeffers said for Marolt the city would be issuing $5,915,000. The
city would be paying in a month early. The city would also pay in
$500,000 from the housing/day care fund. Jeffers noted the
interest on this debt is 2.45 to 6.20. The $225,000 the city would
pay in on March 15 would reduce the April 15th payment by $225,000.
There is a decrease in the bond payment between $50,000 to $55,000
annually. There would be a $191,000 savings at present dollar
value.
Dallas Everhart, finance director, said he would like to know if
there is general support from Council. If so, preliminary work
will be done at no cost to the city. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said
there would be a commitment to cash from the housing day care fund.
There is also the timing issue; interest rates are good right now.
Both Marolt and Truscott were loaded with too much debt at the
beginning. Councilwoman Pendleton said she supports this and would
like to see the overall picture in the housing day care fund.
Curtis said the housing board is prioritizing the activities
through the year 2000. Councilwoman Pendleton said the city has
nothing to lose by going forward.
Councilwoman Richards agreed she wants to look at the long term
housing projects. It is important to make sure the projects that
are already done are done well. Councilman Reno said refinancing
Marolt and Truscott does not seem to preclude the city from doing
other projects. Councilman Reno said he would like to act while
the financing is good. Curtis emphasized the need to get the
Marolt and Truscott projects on a sound basis. Curtis told Council
they are planning to convert 50 seasonal rooms at Truscott to long
term units as part of the long term plan.
RED BRICK SCHOOL RENOVATION AND MANAGEMENT
Amy Margerum, city manager, reminded Council the Red Brick
committee was to advise Council on the renovation of the building
and the management/maintenance of the building. The committee
members are Julia Marshall, Lee Ambrose, Jill Uris, Don Fleisher,
Janet Garwood, Bill Martin, Joann Lyons, Mary Martin, Janet
Roberts, Katherine Lee and Bob Camp. The committee recommends the
site be used for arts, recreation and compatible community uses;
the parcel should not be split or sold off for other purposes; that
the management of the tenant relations and day-to-day maintenance
of the building should be done by one entity; that Council should
appoint an advisory committee to review the operational aspects of
the building and to recommend capital improvements.
10
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
Renovation came down to two alternatives. The first alternative
was to do minimal health and safety renovation to the existing
building to meet UBC and ADA standards. This is not being
recommended to Council as the Committee feels the dollars necessary
to renovate the entire building would be spread too thin. Ms.
Margerum told Council the city has $1,000,000 for the renovation
plus savings as the bonding took longer than anticipated. The
committee felt that money should be used in the most efficient and
effective way. The committee recommends the money be put into the
gym and the newer part of building and fix that up to a higher
level and to demolish the older part of the building. This would
leave room for an expansion at a later date which would be funded
outside the city.
The committee recommends the property management and tenant
relations should be kept in one entity. Large capital improvements
would have to be approved by Council. The advisory group would
come to Council on an annual basis. The committee recommended the
Arts Council manage the building for the first year and that this
be re-evaluated after the first year. There is a draft of the
management agreement. The management entity will pay the city a
set amount per year which would go towards debt reduction or
capital improvements. The management entity would be responsible
for paying the day to day maintenance, insurance and utilities.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters asked how comfortable staff is that the
conceptual cost estimates are close to reality. Bill Efting,
assistant city manager, said these are conceptual and until the
project goes to bid no one will know exactly what the costs are.
Councilwoman Pendleton said she wants the city to get the best use
out of the available money. Councilwoman Pendleton said she would
like to give the Arts Council a chance to manage this building.
Councilwoman Pendleton said doing the entire building may run into
more costs than the project is worth. Councilwoman Pendleton said
the chances are better with alternative 2b than with 1 and it fits
within the budget.
Councilwoman Richards asked what the criteria for the selection
was. Janet Roberts said a lot revolved around the best use for the
space given the amount of money available. Ms. Roberts said it was
important to get the arts groups into the building as soon as
possible. Councilwoman Richards said it is difficult to put a
dollar value to future opportunities. By demolishing the 1941
portion a lot of opportunities will be lost. Councilwoman Richards
said she is very concerned about demolishing space that may be very
difficult to replace. Councilwoman Richards said she would prefer
to mothball the older half of the building. Councilman Reno agreed
with Councilwoman Pendleton. Councilman Reno said he has never
seen a use for the old building and questioned putting a lot of
11
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
money into the older half to renovate it.
Les Holst reminded Council about a year ago the HPC passed a
resolution that they would like to see the entire building saved.
