Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutagenda.apz.19960206 "~_.",..._.",-_.,"".,.....-~,-~."....~-,""^,,,.,, . c AGENDA ASPEN PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 6,1996,4:30 PM SISTER CITIES MEETING ROOM, CITY HALL I. COMMENTS A. Commissioners B. Planning Staff C. Public II. MINUTES ill. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Hernandez Conditional Use for ADU, Dave Michaelson - o...p(Jl'o vc.cL B. 820 E. Cooper Conditional Use for ADU, Amy Amidon (continued from January 16, 1996)-Q.pprZl~l{ IV. NEW BUSINESS A. Show Cause - Buckhorn Lodge, David Hoefer) den.cd.. V. WORK SESSION A. Public Hearing Procedure, Attorney's Office VI. ADJOURN MEMORANDUM TO: Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission FROM: Rhonda Harris, Administrative Assistant RE: Upcoming Agendas DATE: February 6, 1996 February 20 - Regular Meeting 616 W. Main - Landmark Designation (AA) (tabled from January 16, 1996) 918 E. Cooper - Landmark Designation / Public Hearing MEMORANDUM TO: Planning and Zoning Commission THRU: Dave Michaelson, Deputy Community Development Director t,AA, RE: Hernandez Conditional Use Review For an two Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) - Public Hearing DATE: February 6th, 1996 SUMMARY: The applicant is requesting conditional use approval to construct two ADUs located with a main house and guest house on two separate legal parcels. The main house ADU is a below -grade unit of approximately 478 square feet, and the guest house ADU is approximately 500 square feet on the ground floor. The application packet is attached as Exhibit A. Staff recommends approval of the conditional use for an accessory dwelling unit with conditions. APPLICANT: Noelle and Cecil Hernandez, represented by Lipkin -Warner Design Partnership LOCATION: 220 West Gillespie (Lots 35, 36 and 37, Block 90, Hallams Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen) ZONING: R-6 LOT SIZE: Lot A (Main House) = 24,089 s.f. Lot B (Guest House) = 9,975 s.f. FAR: Lot A Lot B Allowed = 4,269 s.f. Allowed = 3,282 s.f. Proposed = 4,122 s.f. Proposed = 2,150 s.f. BACKGROUND: The Planning and Zoning Commission has reviewed the project several times including a lot split ("Moore Lot Split") and most recently a Stream Margin Review for both houses. In addition, the design component of both structures have been approved per Ordinance 30. REFERRAL COMMENTS: Please see comments from the Parks Department, the Housing Office, and the Engineering Department (See Exhibit B). Parks Department: Parks Department staff had previously commented on the Stream Margin Review. Comments included conditions that any removal of trees will require a tree removal/relocation permit. In addition, conditions of approval required that all remaining trees must be protected during construction with no encroachment of the driplines during -excavation. Engineering Department: Engineering requested that final development plans must show easements to ensure no encroachments. In addition, parking spaces should be required for the ADUs due to the on -street parking problems in the West End. The driveway design must be modified to meet City Code. :, Housing Office: The Housing Office has reviewed the project, and had the following comments: (1) The unit in the Guest House is supported in terms of size and location. (2) The unit in the Main House is recommended for denial based on the location of window wells for ' available light. Since the initial referral, the applicant has revised the lightwells and entrance design to address the Housing Office concerns. Cindy Christensen's memo approving these revisions are attached as Exhibit C. Revised design for the Main House unit is attached as Exhibit D. STAFF COMMENTS: Conditional Use Review - Pursuant to Section 24-7-304, the criteria for a conditional use review are as follows: A. The conditional use is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives and standards of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan, and with the intent of the Zone District in which it is purposed to be located; RESPONSE: A fundamental goal of the Aspen Area Community Plan is to "Create housing opportunities for 60% of the workforce to live up -valley of the Aspen Village Trailer Park". A short-term goal with the Housing Action Plan was to develop "650 new affordable housing units, including employee -occupied ADUs to achieve the identified current unmet need to sustain a critical mass of residents". Staff notes that an additional goal included the revision of the ADU program to require registration and deed restrictions of all ADUs. The ADUs, as depicted, exceeds the minimum net livable requirement of 300 square feet. The unit must comply with the Housing Guidelines and shall be deed restricted as a resident occupied unit for working residents of Pitkin County. The property is zoned R-6 (medium density residential). Lands in the R-6 zone are generally limited to the original Aspen Townsite, contain relatively dense development patterns, and are within walking distance to the central core. B. The conditional use is consistent and compatible with the character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and surrounding land uses, or enhances the mixture of complimentary uses and activities in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development; RESPONSE: The R-6 zone is a relatively dense zone district, which is appropriate for the development of ADUs. In staff s opinion, the proposed ADUs do not represent an incompatible use, and the location in the vicinity of the downtown core are consistent with long-term policies of community revitalization. C. The location, size, design and operating characteristics of the proposed conditional use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, impacts on pedestrian and vehicular circulation, parking, trash, service delivery, noise, vibrations and odor on surrounding properties; 2 RESPONSE:. Based on the revisions requested by the Housing Office, both units meet the overall objective of livability. The main unit has been significantly improved with the addition of north and south sources of light, and is now accessed by a covered descending stairwell. The guest house unit is an above - grade unit with an exclusive entry (see p. 14 of application) Parking