HomeMy WebLinkAboutagenda.apz.19940906A G E N D A
ILANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
.ptember 6. 1994, Tuesday
4:30 P.M.
2nd Floor Meeting Room
City Hall
I. COMMENTS
Commissioners
Planning Staff
Public .
II. MINUTES
PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. 520 Walnut Landmark Designation, Amy Amidon
IV.- WORK SESSION WITH CITY ATTORNEY
V. ADJOURN
MEMORANDUM
TO: Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission
FROM: Suzanne Wolff, Administrative Assistant
RE: Upcoming Agendas
DATE: September 6, 1994
Overlay Special Review - September 7
Huff
Stryker
Allen
Special Meeting - September 13
4: 00 - GMQS Text Amendments with County P&Z (CH) (Council Chambers)
5:60 - Williams Ranch Final PUD, Text & Map Amendments,
Subdivision, GMQS Exemption, 8040 Greenline & Special Review (ML)
Regular Meeting - September 20
Independence Place SPA Designation and Conceptual SPA Plan (LL)
Aspen Youth Center SPA Amendment (LL)
Mountain Chalet Change in Use & GMQS Exemption (KJ)
MacCaskill Conditional Use Review for an ADU (KJ)
610 W. Hallam Landmark Designation (AA)
San Serrano Conditional Use Review (KJ)
Creektree Subdivision/PUD Amendment (ML)
Overlay Special Review - September 27
Raymond
Lusk - 904 E. Cooper
Chris Riding
David Brown
Regular Meeting - October 4
709 W. Main Landmark Designation (AA)
West End Traffic Update (Gish)
Morrow Stream Margin Review (KJ)
No Problem Joe Conditional Use Review for ADU (ML)
a. nex
MEMORANDUM
TO: Aspen Planning and -zoning commission
FROM: Amy Amidon, Historic Preservation officer
RE: 520 Walnut Street, Landmark designation- PUBLIC HEARING
DATE: September 6, 1994
-------------
SUMMARY: The applicant requests landmark designation of the
.property at 520 Walnut Street. There are two structures on the
site, a miner's cabin built in approximately the 1880's and what
appears to be a miner's cabin which has been very much altered and
added on to.
APPLICANT: Gretchen Greenwood -Ortiz and Michael Ortiz,, owners.
LOCATION: 520 Walnut Street, Lot 8 and the north half of Lot 9,
Block 3,'William's .Addition to the City of Aspen.
PROCEDURE FOR REVIEW: Landmark Designation - is a three -step
process, requiring recommendations from both HPC and P&Z (public
hearings), and first and second reading of a Landmark Designation
Ordinance by City Council. City Council holds a public hearing at
second reading.
HPC recommended approval of Landmark Designation 7-0 on August 10,
1994.
LOCAL DESIGNATION STANDARDS: Section 24-7-702 of the Aspen Land
Use Code defines the six standards for local Landmark Designation,
requiring that the resource under consideration meet.at least one
of the following standards:
A. Historical Importance: The structure or site is a
principal or secondary structure or site commonly
identified or associated with a person or an event of
historical significance to the cultural, social or
political history of Aspen, the State of Colorado of the
United States.
Response: This standard is not met.
B. Architectural,, Importance: The structure or site
reflects an architectural style that is unique, distinct
I
or of traditional Aspen character.
Response: This house is a good example of a simple
1
worker's cottage which has only minor alterations on the
interior and exterior. It is a traditional rectangular,
gable roofed Victorian structure and has double hung
windows and a front door with arched 1/2 1 ites which were
typical in that era. The clapboard siding appears to be
original.
Alterations which have been made to this structure are
the picture window on the south elevation and the
standing seam metal roof.
C. Architectural Importance: The structure or site
embodies the distinguishing characteristics of a
significant or unique architectural type or specimen.
Response: This standard is not met.
D. Architectural Importance: The structure is a
significant work of an architect -whose individual work
has influenced the character of Aspen.
Response: The architect or builder is unknown.
E. Neighborhood Character: The structure or site is a
significant component of an historically significant
neighborhood and the preservation of the structure or
site is important for the maintenance of that
neighborhood character.
Response: The house is one of three historic residences
on Walnut Street. Walnut and Spruce Streets once. formed
a small neighborhood which was directly adjacent to the
Smuggler Mine operation. This area undoubtedly served
as worker housing.