This was put on hold due to the city's negotiations with the school
board to purchase the building. HPC has requested this resolution
be resurrected. Holst said this is not about architectural review
but is about community, scale and massing. Holst said demolishing
the older half would destroy 14,000 square feet of usable space and
the city would be putting money into a facility that is not big
enough. Holst said the committee has come to a consensus that this
is the correct place for an arts/cultural/recreation center and not
for affordable housing. Holst said the committee should have been
given the direction to make the project work with the budget given.
Sy Coleman asked if there is criteria for eligibility to use this
space. Ms. Margerum said the committee did put together a criteria
for eligibility. After the alternative for the building is chosen,
this can be worked on with the advisory committee and arts council.
The objective is to take care of arts and recreation. Councilman
Reno asked if there is a break down on renovation between the 1971
and 1941 buildings. Ms. Roberts said the committee did not ask for
that cost.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he feels the construction numbers in this
report are very preliminary, as the large contingency number shows.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he feels the HPC should be consulted on
this as this is not just a financial decision. Mayor Pro Tem
Peters said the voters voted on preserving a historic context.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he does not feel a second floor should be
put on this building. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he would like the
construction numbers refined. Ms. Margerum said it is difficult to
get better numbers without going out to bid. The numbers have been
reviewed both by staff and people on the committee with construc-
tion experience. Ms. Margerum there are some costs that can be cut
out, like tenant painting or floor finishing.
Councilman Reno said if this goes to HPC he would like them to look
at historic context, not the structure itself. Councilwoman
Richards supports having HPC review this. Councilwoman Pendleton
said it is a duplication to reopen the vote on this issue.
Councilwoman Pendleton said she would consult the HPC but does not
want to open up the entire issue again. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said
this should be reviewed by HPC if they think this is a significant
building in any way, size, materials, location.
Councilman Reno said he feels the Arts Council should be given the
chance to take the master lease and sub-lease to other users the
first year. Councilwoman Richards and Councilwoman Pendleton
12
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
agreed. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said having the Arts Council manage
the building has been a ground rule since the beginning. Coleman
said he would like to see the Council come up with guidelines for
whom this building was meant.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters suggested the city put out an RFP for a 3
phased architectural program including renovating the entire
building; renovating the newer part and mothballing the older part;
and alternative 2B. Ms. Margerum said the recommendation in the
memorandum is to spend the budget renovating the new part of the
building and not demolish the old part until there is a plan for
the entire building. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he is interested in
finding out more about this recommendation.
Councilman Reno said his concern is where the money is going.
Alternative 1 is $40/square foot; alternative 2B is $50/square foot
for renovation. Councilman Reno said he feels $50/square foot may
be low; there may be problems with costs no matter which option is
chosen. Councilwoman Richards said she does not understand why the
city would spend $100,000 to get rid of the old portion of the
building. Councilman Reno said there will be some costs in
mothballing the old portion. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said he is
interested in the costs of mothballing the old building. He would
also like to hear the recommendations of HPC. Efting suggested
staff get costs for mothballing the old portion including fixing
the roof on that portion.
Mayor Pro Tem Peters suggested Council put off a decision on the
different options until the entire Council is present. Councilman
Reno said in trying to do the entire building, the quality of the
product will not match the money available. Councilman Reno said
getting money on the mothballing option is a waste of time and
money. Mayor Pro Tem Peters said the committee has done great
work. There are questions Council would like some answers to
before they make the final decision.
Councilman Reno moved to adjourn at 8:55 p.m.; seconded by
Councilwoman Richards. All in favor, motion carried.
Kathryn S. Koch, City Clerk
13
Regular Meeting Aspen City Council February 22, 1993
OUTSTANDING EMPLOYEE BONUS AWARDS 1
..............................
CITIZEN COMMENTS 1
................................ ...............
COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS 1
................................ .........
CONSENT CALENDAR 4
................................ ...............
ORDINANCE #23, SERIES OF 1992 - Berger Annexation 5
..............
ORDINANCE #83, SERIES OF 1992 - Child Care Investment Fund 6
.....
ORDINANCE #4, SERIES OF 1993 - Code Amendment for Parking in
LP Zone 7
................................ ...................
ORDINANCE #3, SERIES OF 1993 - Bell Mountain GMQS Allotments
and Exemption for Affordable Housing 7
......................
ORDINANCE #5, SERIES OF 1993 - 111 W. Hyman Residential GMQS
Allocation and Exemption for Affordable Housing 8
...........
ORDINANCE #6, SERIES OF 1993 - Appropriations 8
..................
MAROLT & TRUSCOTT REFINANCING 9
................................ ..
RED BRICK SCHOOL RENOVATION AND MANAGEMENT 10
.....................
14