for each unit is provided by driveway aprons in front of each garage, as well as head -in parking adjacent to the guest house. D. There are adequate public facilities and services to serve the conditional use including but not limited to roads, potable water, sewer, solid waste, parks, police, fire protection, emergency medical services, hospital and medical services, drainage systems, and schools; RESPONSE: No additional infrastructure is required for the ADUs above and beyond what is in place for the existing neighborhood. E. The applicant commits to supply affordable housing to meet the incremental need for increased employees generated by the conditional use; RESPONSE: The ADUs must be deed restricted for resident occupancy. If the units are rented, they must be used to house a qualified working resident of Pitkin County. - F. The proposed conditional use complies with all additional standards imposed on it by the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and by all other applicable requirements of this chapter. RESPONSE: The proposed units are required by Ordinance 1, and must be deed restricted. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of both ADUs with the following conditions: Prior to the issuance of any building permits, the applicant shall comply with the following: A. The owner shall submit the appropriate deed restrictions to the Aspen/Pitkin County Housing Office for approval. Upon approval of the deed restrictions by the Housing Office, the applicant shall record the deed restrictions with the Pitkin County Clerk and Recorders Office with proof of recordation to the Planning Department. The deed restriction5shall state that the accessory units meets the housing guidelines for such units, meets the definition of Resident Occupied Units and if rented, shall be rented for periods of six months or longer; and B . Kitchen plans shall be verified by the Housing Office to ensure compliance with specifications for kitchens in ADUs. 2. The ADU shall be clearly identified as a separate dwelling Unit on building permit plans and shall comply with U.B.C. 35 sound attenuation requirements. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy,, the Planning Department shall inspect the unit to ensure compliance with the conditions of approval. 9 4. All new surface utility needs and pedestals must be installed on -site. 5. The applicant shall consult the City Engineer for design considerations of development within public rights -of -way, and the Parks Department for vegetation species, and shall obtain permits for any work or development, including landscaping, within public rights -of -way from the City Streets Department. 6. Prior to the issuance of any building permits, a tree removal and mitigation plan shall be submitted for review and approval by the Parks Department. Tree removal permits shall be required for the removal or relocation of any tree greater than 6" caliper. 7. All material representations made by the applicant in the application and during public meetings with the Planning and Zoning Commission shall be adhered to and considered conditions of approval, unless otherwise amended by other conditions. RECOMMENDED MOTION: "I move to approve the conditional use for two ADUs at 200 West Gillespie with the conditions as outlined in the Planning Office Memo dated February 6; 1996". Exhibits: "A" - Application Packet "B" - Referral Comments "C" - Revised Comments from Housing "D" - Modified Plans for Main House ADU N - t�l 2) i'roj ect Location 24)o vim. 401 c.L. Ssf? E ATTACH a D L�ALI tESCOM l rM* (iraicate street t address, lot & block rim ber, legal clescription uhere ���) - Exhibit A 3) Present ZCrIi.rr_f I� " �Q .4) Lot Size LJM y ' 760Z. �1(o , 5) Applicant's Nauya, 20dress & Prom r -As ae N 0 C04 � 12 6) R.epresentative's Name, 20dress & Phtx� t �..•1 K WA A 2;IGs r 6v14 WT'A1E2SL4 t P 400 W • MA nV c9. SV I T e /00 7) Type of Application (please ct e k all that app1Y) i t Condltlonal Use Caxxptual SPA _ Special Reaviev 80,40 Greenline Sftr� Margin Final SPA F1ral PM .I'`�J-mta-m View Pla.i']e Subdivision _ .iun.i.zati_on Te�ct/I�.ap Amer»._.tzt Lot Split tIrJt Line - Adj USbDent . eb. `17b I2® 1/42 X17 Final Historic Dev- Minor Historic Dev- Historic Demolition Historic Desigraticn C-, 5 .A3lotme—rit 8) Desc rapticin of Eci.sti. uses -(number and type of e.,astai structures; apprcodmat:e sq- :Et-; rxmber of bectcocms= any p'z'vloLr-- aE)prOvalS granted to the prC)-( Y) vACoo AN r rICo u 9) Desca7iption of Develcpmeat Application A t2L3 01-hohlAi-w Ue-S �44AVMAMI qoljeC- 10) 1 tev you attactsed the follow rrr? fResponse to Attadmner2, M i n i m an amiss ion Ccxztents to Attactment 3, sp ,- is S�� ion con tents -�� to A 4, Reviev Standards for YOur- 1ppliC.tion w ATTACHMENT 2 ' Miniin.um Submission Contents - for All Development Applications All Development Applications shall include, at a minimum, the following information and materials. V 1. The applicant's name, address and telephone number, contained within a letter signed by the applicant stating the name, address, and telephone number of the representative authorized to act on behalf of the applicant. 2. The street address and legal description of the parcel on which the development is proposed to occur. NV 3. A disclosure of ownership of the parcel on which the development is proposed to occur, consisting of a current certificate from a title insurance company, or attorney licensed to practice in the State of Colorado, listing the names -of all owners of the property, and all mortgages, judgments, liens, easements, contracts and agreements affecting the parcel, and demonstrating —the owner's right to apply for the Development Application. 4. An 8 1/2" -x 11" vicinity map locating the subject parcel within the City of Aspen. S . A written descr iption of the proposal :and an explanation in written, graphic or model form of how the proposed development complies with the review standards relevant to the Development Application_ attach2.applications f f.z Ion R HERNANDEZ RESIDENCE Applicant's Authorization Letter Noelle and Cecil Hernandez P.O. Box 1045 Aspen, Colorado 81612 12/11/95 Aspen/ Pitkin Planning Department 130 S. Galena St. Aspen, CO 81611 Re: Hernandez Residence Lake and Gillespie Aspen, Colorado To whom it may concern, By means of this letter we authorize Lipkin Warner Design Partnership to act on our behalf in obtaining the necessary development approvals for our proposed residence at Lake and Gillespie Streets. ZZ CECIL . HEAN' DEZ-" l NOLv,E C . DEz 2 HERNANDEZ RESIDENCE Legal Description: -FIJ,AT rAT 01= THE `oUTHEAST (�QU%\RTcK OF T.