Today, the base of Smuggler Mountain is densely
developed, primarily as housing for local workers.
Preservation of the remaining Victorian structures which
are scattered throughout the neighborhood is important
in providing some reference to the type of mining era
development which once characterized this area.
F. Community Character: The structure or site is
critical to the preservation of the character of the
Aspen community because of its relationship in terms of
size, location and architectural similarity to other
structures or sites of historical or architectural
importance.
t
Response: This site is representative of the modest
scale, style and character of homes constructed during
the mining era, the community's primary period of
2
C. Architectural Importance. The miner's cabin structure
is a unique architectural type for the mining era of Aspen,
reflecting the lifestyle of the miner during the Victorian era of
Aspen.
E. Neighborhood Character. This cabin was probably at one
time in a neighborhood of many miner's cabins, that were used by
the miners close to the base of the Smuggler Mine. A few old
buildings are evident in the neighborhood. The preservation of
this building in this neighborhood would further maintain the
neighborhood history of the community of miners that lived at the
base of Smuggler Mine.
F. Community Character. The preservation of this structure
further preserves the mining history of Aspen.
'In closing, this building fortunately is in a pristine
historical condition. By designating this building as a
landmark, this building that reflects a particular history of
Aspen will be restored and preserved.
v
y i.
'ie
c
IM
s
�4
+
t,
! _. - . " », t.� a .r � •" i I ��. '.,\�,' \S�,I�!-i Z ���r�:�
Y
County of Pitkin } AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE BY
} SS. POSTING OF A PUBLIC HEARING
State of Colorado } FOR A PITKIN COUNTY
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
The undersigned, being first duly sworn, deposes and says as
follows:
being or representing an Applicant for a Pitkin County Development
Permit, personally certify that the attached photograph fairly and
accurately represents the sign posted as notice- of the public
hearing on this matter in a conspicuous place on the subject
property (as it could be seen from the nearest public way) and that
the sign was posted and visible continuously from the o'f? r� day
.
of i 19� to the L"- day of _ _ 19
(Must be posted for at least 15 days before the public �rig).
Subscri%�d and sworn tobefore
i9 me
this cday of
by
WITNESS MY HAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL.
My commission expires :
6 T4� t- /-�-
t N �� u 1 ic' �, �� t��
i/
Address ,/J �� ill
County of Pitkin >
> ss.
State of Colorado >
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC MAILING
OF A PUBLIC HEARING FOR A
PITRIN COUNTY DEVELOPMENT
PERMIT
The undersigned, being first duly sworn, deposes and says as
follows:
I F 6-KETCII--�Rl 7-1
being or representing an Applicant for a Pitkin County
Development Permit, personally certify that a public mailing to
all landowners within 300 feet of the subject property, ten (10)
days prior to the hearing.
Applicant's Signatur
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this day of , 1961
WITNESS MY HAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL.
ISSION EXPIRES:
tary blic's Signature
Address
0
HOMEOWNERS IN A 300 FOOT RADIUS FROM 520 WALNUT STREET
2737-073-00-019
ALICE_AND WILLIAM GRIFFITH
1700 BROADWAY SUITE 720
DENVER, COLORADO 80290
2737-073-00-011
DOUGLAS P. ALLEN
ALPINE PROFESSIONAL BUILDING
225 N. MILL ST. SUITE 210
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-08-001
BRIAN WEINER
C\O PMG
504 MILAN BLDG
SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS 78205
2737-073-00-031
STANLEY AND ROSE LAURISKI
P.O. BOX 803
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-074-90-101
DAVID CROUCH
101 MAPLE LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-90-204
KEN OAKES
204 COTTONWOOD LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-90-202
LESTER HAUER
202 COTTONWOOD LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-90-200
DOUGLAS DRISKELL
200 COTTONWOOD LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
J
2737-074-90-205
PATRICIA AND RICHARD SZEWZUK
2975 SEAHORSE AVE.
VENTURA, CALIFORNIA 93003
A
2737-074-90-207
BEVERLY ANNE CAMPBELL
207 COTTONWOOD LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-90-206
LEE MILLER
4909 S. ALBION ST.
LITTLETON, COLORADO 80121
2737-074-90-303
DAVID WEISS
P.O. BOX 11911
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-073-00-045
CLURE W. BENNIS
P.O. BOX 4618
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-073-00-051
DOUGLAS AND BARBARA SHEFFER
P.O. BOX 250
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-073-00-026
ROBERT L. ZUPANCIS
511 RACE STREET
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-00-025
MICHAEL ORTIZ AND GRETCHEN GREENWOOD-
P.O. BOX 10599
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-073-00-020
2737-073-00-021
2737-073-00-022
2737-073-00-023
2737-073-00-024
2737-073-03-030
ANGELINA M. GRIFFITH
530 WALNUT STREET
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
\0
2737-073-00-020
ESTATE OF JOE MUHICH
C\O ANGELINE GRIFFITH
530 WALNUT ST
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-00-042
JON BUSCH
548 RACE ST.
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-00-046
WARD AND ELIZABETH HAUENSTEIN
535 SPRUCE STREET
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-02-047
MARGARET ANN AND DAVID HARRIS
533 SPRUCE ST.
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-073-00-027
ELLA V. SKUFEA
P.O. BOX 124
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-074-90-308
MARY FRANCIS POWELL
P.O. BOX 9726
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-074-10-015
DIANE AND TONY RUTGERS
512 SPRUCE STREET
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-10-013
MAX AND ALICE VAUGHN
3221 E 1\2 ROAD
CLIFTON, COLORADO 81520
2737-074-19-001
JOHN ERSPAMER AND MARCIA POUTOUS
534 SPRUCE ST #1
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-10-031
JEFF TASSE
MARY MCGUIRE KELSO TASSE
C\O LINDA DETERS
2372 112 RD
CARBONDALE, COLORADO 81623
2737-074-18-001
DONALD LEE DELISE
P.O. BOX 345
WOODY CREEK, COLORADO 81656
2737-074-90-301
DONALD S. WEISS
P.O. BOX 11911
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
2737-073-66-201
ALAN GREENWALD
PINE BROOK TIRE CO.
295 CHANGEBRIDGE RD.
PINEBROOK, NJ 07058
2737-073-66-202
JOHN J. JR SARNO
MARY ANN MCQUADE
49 APACHE WAY
TEWKSBURG, MA 01876
2737-073-66-203'
JANICE BECKER
THOMAS RESTAINO
72 ALDER AVE.
SAN ANSELMO, CA 94960
2737-074-27-001
CENTENNIAL -ASPEN
A LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
100 LUKE SHORT CT.
ASPEN, CO. 81611
2737-074-90-208
CHARLES M. KELLY
DEBORA DYKES
00208 COTTONWOODS LANE
ASPEN, COLORADO 81611
2737-074-09-012
STEPHEN F. ARTHUR
P.O. BOX 4871
ASPEN, COLORADO 81612
�UNDAKER, GORDON S. REAL ESTATE CO
2458 OLD DORSETT RD.; SUITE 300
ST. LOUTS.) MO 63043
�~
BASS, RAlFIEL
------- - --'-'----
P.O. BOX 611
MAYNARD, THOMAS E.
,
��
ASPEN CO 81612
112 VINE STREET
--- --
ASPEN, CO 81611
��
HUNTER CREEK 1045 PARTNERSHIP
A MINNESOTA GENERAL PARTNERSHIP
----------'
4428 YORK AVENUE SOUTH
NICHOLS, MARTHA A.
MINNEApOLIG, MN 55410
P.O. BOX 3744
-- ----- - --'----------------^
A8PEN CO 81612
STANLEY, NANCY C^
'-------------- - --
950 N. KINGrG ROAD #120
CHAPMAN, HARVEY �. JR. AND RUTH J^
WEST HOLLYWOOD, CA 90069
5415 ENCINO AVENUE
-' ---�-- ' --- - ----------
ENCINO, CA 91316
LEONARD, LINDA UND. 1/2 INT.
CHAPMAN, KEITH, K A R E N & KATHY UND.
1/
8435 SOUTH "A" STREET
BETTIO, JACK A.
TACOMA, WA 98444
3875 RIDQEWAY ROAD'
LAKEHURGT, NJ 08733
��
-
MDK AGpEN ASSOCIATES
'
MERANZE, WALKER C/O
------ -'-----------------`
6234 PIDCOCK CREEK RD.
�
-. r
R.S.L. REALTYv INC.
v�
NEW HOPE PA 18938
1899 N"E. 164T11 8TREET
----------'- -- -- ' -------�
NORTH MIAMI BEACH FL 33162
MAGIDSON, JAY M.
