The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutLand Use Case.HP.406 W Smuggler St.48A-89' 406 West Smuggler Historic . 406 06 s.w-71 4,4 Designation 2735-124-12-003 -- - 48A-89 i 8 61 /4 2 5-5 CASE DISPOSITION To: File From: Roxanne Eflin, Historic Preservation Planner Re: 406 W. Smuggler St. - Landmark Designation Date: August 15, 1989 On August 14, 1989, Council unanimously passed Ordinance 49, Series of 1989, officially designating 406 W. Smuggler as a historic landmark. Council also unanimously approved a $2,000 designation grant as well. HPC and P&Z unanimously recommended landmark designation during meetings in June and July of 1989. No conditions of approval were included. cd.406ws 'r Aspen/Pit kj~0impning Office 130 s-~. street aspe*~81611 August 28, 1989 -ir Christie Kienast 406 W. Smuggler Aspen, Colorado 81611 Dear Christie: Thank you for landmark designating your historic home. We are pleased to enclose a check in the amount of $2,000.00 from the City of Aspen. This one-time grant has been awarded by the City Council for the Historic Designation of your property. It is our hope that this grant will assist you in funding your exterior renovation plans. Your commitment to preserving Aspen's historic character is to be commended. Your property is significant to the overall historic integrity of this community and the State of Colorado. It is irreplaceable, requiring special sensitivity in areas of maintenance, setting and compatible design. We look forward to being of assistance to you in the future regarding the preservation of your historic resource. Sincerely, fp-- liAL * Ax Roxanne Efliin Historic Preservation Planner encl RE/sj 1tr.historic.grant.kienast PURCHASE QEER # PLEASE iNVOK.E: AGE . ;A Â·Â·I:. U 1 ..D U >D L â€ž i.3 f--4 i.... 1'.1 h i : -D CITY OF ASPEN i -i O t' - I Â·Â· 5 PHONE;#f /92 3' .z :- 9 SHIPJ-9: V (77.- -' th i LiNÂ·Â·iÂ·'2.-,./ Ur:' .. u .. 6..... 1 3 6 x SM,dGEL ..EL PLANNING ,Â·< 23541.â€¢IL. DEF- SHIP DATE: FO-Â·. PO APPROVAL DATE REQUESTED BY: Â©Â©C 9.-, zy-El REQUISITION #: VENDOR PHONE # REPRESENTATIVE'S NAME AND PHONE # VENDOR TAX ID # QUANTITY 1 UNIT 1 DESCRIPTION 1 UNIT PRICE ITOTAL Â· REMARKS: TOTAL PRICE $ n 67Â· 2 b. 3 Â· c Â·r $Â·'-f k . L.:/ PLEASE REFERENCE PO # . . .. -7 C, ON ALL SHIPMENTS, INVOICES, AND CORRESPONDENCE. THE CITY OF ASPEN SALES TAX EXEMPT NUMBER IS 98-04557 NOT A VALID PURCHASE ORDER UNLESS SIGNED FOR APPROVAL ABOVE. VENDOR COPY -- WHITE DEPT COPY -- YELLOW FINANCE COPY -- PINK 1 El 2./4 -El ~D USE ARFII(lTIal FUEN * 3733-- / 04-/2-003 . A 1) Project Nane \10Â»u- e Â¢ Clwi Je - A-,-, \CL f u.(ujr a.ul- CEL rn 1 6.& 2) Project Incation 406 0. 5 m u. cf gler Â·, LoU-Pâ‚¬ CA ,Ricc\Â£1 33, Â¢241 f W-wÂ·~9:U_,~4 A#un eu~A c 019. \6 ; V-1, ~%-lee.tr-%3, \\-0.Â§1,â€¢-.ul n-AA.-AÂ£.2.~. 10 6.4:, \curMsi U q.f Asp< n (incÂ£-cate street ddress, lot & block nmber, legal description where appropriate) 3) Present Zoning flo-C-ke v,U-9 4) Lot Size 23' K \ 07) 5) Applicant's Name, Address & Phone # C.-\nviÂ·Ste... A- p.- \CLâ‚¬-uas + 40(0 LI). SN-r'.U-C\1\â‚¬'<-, A-eeen, colo,-o-Xe â‚¬*Ilou . 563 - 92-5- %92/. 6) Representative' s Name, Address & phone # 7) Type of Application (please check all that apply): Oonditional Use Ooncentual SPA Oonoeptual IIistoric Dev. Special Review Final SPA Final Historic Dev. 8040 Greenline Conceptial RID Minor IIistoric Dev. Stream Margin Final PUD Historic Demolitian Mourrtain View Plane Subdivision X Historic Designation Condrniniumization Text/Map Amendment CM@S Allotment Iot Split/Int Line _ GMOS ExaIption Adjustment 8) Description of Existing Uses (râ€¢mher and type of existing struch Tres; approximate sq. ft.; number of bedroans; any previous approvals granted to the property). 11-Yv,~ ~vn t , \(Â£*70 15â€¢~.Â£*, diAL LAil- %-a.~,-wA-(Isa--3~ 0 ic.3/'.2/~J. A ALLU *A <. 94 ..9 6- 1.4,w \9< 90' s . ~ ~ 6-1/.A.A.- 9) Description of Developiiant Application 1/\000 1 7% [-77 CE-3 i 77 E- '3,;T , Â·9 2 ~ ill/j.)11 MAY-8 10) Have you att--1 -1 the following? til\\ 1 Respon= , 1 Attachment 2, Minimum Subnission Oontents 4 AA. D Response to Attachment 3, Specific Sulmission Contents --- AA O Response to Attachment 4, Review Standards for Your Application lin 2<*Â·:'~ <4~ ?1'0)~* r-2,Â·-lion*%~04444:Re~ Christie Ann Kienast 41. 0...'-1~#.â‚¬544*Â¢%Â¥*al 406 West Smuggler Aspen, Colorado 81611 4 May 7, 1989 Roxanne Eflin c/o City of Aspen Planning Office City Hall 130 South Galena Aspen, Colorado 81611 Dear Roxanne, I am landmark designating my home at 406 West Smuggler in Aspen. This letter is to request the $2,000.00 grant that I have been told accompanies such landmark designation. Sincerely, ULL'LA...A._QK_e_ ELLE_Le_ 44-L....Q.3_Jit LF Christie Ann Kienast t'Ir WY -8 <4 -Â·1 - 4-49 - *262â‚¬... :7,2.31:* ~lte#*93''fe)~*%-46.Â«~~.