-i: T' ;OKT�d Er�T 0�`-C�Ur`\KTTE,K 0; Sff�TCH 12 10 `XiUT'r-i, ,� tDS WEST OT,TH D T ,E INI 1.0i 5 TJ 3 7� I.oL K a�� H� Lr ,?✓1 r, DD I I I ON i� C I T �1' i , N fir':' �; �i ; OF r15f EN Off LOT-5 5 V b, 0! --�ZCK 2, LN C01viir ; Su51)1vI5iG��i, �,ND P�F:� 0GI I 1 Ef)f Air E-I,�`� ADJ/&CENT), FOL �ILOY/` Tr,� a�' ► HW�5T COFF, 0t= GG�INNING AT rZN 6l� Quo Or H,`\L1t�MI 5 ADDITI, WHCE THE En5T• Gf)E- '� �T�; CORN;- �Ei�Or S�,iO SDI ION 12 ( 195', E�)i;ZA�� Cif) f5E.A1`,'5 50UTH Er,�T 9 i I - I fEE T (�-� CALL . , _ J - .nFEE I7;1`A.JT 55F _; _ _ _ i Tt--; �E�E NCB-! O✓�3bICC' VVE ;, II O: r=;: � T. r 1CC (�iGt�L' �>• I PEGT- i ^ - .- �7'30T'Oo Ers T , 3 J r 1��i r-i C:�q ��'-O-OiI� / ��. 07 FP- cT�. FE Tr', E CG NO 52' cc) � Ti a 30 FEE-T,- ?�'07' CO" �,a5-i , 11� 60 FEE.T,, tCL7-' J ?J06' 00' LA51 / �_ 7. i=E E% . -- � ram. _- `{-�� 1_-. �..� i .- � �11 � C � ' �iJ • 2 r C �� GO / r = � i ---, t 7 -Tr-; 0 00 FED 70 TEE FOUNT o� ' T r i . � I-iu�����C 'r`r I ' r I , JC E5y . �; ��; '= .��; �` �•,T�P� F�,� ��`�I �Jf�i �'E.�; r.� � ! UGi = 5; �, CCL:�r��-.G� ►; = E COr-�, L-1--"E 3c Fq 130 HERNANDEZ RESIDENCE Disclosure Of Ownership: jr±i PON RCL CHK.G' ;1 Wx YaY 5 sYr i �C' :r. C U CfTi ] Aspen/Pltkin cuurnunity Develapr^,er.t Office 130 Soutj. Galena Street Aspen, Colorado 816.11 LAW Cf'F:Cli�S OF H-EivE_'�,Tl S. k=N �+JITc A -.PEN. c:rLea��o e�5r� r 1 �. E= ,, , ,,. - Decer,L 12, 1995 A.C, SC:! S l,4 i cc 2 (57G1 %2 r5151 ^, 1.:��J' 1 cll �iLc"1. 5.� '.1' v��: - — D_ - r--c, :r 1'fi;eGL -ee' tE'- f �� `j�� 1"icnsd tC ~t-� OColorado arzd hereby Cart.�.fies as fo1lo•:s Title tc Lots & B, Moores Lot Split according to the Plat tl.?meef recorded February 10, 1995 in .Plat Book 35 at Page 90, is vested in Cecil M. Hernandez and iNcell.e C. Hernandez. Mr, and Mrs. Heir1ande- acquired title pursuant to a Warranty Deed recorded on Jun8 231 1995, in Bop;', 784, Page 292 of the records of Pitkin COT--n tv. `�' tln :LS 5li���°C�ti t� a t�Pt a a.� .1 pa reser-�a�.icra recordead in Book. 55 at Page 21 a waterline easeztten-tt recorded is B`o'{ 51- ar Page 965 (said being fi e fF)et in width); i :nd ali easements and rictl:ts-of-way zn[ ct er �Lte.rs disclosed cn t:.e Plat of the property referred to above. 141-. a._ 14rs. Flernazdez have the right, as ow _ers or the praFe=tY, tc an f ,-)r the development conteruplatcd by t5is application. Please feel frame to call me if you have alcy further quest -ions. Very truly you, s , HER3EIRT S . Ki T-N PROF: SS=0Npi C0E -P0,RATICN By s F`"-'� Herbert S. Klein a HERNANDEZ RESIDENCE Vicinity Map G rC�r L� w Q Qti Q 44 o E c c� The Hernandez Residence: Written Description of Proposal: 2 - story, stucco, glass curtain wall and wood, single-family residence with a guest house of similar composition. Written Description of Compliance With Development Standards: 'A' - Consistency with the Aspen Area Plan and with the intent of the R-6 Zone district. This project is a single family residence with a guest house which will be used year-round as a permanent home for the owners. The project will also contain (and is the subject of this application) two (2) registered and deed restricted accessory dwelling units (ADU). Both of which contribute to the overall goal of enhancing the permanent community. `B' - Effect on the character of the immediate vicinity: The residential character of the existing neighborhood will be strengthened by the addition of permanent - year round - residences. 'C' - Effect on the surrounding properties: The immediate surrounding properties are all of residential use and will not be adversely effected by these ADU's. `D' - Public Facilities All public facilities are presently available on the site. 'E' - Affordable Housing This application is to provide two 'affordable housing' units. `F' - Additional Aspen Area Plan Standards. One of the primary policies of the Housing action plan is to promote the use of accessory dwelling unit programs. ATT ACC HE?.7 3 Specific Submission Contents: Development Application for*Conditional Use The Development Application for a._-.cond-. =ional use shall include the following.' V A- A sketch plan of the site showing existing and proposed Features which are relevant to the review of the conditional use application; and F�. If the application involves development of a new structure c_ expansion or exterior remodeling of an existing structure, proposed elevations of the struc- ture. f-'O LU LU L-U D-/ 7U N LU < < LU FLOOR PLAN APU - P&Z COND. U5E REVIEW to t is LU L-U D-/ 7U N LU < < LU FLOOR PLAN APU - P&Z COND. U5E REVIEW to t is Q i ITT, 1:20 i j SITE PLAN! ADU - P&ZCOND. USE REVIEW I ! r- f u W Z � Z •n AIR N 9 Y � Z V 1 G y � J ! l ! •fin. SOUTH ELEVATION ADU- F&z COND. USE KEVIEW f "kk II nioziN NOKTH ELEVATIk ADU - f&7- COND. USE. Rsz Jill ... to y '-'' •a��q7 '�d Yri � ..t t x .�` , M .. y E t !:� � ,7,. A ri �! 2 r' +. (✓$.may !'�' 1 ' +r` -..�.-C Y iJ� r 3 J y Z ,�.� z r T Y. •5 ��� Y � d ( 4 Z Ki ^� 4 TR �'k: •T °k�'/Y MC .ro"r;"W 5 i ;.. t k d f'S •r M q r C4'_'kYJ ��4 Jam` . ,-r CE550KY DWELLI� U LLJ < 04 ro 14) FLOOR FLi-' APU - P&Z COND. L i REVIEW P-i4 LLI z 'A cl, IL'All: ss� Fps err 11-2,,95 ry C"noNAL L6E ,Z,.w WEST ELEVATION APU - P&Z CON P ' U5E KEYIEW IK—Aim M M LU Mill CZ U LU LU < LU it NORTH ELEVAJ10" APU - P&Z CONO. U REVIEW P.-C40 DEC.14 '95 4:29PM P . 2 ; .