°/
MAGIDGON FINE ART -C/O
------''-------------- '----
520 E COOPER AVE
PRYMAK BILL
, '
ASPE N CO 81611
1530 WEST 10TH. AVENUE -
------' -------- --
BROOMFIELD, CO 80020 ^ -
WOLOSHIN, MELVYN A.
'
WOLOSHIN, ROBERTA S.-
BOX. 7107
SMITH, NANCY RO8S
WILMIN6TON, DE 19803
_
��
`
P.0~ BOX 185
----'`------ ---`--'---- -----------
-- ---
FOREST HILL' MD 21050
��
WIMBERLY, THOMAS FELTON III
.
------ - -'-- - ------�
P.O. B OX 761
KENWOODv ,JOEL D.
`/
BIRMINGHAM, Al... 35201
2531 NW 59TH 8T
-
BOCA RATON FL 33496
BARNARD, WILLIAM C.
C/O ZAP HEALTH CLEANINy .'
--------
PO BOX 8313 /
HOUSTON, DOUGLAS J.
ASPEN CO 81612
�/
. .
1683 BOLTON
WALLED LAKE, MI 48088
PAULGON, W I L L I A M T.
^^
`
.L
Y�
P.O. BOX 7693 -. -
,
1ENER WILLIAM B. JR
. , . .
AIR HOST, INC.
^
°
TEXA8, STE. 2375
1355 LYNNFIELD ROAD; GUITE 205
LA 71101
MEMPHITN 38119
GEV�PORT `
\=/
JERRY
FREIv MURIEL
`
�
i.v MARC E.
J. BOX 50443 ~
P.O. BOX 2171
� `ATA BARBARA, CA 93150
ASPEN., CO 81612 ,
IENER WILLIAM B. JR
. .
GOLDHAMER, THERESA W. `
v
33 TEXAS; SUITE 2375
95 SOUTH JERSEY STREET
�REVEPORT LA
DENVER, CO 80224 `
BERNARD GUSAN
' ,
ITTNER GHIRLEY MARIE
,
'45 VINE STREET
563 BETHANY CURVE
�SPEN CO 81611
SANTA CRUZ, CA 95060 `
,
��'
�AC�ILL SUZANNE B. B
,
LAIRD, DR. LOMA L. `
�.O.BOX 2051
4920 NE STALLINGG DR.
)SPEN CO 81612 '
�
��
NACOGDOCHES, TX 75961 `
v
'ARKER ALE�IS
BYRUM ALBERT G JR
, ^ ^ ' ,
.
,
BYRUM, PATRICIA '.'
`g2 5 T H PL
1004 LEATHERWOOD CIRCLE '
�ERDALE FL 33312
/MART
INSVILLE, VA 24112
^ �
-qERMAN YONEKO 8UZUKI
i�/
CHRIGTENGEN, CAROLINE %.
A. BOX 7928
720 EAST DURANT AVE.
PEN v CO 81612
-
ASPEN, CO 81611
MENDELGON, MEL I.
HERMANv YONEKO SUZUKI
MENDELSON, ROBERTA L.
�.O. BOX 7928
5412 FRANCI8CA WAY
�SPEN CO 81612
A�OURA HILLS CA 91301
'
��
AI RICHARD TSENG-YU AND
- ,
MC CARTHY KEVIN J
- ' J.
- AI, BARBARA ELLEN
]731 E. VOLTAIRE
330 E. 38TH GT.; APT. 16J
3COTTGDALE AZ 85254
.
.
NEW YORK, NY 10016
.
.
~ARL8ON MATTHEW W.
~
RAUCHENBERGER CARL
,
`
,
�*
RAUCHENBERGER, MERILYN
1003 VINE
1480 LAKE SHORE DRIVE
- '
�SF CO 81611
BARRINTON IL 60010
' '
MC 'DONH A�, THOMAS G.
RICHARD ^
]ENNIN�S, M
��
�ENDELS, JOEL M.