Â·c -i .' -~:Altâ€ž=r .. MEMORANDUM TO: Aspen Historic Preservation Committee From: Roxanne Eflin, Planning Office Re: Landmark Designation: 406 W. Smuggler St. Date: May 24, 1989 LOCATION: 406 W. Smuggler St., Lots P & Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen and Lots 16 & 17, Block 33, Hallam's Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen APPLICANT: Christie Ann Kienast APPLICANT'S REQUEST: Landmark Designation for the c. 1890 cottage at 406 W. Smuggler St. A Landmark Designation grant of $2,000 is also being requested by the applicant, which should be granted by Council at second and Final reading of the Designation Ordinance. HISTORIC EVALUATION RATING: "3" SUMMARY: This property will become Aspen's 97th designated historic landmark. PROCEDURE FOR REVIEW: Landmark designation is a three-step process, requiring recommendations from both HPC and P&Z (public hearing at P&Z level), then first and second reading (public hearing at Final reading) of the designation ordinance by Council. The designation grant is expected to be approved by Council at Final reading as well. HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION STANDARDS: The Standards for Landmark Designation are found in Section 7-702(A) of the Land Use Code. Any structure or site that meets one (1) or more of the standards may be designated as a Historic Landmark. Staff finds that the application meets both the criteria in both Standards E. (Neighborhood Character) and F. (Community Character). Standard E. Neighborhood Character: The structure or site is a significant component of an historically significant neighborhood and the preservation of the structure or site is important for the maintenance of that neighborhood character. Response: Located immediately adjacent to the proposed Hallam Lake district, 406 W. Smuggler is next to another designated landmark structure, and within a block containing .. two additional historic resources. The Planning Office finds that the preservation of this cottage is a critical element in the continued integrity of the West End neighborhood's historic character. The structure has received some modifications over the years to the front and rear, yet retains many of the original architectural elements and scale. Standard F. Community Character: The structure or site is critical to the preservation of the character of the Aspen community because of its relationship in terms of size, location and architectural similarity to other structures or sites of historical or architectural importance. Response: The Inventory file in the Planning Office states that the structure's architectural significance lies in its representation of a "type, period or method of construction". Planning Office records indicate the structure was relocated to the present site from its original location at 7th and W. Hopkins in 1973. We find that even though the structure's historical significance has been diminished due to this relocation, it is representative Of Aspen's Mining Era, illustrating the family/home environment of the average citizen in Aspen which was then dominated by the silver mining industry. RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Office recommends that the HPC recommend for approval Landmark Designation for 406 West Smuggler Street. memo.hpc.406ws 2 .. ORDINANCE NO. (Series of 1989) AN ORDINANCE DESIGNATING 430 WEST MAIN STREET, 406 WEST SMUGGLER STREET AND 210 SOUTH GALENA STREET, AS H, HISTORIC LANDMARK PURSUANT TO DIVISION 7, SECTION 7-701 OF THE LAND USE CODE. WHEREAS, Glenn A. Beck, as owner of the real property described as 430 West Main Street, Lots K, L, and M, Block 37, City and Townsite of Aspen; Christie Ann Kienast, as owner of the real property described as 406 West Smuggler Street, Lots P & Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen and Lots 16 and 17, Block 33, Hallam's Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen; and The Elks Club #224, as owner of the real property described at 210 South Galena Street, Lots K, L, and M, Block 94, City and Townsite of Aspen, have filed an application for historic landmark designation pursuant to Section 7-701 of the Land Use Code, and WHEREAS, the property at 430 West Main Street was listed in the 1980 Inventory of Historic Sites and Structures, as amended in 1986, and has received the historic evaluation rating of "3"; the property at 406 West Smuggler Street was listed in the 1980 Inventory of Historic Sites and Structures, as amended in 1986, and has received the historic evaluation rating o f "3"; and the property at 210 South Galena Street was listed in the 1980 Inventory of Historic Sites and Structures, as amended in 1986, and has received the historic evaluation rating of "Exceptional"; and, WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Committee recommended historic designation for 430 West Main Street and 406 West .. Smuggler Street at a duly noticed public hearing on May 24, 1989, and recommended historic designation for 210 South Galena Street at a duly noticed public hearing on June 14, 1989; and, WHEREAS, the Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission recommended historic designation for all three structures at a duly noticed public hearing on July 5, 1989; and WHEREAS, City Council wishes to pursue those recommendations and complete the designation process. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ASPEN, COLORADO: Section 1 That the property at 430 West Main Street, described as Lots K, L, and M, Block 37, City and Townsite of Aspen; and the property at 406 West Smuggler Street, described as Lots P and Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen and Lots 16 and 17, Block 33, Hallam's Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen; and the property at 210 South Galena Street, described as Lots K, L, and M, Block 94, City and Townsite of Aspen, be granted H, Historic Landmark Designation. Section 2 That the Zoning District Map be amended to reflect the rezoning described in Section 1 and the Planning Director shall be authorized and directed to amend said map to reflect said 2 .. rezoning. Section 3 That the Planning Director shall be directed to notify the City Clerk of such designation, who shall record among real estate records of the Pitkin County Clerk and Recorder's Office a certified copy of this ordinance. Section 4 That if any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or portion of this Ordinance is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof. Section 5 That a public hearing on the Ordinance shall be held on the day of , 1989, at 5:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, Aspen City Hall, Aspen, Colorado, fifteen (15) days prior to which hearing notice of the same shall be published once in a newspaper of general circulation within the City of Aspen. INTRODUCED, READ AND ORDERED PUBLISHED as provided by law by the City Council of the City of Aspen on the day of 1989. William L. Stirling, Mayor 3 .. ATTEST: Kathryn S. Koch, City Clerk FINALLY adopted, passed and approved this day of , 1989. William L. Stirling, Mayor ATTEST: Kathryn S. Koch, City Clerk ord.430wm.406ws.210sg 4 .. CASELOAD SUMMARY SHEET City of Aspen DATE RECEIVED: PARCEL ID AND CASE NO. DATE COMPLETE: 2735-124-12-003 48A-89 STAFF MEMBER: /â‚¬ E PROJECT NAME: 406 W. Smuqqler Historic Designation Project Address: Same Legal Address: Lots P & 0. Block 33 APPLICANT: Christie Ann Kienast Applicant Address: Same REPRESENTATIVE: Representative Address/Phone: 5-8921 PAID: YES NO AMOUNT: n/a NO. OF COPIES RECEIVED: TYPE OF APPLICATION: 1 STEP: 2 STEP: P&Z Meeting Date PUBLIC HEARING:J YES j) NO VESTED RIGHTS: YES NO CC Meeting Date PUBLIC HEARING: YES-3 NO VESTED RIGHTS: YES NO Planning Director Approval: Paid: Insubstantial Amendment or Exemption: Date: REFERRALS: City Attorney Mtn. Bell School District City Engineer Parks Dept. Rocky Mtn Nat Gas Housing Dir. Holy Cross State Hwy Dept(GW) Aspen Water Fire Marshall State Hwy Dept(GJ) City Electric Building Inspector Envir. Hlth. Roaring Fork Other Aspen Consol. Energy Center S.D. DATE REFERRED: INITIALS: FINAL ROUTING: DATE ROUTED: 3 - 1 -7 - 549 INITIAL: cb'~14<, City Atty City Engineer 3< Zoning Env. Health Housing Other: FILE STATUS AND LOCATION: .. MEMORANDUM TO: Aspen City Council Thru: Robert S. Anderson, Jr., City Manager 00>25 p=- From: Roxanne Eflin, Planning Office 34 Re: Historic Landmark Designation, Ordinance 49: 430 W. Main St., 406 W. Smuggler, 210 S. Galena, Second Reading, Public Hearing Date: August 14, 1989 SUMMARY: The Planning Office recommends approval of Ordinance #49, Series of 1989 on Second Reading, which combines three Landmark Designations in one Ordinance. The applicants for 430 W. Main and 406 W. Smuggler have applied for the $2,000 Designation Grant. LOCATIONS: 430 W. Main St., Lots K, L, and M, Block 37, City and Townsite of Aspen 406 W. Smuggler St., Lots P & Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen and Lots 16 and 17, Block 33, Hallam's Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen 210 S. Galena St. (The Webber Blocks, a/k/a Elks Building), Lots K, L, and M, Block 94, City and Townsite of Aspen APPLICANT: 430 W. Main St. - Glenn A. Beck 406 W. Smuggler St. - Christie Ann Kienast 210 S. Galena St. - The Elks Club #224, represented by Ed Irwin APPLICANT'S REQUEST: Historic Landmark Designation (Note: A Landmark Designation grant of $2,000 is also being requested by the applicants of 430 W. Main and 406 W. Smuggler), which should be granted by Council at second and Final reading of the Designation