� Exhibit B MEMORANDUM TO- Dave Michaelson, Community DevQloptnent FROM; Rebecoa Baker, marks D<tpartrneut DATE; December 13, 15 RE: Hernandez Rc sidonce - Hallum bake Fluff F. SA Reviow A I have mviewed the application subrrlitted by Lipkin Warner un behalf of the I1cmandez residence development. Thesubmitted landscape Flan does not sbow the size err species of trees to be rcmowd or relocated. While this information is not required as a corWitian of approval for this application, it is scrrlctimes helpful to the pmpw l.y owtcr to know the process of a tree removal perrnit in the planning stages. All ooniferoL s trees over 4 inches in diameter or deciduous trees over 6 inchus in diameter (both irxc;asured 4 1/2 feet above grade) require a free removal or reioWion petit prior to issuwice rzf a building pennii. Iftl-ie, permit is granted for the removal or relocation oft=s then t jose trees are required to he mitigated at comparable valtic,. The only other comment in relatioft to the plwi is that all remaining trc-us must be prctecled during construction to include no eaca,vilti.on within the driplim: of the trees. Particularly, those. sprizcc trees along the driveway on [he west and the spru e to the nmih of the guest house should have snow fencing placed around them to enst,re thoir protection during construction. k mandz.doc JAN 30 '96 10:09AN ASPEN HOUSING OFC P.1 i 7. i "4 "co TO: Dave Michaelson, Planning Office FROX: Cindy Christensen, Housing Office DATE: Caxivary 30r 1996 RE: HERNAND8Z REVIEW FOR AN ACCZS�ORY DW-ELLTNG UNIT parcel ID No. 2735-121-21-001 TSSUE The applicant is asking f or ipproval tor two proposed acceosory dwelling units -- one to be Iodated in the main residence and one in the guest house. BACKGROUND: According to the plans, thp unit located in the maiTI house is to be approximately 439 square feet and be in the basement of the main house, The other unit in the guest house ja to be approximately 500 square fast and is to be located on the ground f 10037, - -in with the snit located in the RECOIMNDATICK. There is no prob]e guest house. This is a nice sized unit *nd is on the ground floor. The Housing office would recommend approval Of this unit. The unit located in the main house �s to be located in the basement. The applicant proposes two light wells, one on the north side of the house and the other on the south side of the house. Although the light well on the south sido will provide light, it is to be covered by a grate and will have the porch covering part of it. There needs to be more natural light to this unit. The north light well could help if it is done move like a garden window as well as the south light well. Because.,of the above, th� Housing otfice would recommend denial of thiEi- unit has it is proposed today. Both kitchens must also consist of a minimum two -burner stove with oven, standard sink, and a 6-cubic foot plus freezer. It is hard to tell by the plans if the kitchen falls under this definition. Should the units be approved, deed resitrictions must be -recorded before building permit approval. Thij5 deed restriction can be obtained in the Housing Office. \refcvrft1\hernEmd.adu i MEMORANDUM To: Dave Michaelson, Planning Office From: Chuck Roth, Engineering Department e`�. Date: January 28, 1996 Re: Hernandez Conditional Use Review for Two Accessory Dwelling Units (400 W. Main St.; Lots 3-8, Block 2, Aspen Company Subdivision, aka Lots A & B, Moores Lot Split; Parcel ID No. - not provided) Having reviewed the above referenced application, and having made a site visit, the Engineering Department has the following comments: 1. Legal Description - Note that state statute requires that a legal description contain the name of the individual who prepared the legal description. 2. Easements - The application makes references to easements on the property, but the drawings do not show the easements for confirmation that no construction is proposed on the easements. If the application is approved, final development plans must indicate the locations of the easements with no construction on the easements. 3. Parking - The application does not fully discuss parking spaces nor request parking space waivers for the ADU's. The Engineering Department recommends that parking spaces be required for the ADU's because on -street parking in the West End continues to be a problem both for quantity and for snow removal. It is preferable to have an unused parking space on site rather than not to provide for parking on site and have development parking needs being met on West End streets. 4. Drainage - The approvals of the Moores Lot Split provided the condition that storm runoff design meet the requirements of Section 24-7-1004.C.4(f) of the City Code. 5. Utilities - Any new surface utility needs for pedestals or other equipment must be installed on an easement provided by the applicant and not in the public right-of-way. 1 6. Driveway - The property frontage along public right-of-way is a length of about fifty-three feet (53'). The City Code permits a maximum driveway width of 10' for frontages of 60' or less. The final development plan must indicate a driveway design meeting City Code. 7. Landscaping in the Public Right-of-way - The final development plan must indicate proposed landscaping in the public right-of-way which must conform with City Code as discussed below. 8. Sidewalk, Curb and Gutter - The site is located in the West End where the Pedestrian Plan does not call for sidewalks. Due to snow conditions, the extent of curb and gutter in the area is unknown at this time. Prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy, curb and gutter must be constructed if appropriate and an agreement entered to construct sidewalk if required by the City in the future. The final development plans must indicate a five foot wide pedestrian usable space in the public right-of-way adjacent to the property. 9. Previous Approvals - Note that the approvals of the Moores Lot Split required that ADU's be provided on each parcel and that development be subject to ESA review. 10. Work in the Public Right-of-way - Given the continuous problems of unapproved work and development in public rights -of -way adjacent to private property, we advise the applicant as follows: The applicant must receive approval from city engineering (920-5088) for design of improvements, including landscaping, within public rights -of -way, parks department (920-5120) for vegetation species, and streets department (920-5130) for street and alley cuts, and shall obtain permits for any work or development, including landscaping, within public rights -of -way from the city community development department. cc: Nick Adeh, City Engineer Lipkin Warner Design Partnership, 400 W. Main St., Suite 100, Aspen M96.24 2 FEB 01 '96 08:51AM ASFEN HOUSING OFC P•2 Exhibit C SOU TO: Dave Michaelson, Planning Office FROM: Cindy Christensen, Housing Office DATE: EebrUa.ry 1, 1996 RE: HERNAN EZ REVIEW FOR. AT ACCESSORY UwELijYNG UNIT Parcel XD No. 2735-121-21-001 in my previous memo dated