340 W. 57TH EST. SUITE 10P '
1004 VINE STREET
NEW yORK NY 10019 \J
'
�SPEN, �O 816�1
i. R. J. PECK CO.,
RIDLING, JERRY B^
� NEW YORK G'EIII ERAL PARTNERSHIP
RIDLING, MIRIA
�
/ OGDEN ROAD
1110 STONYBROOK DRIVE
3)CARGDALE, NY 10583
NAPA CA 94558
,
' �
�ARRETT, WILLIAM A. AND
SANDERS, RICHARD ALLEN
�RIMIANI, MARC G. -
2029 CENTURY PARK EAST, 408
2041 BROOKHIGHLAND RIDGE
_OS ANGELES CA 90067
BIRMINGHAM, AL 35242
�
^ ' ^ ^
`OATES JOHN J JR
DIXON DONA J
^
\
�OATEG, MARY ANN
DIXON, KATHLEEN A.
:'.O. BOX 25277
924 VINE'STREET
]KLAHOMA CITY, OK 73125
ASPEN, CO 81611
�
1IRIN, BERNARD
HABBERSTAD, P A U L
�
,.O. BOX 7681
P.O. BOX 8091
�SPE- N, CO 81612
ASPEN, CO 81612
�
-1UNTTING,, 8TANLEY R.
8PEERv CHRISTINE
�
-4UNTTING, MARCARET A.
4655 PLEASANT RIDGE ROAD '
P.O. BOX 2894
BOULDER, CO 80301 �
A!PEN, CO 81612
�
----------''------------'- -'- ' -------
-ARSON, WENDY L.
~/
-----'- ---------'----- ---------`r
III UGEIII T, TH8MAS A.
.�
78 GLENN DEE RD.r #9
927 VINE`ST. .
4SPEN7 CO 81611
ASPEN, CO 81611
<EMP, CHARLOTTE LEIGH
KERR, MICHAEL K.
\
8OYD, MARY LETTA
,.O. BOX 7128
P.O. BOX 87
ASPENv CO 81611 -
A8PEN CO 81612
,
�
�ARDER FAMILY INSURANCE PARTNERSMIP
MOORE, THOMAS P.
�
�JALTERS, AMY CARDER - C/O
MOORE, TERRY L.
40 MULE DEER TRAIL
C/O 102 RAMA ROAD
ITTLETON CO 80127
- ,
BEAVER FALLS, PA 15010
�
-
-
.
-ADIN, LAWRENCE L.
��
PILATI, SALLY R,
,
,.O.BOX 11630
3704 MACKEY COVE DR
)SPEN, CO 81612
^�
PENSACOLA FL 32514-8152
�
' '
--------------''------- -- - -'----'-`
'lARCELO, RUEL O.
---------- - ----- --
LAPIN, RICHARD M.
7'--`
`
300 PUPPY SMITH; SUITE 205-204
'P.O. BOX 8313
�SPEN, CO 81611
ASPEN, CO 81612
8UNEVICH, PETER
JAFFE, NORMAN
8U1-4EVIC11BRI�ITTE
,
~/
J°
\m
�301 CRACKER BARF'EL
CORWITH ROAD
rn nm���
nnTncF `AmpTDN' NY 11932
MEMORANDUM
TO: Aspen Planning and -Zoning Commission
FROM: Amy Amidon, Historic Preservation Officer
RE: 520 Walnut Street, Landmark designation- PUBLIC HEARING
DATE: September 6, 1994
SUMMARY: The applicant requests landmark designation of the
property at 520 Walnut Street. There are two structures on the
site, a miner's cabin built in approximately the 1880's and what
appears to be a miner's cabin which has been very much altered and
added on to.
APPLICANT: Gretchen Greenwood -Ortiz and Michael Ortiz, owners.
LOCATION: 520 Walnut Street, Lot 8 and the north half of Lot 9,
Block 3, William's Addition to the City of Aspen.
PROCEDURE FOR REVIEW: Landmark Designation is a three -step
process, requiring recommendations from both HPC and P&Z (public
hearings), and first and second reading of a Landmark Designation
Ordinance by City Council. City Council holds a public hearing at
second reading.
HPC recommended approval of Landmark Designation 7-0 on August 10,
1994.