Ordinance. HISTORIC EVALUATION RATING: 430 W. Main St. - "3" 406 W. Smuggler St. - "3" 210 S. Galena St. - Exceptional These historic properties will become Aspen's 96th, 97th and 98th Designated Historic Landmarks respectively. PREVIOUS COMMISSION ACTION: All three structures have received .. HPC and P&Z recommendations for designation during meetings in June and July, 1989. HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION STANDARDS: The Standards for Landmark Designation are found in Section 7-702(A) of the Land Use Code. Any structure or site that meets one (1) or more of the standards may be designated as a Historic Landmark. Staff finds that the following criteria is applicable to the historic resources as noted below: 430 W. Main St. - Standard A. (Historical Importance), Standards E. (Neighborhood Character) and F. (Community Character). 406 W. Smuggler St. - Standard E. (Neighborhood) and F. (Community Character) 210 S. Galena St. - The Webber Block meets all six Standards, and is currently in the process of being nominated to the National Register of Historic Places Standard A. Historical Importance: The structure or site is a principal or secondary structure or site commonly identified or associated with a person or an event of historical significance to the cultural, social or political history of Aspen, the State of Colorado, or the United States. Response: 430 W. Main St.: Although we find that 430 W. Main is not "commonly" associated with a person or event of historical significance, in our research we have discovered the following interesting historical facts that relate to and meet this review Standard: a. The parcel was original owned by B. Clark Wheeler, town founder and the earliest "Wheeler" entrepreneur b. Referred to as the "M. 0. Berg" residence, it was originally constructed in 1892 at a cost of $5,000.00. Mr. Berg was the proprietor of The Mint (a saloon) in downtown Aspen. "At The Mint you could find the best wines, liquors, beer and cigars". Mr. Berg came to Aspen in 1885. c. The Beck family has owned the property since 1945. 210 S. Galena St.: The Webber Block was considered the third most important structure in value to be built in Aspen during the silver mining era. It was built for $40,000 by Henry Webber, who came to Aspen from the east as a shoe and 2 .. boot merchant. As his business grew, so did his prominence in the community. Webber was also responsible for the construction of his home, Pioneer Park (400 W. Bleeker) and the Webber Building (now the Isis Theatre). 210 S. Galena was the location of many of Aspen's service-oriented businesses, including the 1892 Aspen National Bank, Allan's Drug Store, attorneys, engineers, etc. The Post Office was located here from 1926-1959. The Elks purchased the building in 1912 for back taxes. Standard B. Architectural Importance. The structure or site reflects an architectural style that is unique, distinct or of traditional Aspen character. Response: 210 S. Galena St.: The Elks Building has long been considered one of Aspen's finest Victorian-era structures, massive in form and material, eclectic in design, and unique in detail. The Elks Building is a significantly distinct historic resource to Aspen's Commercial Core Historic District, and a visual landmark since its construction. Traditional Aspen materials (red brick and Peachblow sandstone) speak clearly to its heritage. Standard C. Architectural Importance. The structure of site embodies the distinguishing characteristics of a significant or unique architectural type or specimen. Response: 210 S. Galena St.: While traditional in Victorian massing and form, this structure embodies unique eclectic details making it one of a kind! The prominent corner entrance, topped with a projecting turret and corner dome with balustrade, and the lunette arch centered at the west elevation parapet are element which best illustrate the structure's unique style. The masonry craftsmanship is excellent; unique brick detailing (corbeling and "checkerboarding") appear between the upper floors at the predominant southwest corner. The cornice and parapet detailing are also significant details. The structure is a three-bay design, with a balanced fenestration pattern to enhance each bay and provide the upper floor rhythm. The storefront design is relatively unchanged, with the exception of the new windows recently installed for the main floor Esprit retail space. Standard D. Architectural Importance. The structure is a significant work of an architect whose individual work has influenced the character of Aspen. 