January 30, 1996, I recommended denial of the unit located in the ma.iri house . , The architect, Lipkin & Warner, have provided tie with new drawirigs of this specific unit. This is a much hetter floor plan and allows for more natural light to enter into the unit. I have provided you with the revised architectural draw ng5. Therefore, t wduld recommend approval o this unit also. , Again, bath kitchens must also consist- of a minimum two -burner stove with ovefl, ota.ndard sink, and a 6-cubic foot refrigerator plus freezer. it is hard to tell by the glans if the kitchen falls under this definition. Should the units be approved, deed restrictions must be recorded before building permit approval. This deed restrl.ction can be obtained in the Housing office. x e f arral\he mars . a4u FEB 01 '96, 09:51AM ASPEN HOUSING OFC Exhidit D Cl (s):n LUC N :z Lu C�j < MILM" :z 71P W Lu D" icNjwymew- -mwvl FUMMIRMN&M)c wricw Mim MIN bIr 64 I # -001 SAMMENT FLOOR ADU - FMC014P. u5E REYIEW FEB 01 ' 96 0B : 52AM ASPEN HOUSING OFC P . 4 W { 1 1 z L a i _ate rJ Ljj M Lu dA-m m� 161PA �MN ►YRiYI Pf ICi = �1�/7M 15VrF-LOOk PLAN APU - F8Z COND. USE REVIEW FEB 01 '9G 0e:52AM ASPEN HOUSING OFC P. 5 Lu u z LLJ LU T, tress AW- Ism OND. U$E rX-MEW FEB 01 '96 oe:53AM ASPEN HOUSING OFC Lu P. 6 fu uc z Lli z ui Ck Lu LJJ 4.) Z < < wa lr.4074 7m — tRA%M MddkE"a*Lum RDW Lwd k� APV - M=ND. USE FEB 01 '96 08:539H ASPEN HOUSING OFC i P. 7 Lu lT is APU - PAZ COME% USE in the basement of a new addition on the site. The net liveable area must be verified by zoning not to exceed 700 s.f. prior to the building permit application. The unit must comply with the Housing Guidelines and shall be deed restricted as a resident occupied unit for working residents of Pitkin County. B. The conditional use is consistent and compatible with the character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and surrounding land uses, or enhances the mixture of complimentary uses and activities in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development; RESPONSE: The RMF zone has greater density allowances than single family zones and can readily tolerate the proposed ADU. C. The location, size, design and operating characteristics of the proposed conditional use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, impacts on pedestrian and vehicular circulation, parking, trash, service delivery, noise, vibrations and odor on surrounding properties; RESPONSE: The roof above the access to the ADU will shed snow to the east. The ADU will have egress window wells for the bedrooms and high windows in the stairwell entry providing some natural light to the living space. The kitchen must meet the specifications of the housing guidelines. No on -site parking is currently provided. The redevelopment of the parcel will include two parking spaces inside a new garage. The application states that one of these spaces will be dedicated to the ADU. No other neighborhood impacts are anticipated. D. There are adequate public facilities and services to serve the conditional use including but not limited to roads, potable water, sewer, solid waste, parks, police, fire protection, emergency medical services, hospital and medical services, drainage systems, and schools; RESPONSE: No new services are required for the ADU above and beyond what is in place for the existing neighborhood. E. The applicant commits to supply affordable housing to meet the incremental need for increased employees generated by the conditional use; and RESPONSE: The dwelling unit must be deed restricted for resident occupancy. If the unit is rented a qualified working resident of Pitkin County shall reside in the unit. F. The proposed conditional use complies with all additional standards imposed on it by the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and by all other applicable requirements of this chapter. 2 MEMORANDUM TO: Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission THRU: Dave Michaelson, Deputy Director of Planning FROM: Amy Amidon, Historic Preservation Planner RE: Anson Conditional Use Review - Public Hearing DATE:, February 6, 1996 SUMMARY: The applicant proposes to construct a 2 bedroom 700 square foot accessory dwelling unit that is 100% below grade. The unit is proposed within a remodeled single family residence. The redevelopment of the property has been reviewed by the HPC as the parcel is an Historic Landmark. The proposal received conceptual HPC approval. Staff recommends approval of the conditional use for an accessory dwelling unit with conditions. APPLICANT: Wes and Susan Anson, represented by Jake Vickery LOCATION: 820 E. Cooper (Lot P. Block 111, Townsite of Aspen) ZONING: R/MF APPLICANT'S REQUEST: To voluntarily provide an approximately 700 square foot 2 bedroom accessory dwelling unit in the basement of a remodeled and expanded single family residence. REFERRAL COMMENTS: The Housing Office reviewed the 1/10/96 floor plan with staff. No outstanding issues are seen. Standard Housing Office conditions of approval shall apply. STAFF COMMENTS: Zoning staff has been in contact with the architect regarding the minimum required open space for this parcel. The site plan in this packet will be modified somewhat to accommodate a larger front yard open space. This situation is not considered an impediment for P&Z's review of the ADU. Any approvals by the HPC or P&Z shall be conditioned on conformance with the open space requirements or other applicable zoning regulations. Conditional Use Review - Pursuant to Section 24-7-304 the criteria for a conditional use review are as follows: A. The conditional use is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives and standards of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan, and with the intent of the Zone District in which it is proposed to be located; RESPONSE: The proposed accessory dwelling unit is proposed to be RESPONSE: The proposed unit is not required by Ordinance 1. The applicants are voluntarily constructing the ADU. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the ADU with the following conditions: 1. Prior to the issuance of any building permits the applicant shall: a. verify the net liveable square footage of the ADU with Zoning staff; b. upon approval of the deed restriction by the Housing Office, the applicant shall record the deed restriction with the Pitkin County Clerk and Recorder's office and forward proof of recordation to the Planning Department. The deed restriction shall state that the accessory unit meets the housing guidelines for such units, meets the definition of Resident Occupied Unit, and if rented, shall be rented for periods of six months or longer; C. kitchen plans shall be verified by the Housing Office to ensure compliance with specifications for kitchens in ADUs; d. verify compliance with RMF open space requirements with Zoning staff; e. indicate on building plans the one parking space dedicated for the occupant of the ADU. 2. The ADU shall be clearly identified as a separate dwelling unit on building permit plans and shall comply with U.B.C. Chapter 35 sound attenuation requirements. 3. Prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy the Planning Department:. shall inspect the unit to determine compliance with the conditions of approval. 4. All material representations made by the applicant in the application and during public meetings with the Planning and Zoning Commission and HPC shall be adhered to and considered conditions of approval, unless otherwise amended by other conditions. RECOMMENDED MOTION: "I move to approve the conditional use for 820 E. Cooper with the conditions outlined in the Planning Office memo dated February 6, 1996." ATTACHMENT: A. Plans and Written Application 3 I, TO: AMY AMIDON, HPC OFFICER FROM: JAKE VICKERY J A K RE: APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE T ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT 820 EAST COOPER 100 DATE: DECEMBER 6, 1995 POST OFFICTH E BOX 123 0 POST OFFICE BOX 12360 ASPEN,COLORADO81612 TELEPHONE / FACSIMILE This Conditional Use application is to be consolidated with and reviewed in conjunction( 9 7 0 ) 9 2 S - 3 6 6 0 with the Land Use application for this project dated July 27, 1995 and as subsequently amended and approved at a public hearing before HPC on September 27, 1995. Items referenced below as attachments are contained within the original application. (Attachment #, Item #) (2-1) see attached Owner's Authorization Letter (2-2) see attached Legal Description (2-3) see attached Disclosure of Ownership (2-4) see attached Vicinity Map (2-5) Compliance with relevant Review Standards: This proposal is to provide a 2 bedroom ADU in the basement of the proposed addition as indicated on the attached plans. There is an existing 1 bedroom free market unit now located at the rear of this property which will be demolished. The existing cottage structure is an historical resource. The new addition is placed below grade to reduce impacts to this historic structure and site. The proposed ADU will have a maximum of 700 net livable square feet and will accommodate 2 or more employees or an employee family. Please refer to other sections of this application for more detail regarding the proposed development. Currently there are three bedrooms and no on -site parking spaces. The total number of bedrooms proposed for this house is 5. A total of two parking spaces are provided for this development. Both parking spaces are located in the proposed garage. Pursuant to Section 5-510-A-1, one of the parking spaces will be dedicated to the ADU. This application is submitted with the expressed understanding that the deed restriction placed on the property as a result of the ADU approval will be the one in place at the time of submittal of this application. Please see Items 4A through 4F below for a more detailed explanation of conformance to specific standards. The proposed work is under review by the Historical Preservation Commission and additional information is available in the related Combined HPC Landmark Designation and Conceptual Review Application. (4-A) The Aspen Land Use Code permits an ADU as a conditional use in the ` RMF Zone. This application is submitted conditional upon this property being designated an Historical Landmark. Non -conforming Lot: The minimum lot size in the R.MF zone is 6,000 square feet. The lot in this application is 3,000 square feet. It is a pre-existing, non -conforming lot of record and the proposed development is permitted under Section 9- 106 "Non conforming Lots of Record" paragraph "C. Historic landmark". This paragraph exempts lots containing historical landmarks from being required to meet the minimum lot area requirement of its zone district for permitted and conditional uses. (4-B) The ADU provides an accessory residential use in the RMF Zone and a mix in a variety of housing types in the neighborhood. It is compatible with other residential uses in immediate vicinity. (4-C) The proposed location below grade maintains open space and minimizes the mass above grade. Light and air are provides by generous light wells. (4-D) Services will be an extension of the services already in place and are adequate. (4-E) This proposal will not generate any new employees and provides on -site housing for two resident employees. (4-F) This proposal conforms to the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and other requirements of the Code. RCHITECT NICKER` TO: AMY AMIDON, HPC OFFICER 100 FROM: JAKE VICKERY POST OFFICEUTH BOXING 12363 ` POST OFFICE BOX 12360 RE: APPLICATION FOR GMQS EXEMPTION ASPEN, COLORADO81612 TEI 820 EAST COOPER (9 7r0 )) 9 2 5A 3 t6 6L0 DATE: DECEMBER 6, 1995 GMQS EXEMPTION Request is hereby made for a GMQS Exemption by Planning Director pursuant to Section 8-105-a-ii-e-3 "Remodeling, restoration or expansion of existing single family or duplex dwellings" of the Aspen Land Use Code. The proposed development complies with this standard in providing no new unit of density. This Application for Growth Management Exemption is to be consolidated with and reviewed in conjunction with the Land Use application for this project dated July 27, 1995 and as subsequently amended and approved at a public hearing before HPC on September 27, 1995. (6-1) Description This request for exemption would allow an existing historical residence to be expanded in its existing location on site with its primary street facade unaltered and an ADU to be provided in the basement. New square footage has been placed to the rear of the site and subgrade to minimize impacts on the historical resource and site. Please refer to other sections of the above referenced