LOCAL DESIGNATION STANDARDS: Section 24-7-702 of the Aspen Land
Use Code defines the six standards for local Landmark Designation,
requiring that the resource under consideration meet at least one
of the following standards:
A. Historical Importance: The structure or site is a
principal or secondary structure or site commonly
identified or associated with a person or an event of
historical significance to the cultural, social or
political history of Aspen, the State of Colorado of the
United States.
Response: This standard is not met.
B. Architectural Importance: The structure or site
ref lect,s an architectural style that is unique, distinct
or of traditional Aspen character.
Response: This house is a good example of a- simple
1
worker's cottage which has only minor alterations on the
interior and exterior. It is a traditional rectangular,
gable roofed Victorian structure and has double hung
windows and a front door with arched 1/2 lites which were
typical in that era. The clapboard siding appears to be
original.
Alterations which have been made to this structure are
the picture window on the south elevation and the
standing seam metal roof.
C. Architectural Importance: The structure or site
embodies the distinguishing characteristics of a
significant or unique architectural type or specimen.
Response: This standard is not met.
D. Architectural Importance: The structure is a
significant work of an architect -whose individual work
has influenced the character of Aspen.
Response: The architect or builder is unknown.
E. Neighborhood Character: The structure or site is a
significant component of an historically significant
neighborhood and the preservation of the structure or
site is important for the maintenance of that
neighborhood character.
Response: The house is one of three historic residences
on Walnut Street. Walnut and Spruce Streets once. formed
a small neighborhood which was directly adjacent to the
Smuggler Mine operation. This area undoubtedly served
as worker housing.
Today, the base of Smuggler Mountain is densely
developed, primarily 'as housing for local workers.
Preservation of the remaining Victorian structures which
are scattered throughout the neighborhood is important
in providing some reference to the type of mining era
development which once characterized this area.
F. Community Character: The structure or site is
critical to the preservation of the character of the
Aspen community because of its relationship in terms of
size, location and architectural similarity to other
structures or sites of historical or architectural
importance.
1
Response: This site is representative of the modest
scale, style and character of homes constructed during
the mining era, the community's primary period of
E
ATTACHMENT 4
REVIEW STANDARDS: APPLICATION FOR HISTORIC DESIGNATION
1. WRITTEN DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL:
The property at 520 Walnut has a 12 foot by-20 foot
Victorian miners cabin located on the property. The miner's
cabin is original to the property, yet it has been relocated on
the property a number of times throughout its history. The cabin
presently sits on a wood foundation, and it is our plan to add a
concrete foundation with red sandstone facing. The miner's cabin
is in its original condition with original siding. The only
alteration to the structure has been a new red standing -seam roof
that was added in the 1970's. Our intentions are to replace -this
roof with a more authentic material. The Historic Preservation
Commission would be reviewing my selection of materials. It is
our intention to have the cabin historically designated, as we
plan to move it on the site to a place where it will remain a
detached building from the new main house, that we are in the
process of planning. The relocation of the miner's cabin to
another location will allow the building to remain as a separate
structure and to be preserved in its original condition.
The proposed structure for historic designation must meet at
least one of the review standards for historic designation. This
cabin meets many of the following review standards:
A. Historical Importance. The miner's cabin is a principal
building to the mining era of Aspen. More than likely, the miner
who built and owned this cabin worked in the Smuggler Mine, due
to the proximity of the cabin to the historic mine.
B. Architectural Importance. The structure reflects the
unique Miner's cabin architectural style, one room building that
is unique to the history of the Silver Mining era of Aspen.
i
SIM
historic significance.
Recommendation: Staff and HPC recommend the P&Z approve
Landmark Designation of Lot 8 and the north half of Lot
9, Block 3, Willliam's Addition to the City of Aspen,
finding that standards B, E and F are met.
Additional Comments:
3
historic significance.
Recommendation: Staff and HPC recommend the P&Z approve
Landmark Designation of Lot 8 and the north half of Lot
9, Block 3, Willliam's Addition to the City of Aspen,
finding that standards B, E and F are met.