application for additional detail on this proposed development. (6-2) The original application contains a complete set of architectural preliminary drawings. (6-3) The original application contains applications for Landmark Designation and HPC Conceptual Review. (6-4) Copies of recorded documents which effect this development: None. ' � •�. • . mil• Y • •:•I � y -� ,.. ,,,. .. ,�/ �;� , � lee E 6) t1.Ve Is I'IaIDe r 14�f�L2SS St r � jib /✓' 7) Type of LicatiAn (please ctecc all that amly) = j '� , cnditi Cw4nptual SPA Dev. Special Pevi ew Final SPA Final Fiisa- m is Derr_ 8440 Greer0jrwe Stream Margin ri _ PM Final EUD Minor Edstoric Dev. � His-torl�c L�nollti �i M✓antain View Plane Subdivi_si.m x I-Ij ric Designatij= . umization G'�S xuot meat Int Splitazt Lim. QQS �cn . Adjustmart 8) De =ipticsn of Existing Uses (n.mber and type of exist lg app radna e sq- :Et—; rx=ber of i . any dpmuvals T=ited tD the PrcpertY) - `�J i� l� r,� � ��i►1�'-�1 ��� ay�l `i�.� �,-r�'j �.1 �., Y1 ,r.;-t� 0,A 9) Des,-�---iption of Develcpmesit Application A nBILTI ERIM�� •) Have ycu attached the • • • 0 co CD U) co C) Lij o 0 C9 0 U, u > o U) C) 00 r-I '�3 .t .ti. �. .. .}il;r•�._,7.i.:)�kiiwtta'�.aU21�S�'u'SUz}r..Su1�1.tt..l•C....�. �2f.1:��1.�J w,=.,e�� w O to vino a�00 x0 0 00 �o� w w z O U w O ,, W 11.4 EE+ > x rn N z Ao a�po WHWr' x H O cn � U Z�aW 0W > ►n O W / w N�y < oaozAW c P., O IX4 fir �N rn O P14� �00 Uo r0 w' { Ow 4� Q RCHITECT February 5, 1996 Amy Amidon Aspen Planning Department 130 South Galena Aspen, Colorado 81611 CERTIFICATE OF POSTING RE: P&Z Review - Conditional Use for an ADU at 820 East Cooper. Dear Mary, I hereby certify that a sign stating all required information from the attached Notice of Public Hearing was posted on or before January 5, 1996. Sincerely, s Jake Vickery, Architect PO Box 12360 Aspen, CO 81611 100 SOUTH SPRING ST. #3 POST OFFICE BOX 12360 ASPEN,COLORAD081612 TELEPHONE / FACSIMILE ( 9 7 0 ) 9 2 5 - 3 6 6 0 RCHITECT February 5, 1996 Amy Amidon Aspen Planning Department 130 South Galena Aspen, Colorado 81611 CERTIFICATE OF MAILING RE: P&Z Review - Conditional Use for an ADU for 820 East Cooper Dear Amy, 100 SOUTH SPRING ST. #3 POST OFFICE BOX 12360 ASPEN,COLORADO81612 TELEPHONE / FACSIMILE ( 9 7 0 ) 9 2 5 - 3 6 6 0 I hereby certify that the attached Notices of Public Hearing were mailed to the addresses on the attached List of Surrounding Property Owners on or before January 5, 1996. Sincerely, lC� Jake Vickery Architect PO Box 12360 Aspen, CO. 81611 February 5, 1996 Amy Amidon Aspen Planning Department 130 South Galena Aspen, Colorado 81611 CERTIFICATE OF MAILING RE: P&Z Review - Conditional Use for an ADU for 820 East Cooper Dear Amy, RCHITECT I L 100 SOUTH SPRING ST. #3 POST OFFICE BOX 12360 ASPEN, COLORADO 81612 TELEPHONE / FACSIMILE ( 9 7 0 ) 9 2 5 - 3 6 6 0 I hereby certify that the attached Notices of Public Hearing were mailed to the addresses on the attached List of Surrounding Property Owners on or before January 5, 1996. Sincerely, I Jake Vickery Architect PO Box 12360 Aspen, CO. 81611 I 4 I r- tv rd rO ?+ J 4 C II C to - to w a) (1) tr ' 'L3 to res o to as ?, �, O O f4 Q I~ 4J O O I) O 0 a) C S4 O-1 U Q U C v) a) o- C t~ rn � . U O a) rd .14 tom, -14 II • •-A a) a) 'U � •,-q (a (6 a) C to c •,A Kc rn' ro w er U -t-) II a, V Q, C N ro V .Q �4 --4 (1) ro ^ A r-t a) (IJ to (d I I , , - r-t In � V U r-) U �� rZj 0) -Q " 01 r-A �p H .o O v] cVd p ' Q L7 a) 1 I I o U Fr; O• r-4 Q+ S i � cU J, a) 1~ O to • r+ U 'd �, J4 11 c, Rf �_, tort o K1: � " • r 1 a) II J >i U j a) �o 4-J -u ) O o C. � ° ^ [ 040 -Q v) o ° U o`� rl Mp, �+ p U.>i n () + -Q V o O U N con.� w cl + r-A o II r-i to a N w o 0 •-, to r t r t O I I ,, .,� ry s a o f, to ;� ' �+ t,4 ° cc3 00 `0 r-� ' to rti (1 3 �' cd rd y N rcS rtS to a) ul •0 u, (U o . u a� 3 a ( I~ a' : r� I) }j �' rO to � p l��f o U t%Ot�, c�3 'b a� (n r) to . ri O : O a) U r4 • V i n �UZQUw""' W ,•.r,�.caC�3t�pcdw�,+ '.N Q +q a� aQ ( , 3v H S4 V�4 J, .r-�-�i, u b rO ��' , o ( U I a) O H � 0, f (0 b U ° -C -+ (U °w~I .rn (1)) t 0 o O 'b -U D .,q W �>4 (1) 0� H O a) ✓i II `- O wW Cd W C t-. oA 0 t4 w En a-) �4 11) (ij `C5 v 11 w Cq a) � o .0pv,n °O C ' U) a)o o a , s4 w in (4 4 ° 1�4O w oU rU 11 rd F-f i r-+ . ~�,G o c II --1 H O �a)U Nas1N �)a, IQ -i 0 , rd Uo o ~ o t] Qo zo 0 0 Z 0, V a) a) ZW s•-0 0' II h r-U a) N ;a 0 pi � 4-► S4a 0 u ao 0 4-4 U)F, to I I H � rd rd a) OZ :•�� aa� , a� a� 3s~ Q ° ac�a ►-b [ a) N u w x U +a�� -rd wO U O � o (1) 0 r ems -a) �4 �4 U, n �° ° V o ta)•a Jr II a) w ONQa�WaV►Z•�i 4a= �•� 'asni U �a) -t-i' � IiI1IiI1 f�F-• Ww WHW �� aa) ~ a) �((a) G `r�3n �F�y, xaU.00-4 CCO o -U � 0 0 o d � ro `o rl, 2c*°c� •�, O a-) d UL4 �3tZ al -S 0 b o w rU 11 �, }VIINi4�O°U V�44� �r- ° b°c) U N o a) a) tr' a) O rd (N '0E4 .R(te,° O �,°�(3' o a)0 � o, � w�W;-0u ��u)P Cr404��'0a � ° o owi(10 1 a �4 in 0 q)4?+ $ � Pq V U 'Q cd a rd ?i O pQ O a) d to rd p 0 rCS �4 .!, °~ °� U ;14 V c�U a) ts,!oU 4' �,3o�r-uN o 4-' rQ U 04 O V0, Q,° jdo in a) o ,o ), o Q' w a) o .�p tn P4. rU 1: � Wp i40 O) p N O 0-0 ,., 2�04 V r-i -P ~U oA 04 , 0 c� � N }�4� w ), a1 4y o ,O^ H z3 a) rd j '.� 11 r + ?i H s~ O �� Oro a) t� ,..a '�4 ° a) w to -Q .0 • • O - v f •-1 F-1 '� • t' f,� a� 'd °� O a ! • • H (1) s a W �4 w II Q V • • E-+ '0 w a) r-1 Q, 4J f4 tr ro • a) rq 3 N W O O, V � !~ � w II r W O a) a) a) o w u) O w fi b- r - r--r t)' (Y, O 1 C', ebb v� �� a Z 4jrj) o rdw0 11 a,U Z3_QXu 0::CV 0 a) a,nr-i to U) u� AJAE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP A COLORADO PARTNERSHIP 1501 N. Pierce; Suite 112 Little Rock, AR 72207 "HERWIN, Greg �LKINS, Christine 1010 E. Hopkins Ave. #26 Aspen, CO 81611 SHERWIN, Gregory 1020 E. Hopkins Ave. Aspen, CO 81611 MIKI P.O. Box 444 Aspen, CO 81612 SEIFERT, PATRICA P.O. Box 2262 Aspen, CO 81612 SMITH, E. Sawyer, Jr. 835 E. Human Ave; Apt L Aspen, CO 81611 TAYLOR, JUDITH A. 616 E. Hyman Avenue Aspen CO 81611 KRANS, Gerald & Annette DORWORTH, Adrian #26 FOURTH FINANCIAL MORTGAGE CO P.O. Box 2694 P.O. Box 2385 Aspen, CO 81612 Venice, CA 90294 SHMIDT, Cheryl & Mary, Jack OLANDER, Michael R. P.O. Box 2768 Aspen, CO 81612 GOLDMAN, Michael & Gloria 1603 West Ina Road zcson, AZ 85704 SOMPLE, Penelope 3035 Calla Drive Santa Cruz, CA 95062 DAVIS, Harriet & Herbert 1050 George St; Apt 9M New Brunswich, NJ 08901 Martin, Galen & Mary Lou 5001 Hopewell Road Louisville, KY 