Additional comments:
3
ATTACHMENT 4
REVIEW STANDARDS: APPLICATION FOR HISTORIC DESIGNATION
1. WRITTEN DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL:
The property at 520 Walnut has a 12 foot by 20 foot
Victorian miners cabin located on the property. The miner's
cabin is original to the property, yet it has been relocated on
the property a number of times throughout its history. The cabin
presently sits on a wood foundation, and it is our plan to add a
concrete foundation with red sandstone facing. The miner's cabin
is in its original condition with original siding. The only
alteration to the structure has been a new red standing -seam roof
that was added in the 1970's. Our intentions are to replace -this
roof with a more authentic material. The Historic Preservation
Commission would be reviewing my selection of materials. It is
our intention to have the cabin historically designated, as we
plan'to move it on the site to a place where it will remain a
detached building from the new main house, that we are in the
process of planning. The relocation of the miner's cabin to
another location will allow the building to remain as a separate
structure and to be preserved in its original condition.
The proposed structure for historic designation must meet at
least one of the review standards for historic designation. This
cabin meets many of the following review standards:
A. Historical Importance. The miner's cabin is a principal
building to the mining era of Aspen. More than likely, the miner
who built and owned this cabin worked in the Smuggler Mine, due
to the proximity of the cabin to the historic mine.
B. Architectural Importance. The structure reflects the
unique Miner's cabin architectural style, one room building that
is unique to the -history of the Silver Mining era of Aspen.
C. Architectural Importance. The miner's cabin structure
is a unique architectural type for the mining era of Aspen,
reflecting the lifestyle of the miner during the Victorian era of
Aspen.
E. Neighborhood Character. This cabin was probably at one
time in a neighborhood of many miner's cabins, that were used by
the miners close to the base of the Smuggler Mine. A few old
buildings are evident in the neighborhood. The preservation of
this building in this neighborhood would further maintain the
neighborhood history of the community of miners that lived at the
base of Smuggler Mine.
F. Community Character. The preservation of this structure
further preserves the mining history of Aspen.
-In closing, this building fortunately is in a pristine
historical condition. By designating this building as a
landmark, this building that reflects a particular history of
Aspen will be restored and preserved.
-�- 7s!W Aso'♦
' Y 4 ter•
,
o
•
'
' , •; -71
' K
' yy
FJ
County of Pitkin } AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE BY
} S S . POSTING OF A PUBLIC HEARING
State of Colorado } FOR A PITKIN COUNTY
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
The undersigned, being first duly sworn, deposes and says as
follows :
I.. e;9eqOE" —7 -
being or representing an Applicant for -.a Pitkin County Development
Permit, personally certify that the attached photograph fairly and
accurately represents the sign posted as notice- of the public
hearing on this matter in a conspicuous place on the subject
property (as it could be seen from the nearest public way) and/that
the sign was posted and visible continuously from the o� ru day
.
+,w
of -5, 19`�� to the day of , 19
(Must be posted for at least 15 days before the public �rig) .
Appl ' A I s Si ure
z
Subscri d and sworn to before me
this day of 19�
by
WITNESS MY HAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL.
My commission expires:
� N u lic,�� ature
Address,4�
County of Pitkin >
> ss.
State of Colorado >
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLIC MAILING
OF A PUBLIC HEARING FOR A
PITKIN COUNTY DEVELOPMENT
PERMIT
The undersigned, being first duly sworn, deposes and says as
follows:
10, 61?�ET611�wy -77,
being or representing an Applicant for a Pitkin County
Development Permit, personally certify that a public mailing to
all landowners within 300 feet of the subject property, ten (10)
days prior to the hearing.
Applicant's Signatur
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 6E* day of , 19
WITNESS MY HAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL.
ISSION EXPIRES:IF
tary blic's Signature
Address
0
County of Pitkin } AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE BY
} SS. POSTING -OF A PUBLIC HEARING
State of Colorado } FOR A PITRIN COUNTY
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
The undersigned, being first duly sworn, deposes and says as
follows:
being or representing an Applicant for a Pitkin County Development
Permit, personally certify that the attached photograph fairly and
accurately represents the sign posted as notice of the public
hearing on this matter in a conspicuous place on the subject
property (as it could be seen from the nearest public way) and that
the sign was posted and visible continuously from the `%° day
of '-5 19 to the day day of�, 19
(Must be posted for at least 15 days before the public ari g) .
Appl ' nt' s Sic��n ure
,
(Attach photograph here)
Subscrib d and sworn to before me
this Wday of GG , 191
by .
WITNESS MY HAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL.
My commission expires:
N u lic',�, nature
Address ,c�5/t�'C