40299 CADY, JOHN J. 8121 Killarney Court Wichita, KS 67206 ROBERTS, Marion & Tania 1004 Mopac Circle, Suite 21 Austin, Texas 78746 SKIPSEY, Charles & Eleanor 16839 Viade Santa Fe Rancho Santa Fe CA 92067 BELKOVA, Dasha Revocable Trus, HOKE, Christopher ABEL, ,Carlos & Amalia BELKOVA, Dasha - Trustee 5721 N. Country Club Terrace 523 Cragmont Ave. 1107 Landings Blvd. Edmond, OK 73034 Berkeley, CA 94708 West Palm Beach, FL 33413 KRANS, Gerald & Rosemary CHAPUT, Armond & Susan STENGER, Friederike & Walter FOURTH FINANCIAL MORTGAGE CO 3426 Westcliff Road South 117 Center Point Dr. Ste. 300 P.O. BOX 1069 Fort Worth, -texas 76109 Nepean ONTARIO CANADA Wichita KS 67201 K2G 5X3 KOUTSOUBOS, Ted 419 East Human Ave. Aspen, CO 81611 VAVREK, John R. 819 E. Human Ave; Apt. 4 ^Spen, CO 81611 BOONE, Mary Carol 2700 W. 35th Street Austin TEXAS 78703 BRANIFF, Carlos & Reha Bosque De Ombue 135 Basque De Las MEXICO D F MEXICO FINNEGAN, John & Sandra 84 Rilling Ridge New Canaan, CT 06840 HAYWOOD, Karen P.O. Box 12115 Aspen, CO 81612 Kartiganer, Esther 333 E. 53rd Street New York NY MCC GUBELMAN Indianhead Farms, Inc. 900 E,. Durant C 108 P.O. Box 623 Aspen, CO 81611 Mason City, Ia 50402 rt, Billy Jr. and Brumder, H. Christopher J. Analore Firstar Trust-Attn: Toby C/O Coates, Reid & Waldron 14th F1 720 E. Hyman P.O. Box 2054 Aspen, CO 81611 Milwaukee, WI 53201 Hedstrom Olof H. & Carolyn P.O. Box 4815 Asepn, CO 81612 Lampton, Julie M. P.O. Box 12111 Aspen, CO 81612 Meagher, Sharon E. P.O. Box 2187 Aspen, CO 81612 Weinrot, Edwin & Irene 0. Box 48128 Angeles, CA 90048 0128 Myers, Joseph V. Jr. 265 BRighton Road NE Atlanta, GA 30309 Quintenz, Kenneth & Susan 91 North Stanbery Ave. Columbus, OH 43209 Stacker, Lynne M. 694 Maple Park Drive St. Paul, Mn 55118 Meltzer, David B. 36 South State Street Chicago, Il 60603 Jones, Kelley & Kendal & Jones, John Kyle 1406 W. 13th St Austin Texas 78703 Wachtmeister, Edward Trust UTA 6223 Whitehall Farm Lane Warrenton, VA 22186 Thompson, Dennis & Sharon 314 S. Galena St., Ste 202 Aspen CO 81611 312009 Ontario Limited An Ontario Corporation 180 Steeles Ave. W. Ste 206 Thornhill Ontario CANADA L4J / ENSIGN, Beverly C. DELAPLANE, Muriel 88 Indian Springs Drive Forsythe GA 31029 KLIKA, Riggs & Yvonne 32415 Burlwood Drive Solon, OH 44139 PRICE, James & Julia 32670 Woodsdale Lane Solon, OH 44139 SCHUBINER, Craig E. 1600 Maddy Lane Keego Harbor MI 48320 CORREIA, John E. 6730 East Northwest Hwy. Dallas, Texas 75231 MCLAUGLIN William & Martha 14422 Industry Ave. 7674 Laredo Texas 78041 7948 GRUESER William & Patricia P.O. Box 882829 Steamboat Springs CO 80488 ASPEN DIRIGIBLES LLD NEILEY & ALDER - C/O 201 N. Mill St #102 Aspen CO 81611 Morse, William & Eudice 757253 Ontario Limited BOWDEN, Robert 14851 County Line Road Landawn Shopping Centers 1370 Mt. View Drive Chagrin Falls, OH 44022 LTD Aspen, CO 81611 C/O 11 Polson Street Toronto Ontario CANADA M5A lA Gordon, Marvin & Sylvia CARRILLO, Joseph & Anna Marie FRANCO, Vivian 25862 Hersheyvale 236 Henry Street 805 E. Cooper #7 "-inklin, MI 48025 Brooklyn Heights NY 11201 Aspen CO 81611 Kozlow, Robert & Carol Berkowitz, Karen & Alan LUSTBERG, MARTIN & Myra 6764 Knollwood Circle West P.O. Box 35 20 Deerfield Lane West Bloomfield, MI 48322 Brooklandville, MD 21022 Upper Saddle River NJ 07458 POLINE, Patricia A. CHAPMAN, COLIN LOGAN, Thomas J. 7 Ascot Manor 627 Rio Grande Place P.O. Box 6758 Atlanta GA 30327 Aspen, CO 81611 Snowmass Village, CO 81615 `�TACAR CORP. OVERSEAS LIEB, Madeline Trust 'ABLISHMENT LIECHTENSTEIN 800 East Hyman Ave. #A tZP. Aspen, CO 81611 380 Interstate Nortyh Parkway Atlanta, GA 30339 NOVO, Oscar & Maria Del Carmen HESS, Phyllis J. 13101 S.W. 70th Avenue P.O. Box 8582 Miami FL 33156 Aspen, CO 81612 AINSWORTH INVESTMENT, INC. MILLER, Jeffrey R. FIASSE, Christian - C/o P.O. Box 4625 3360 S. Ocean Blvd., Apt. 3E1 Aspen CO 81612 Palm Beach, FL 33480 KOHLHEPP, Robert 580 Chaswil Drive Cincinatti OH 45255 PILGRIM INVESTMENT SHERMAN, Jane & Larry = C/O '. Box 968 .ningham MI 48012 JACOB, Linda & ARnold 3000 Town Center #1780 Southfield MI 48075 Nellis, Chad P.O. Box 8144 Aspen, CO 81612 THRESHIE FAmily Trust part b THRESHIE, Judith H. - Trustee 181 42 Estes Way Santa Ana, CA 92785 LOST, RAymond H. II 6460 W. Greentree Drive Somis, CA 093066-9714 KATZ, Robert S. 1020 Waiholo St. Honolulu, HI 96821 LAW Glenn Eugene P.O. Box 2537 Aspen, CO 81612 ELDEAN, Herbet Trustee LEVITT, Madelyn M Herbert R. Eldean Trust LEVITT, Jeanne Eldean Shipyard & Yacht Sales 6001 Montrose Road Ste 600 Macatawa, MI 49434 c/o Nelli Rockville, MD 20852 Klein, Loanne G. 4045 Crestwood Drive Northbrook, IL 60062 POAG, Sara & Morgan PRICE, Janie 1006 Dover Road Greensborao NC 27408 BUTLER, Gerald & Marchita MULLINS, Billy J. Jr. & SandrE WATERS, Jospeh D. & Leslie 3740 River Pines Drive 17102 Club Hill Drive 5104 Oak Tree Circle Ann Arbor, MI 48103 Dallas Texas 75248 Dallas TEXAS 75287 OLESHANSKY, William & Marlene SEQUOIA Development Corp. BUTCH & SUNDANCE INVESTMENTS 4085 Winterset Attn: Stanford Stiles COMM HOLDINGS CORP - C/O West Bloomfield, MI 48323 4950 Woodway, #706 5575 DTC Pkwy Ste 360 Houston, Texas 77056 Englewood CO 80111 SELLON, Jeffrey & Jennifer 949 Forest Ave. Rye, NY 10580 COLLINS, G.D. 305 Majestic View Drive Boulder, CO 80303 BUTCH & SUNDANCE INVESTMENTS COLORADO CORP. 1400 28th Street Ste 1 Boulder CO 80303 BLITZ, Robert G. MCGOVERN, P.J. & Lisa PASTEL, Linda ANTONELLI, Joan 101 S. Third St. #360 COMM Holdings CORP - C/O 3423 Q. ST. N.W. Grand Junction, CO 81601 520 E. Hyman Ave. #302 Washington D.C. 20007 Aspen, CO 81611 RUSHNECK, Ronald Jr. COSBAY REALTY CO, N.N.Y f' C74/ % RUSHNECrN.Gary & Susan STENGER, Emil 480-South Broadway 28-11-210 Street Tarrytown, NY 10591 Bayside, N.Y 11360-2460 COHEN, Philip & liliana 35 Shaker Ridge Drive CANAAN, NY 12029 PAUL, Richard & Suzanne 1210 Inverness Avenue Pittsbur, PA 15217 MAGNER CHILDREN'S MINORS TRUST C/O T. Gerald Magner, Jr 1500 Sheridan Road Apt. 6F Wilmette, IL 60091 SHERMAN, Robert & Elizabeth 1025 Mistwood Lane Downers Grove, IL 60515 SHERMAN, James & Ruth LAUGHLIN, James 4032 Linden Avenue WEstern Springs, IL 60558 kolel'ov �OL19�%y�� i NORTH ELEVATION '- zreLs6 HEKNANDEZ GUESTHOUSE LAKE 5TREET A5PEN,CO I I L IPKIN • WAR►4ER DESIGN PARTNER5MIP 400 Wc:s Mein 5t-5u'i-,e 10C Air% Colorado B 1.6.1.1 Phone! 970.920.1142 Fax 970 '20WIro Sle- - I C) 1