3 .. Response: 210 S. Galena: We find the historic Webber Block clearly meets this standard. The structure was designed by architect William Quayle, who also designed the Italianate Pitkin County Courthouse, two of Aspen's most significant historic resources. It is interesting to note that both interiors have also remained relatively unaltered in 100 years. Standard E. Neighborhood Character: The structure or site is a significant component of an historically significant neighborhood and the preservation of the structure or site is important for the maintenance of that neighborhood character. Response: 430 W. Main St.: The Main Street Historic District, established in 1975, is considered as one of Aspen's most significant historic districts, primarily due to its high visibility and entrance to town. This structure is located within the context of this district, and is a contributing factor to its overall integrity. The preservation of this historic structure is a critical element in the continued integrity of the "Main Street" historic character. 406 W. Smuqqler: Located immediately adjacent to the proposed Hallam Lake District, 406 W. Smuggler is next to another designated landmark structure, and within a block containing two additional historic resources. The Planning Office finds that the preservation of this cottage is a critical element in the continued integrity of the West End neighborhood's historic character. The structure has received some modifications over the years to the front and rear, yet retains many Of the original architectural elements and scale. 210 S. Galena St.: The Commercial Core Historic District's integrity consists of magnificent structures such as the Webber Block. Aspen's very image is founded on these irreplaceable historic resources. We find that the preservation of this building speaks to the heart and soul of our community, and are very encouraged with the pending renovation plans. Standard F. Community Character: The structure or site is critical to the preservation of the character of the Aspen community because of its relationship in terms of size, location and architectural similarity to other structures or sites of 4 .. historical or architectural importance. Response: 430 W. Main St.: The Inventory file in the Planning Office states that the structure's architectural significance lies in its representation of a "type, period or method of construction", and that it contributes to the significance of an historic district. Staff finds this structure is representative of Aspen's early mining era and illustrates the family/home environment and life styles dominated by the silver mining industry. 406 W. Smuqqler: The Inventory file in the Planning Office states that the structure's architectural significance lies in its representation o f a "type, period or method of construction". Planning Office records indicate the structure was relocation of the present site from its original located at 7th and W. Hopkins in 1973. We find that even though the structure's historical significant has been diminished due to this relocation, it is representative of Aspen's Mining Era, illustrating the family/home environment of the average citizen in Aspen which was then dominated by the silver mining industry. 210 S. Galena St: Aspen's Commercial Core has a distinct character which is unmatched by most other resort communities. Galena Street contains eleven of Aspen;s most significant historic resources, their preservation is essential to the character, image and vitality of our entire community. The Planning Office commends each applicant for seeking Landmark Designation, and encourages the sensitive and careful renovation of these structures to insure their preservation for decades to come. DESIGNATION GRANT APPLICATIONS: Both of the applicants for the residential structures at 430 W. Main and 406 W. Smuggler have requested a designation grant in the amount of $2,000. The funds are proposed to assist in the costs of exterior maintenance and repair. The provision of the Land Use code, via Ordinance 42, Series of 1987, allows designation grants for historic residential structures rated "4" or "5"; a maximum of ten (10) grants per year. So far this year only two designation grants have been made, with less than six (6) grants expected in total. Both of these structures are currently rated "3". Both applicants have stated their interest in utilizing the funds for renovation, precisely the intended use for this incentive program, and are 5 .. very supportive of the historic preservation program in general. The HPC supports all incentives for historic preservation, and the Planning Office feels strongly that in the spirit of this incentive provision, designation grants should be awarded to these two applicants. RECOMMENDED MOTIONS: "Move to approve Ordinance 49, Series of 1989, on Second Reading." "Move to approve the $2,000.00 Designation Grant for both 430 West Main Street and 406 West Smuggler Street." CITY MANAGER'S COMMENTS: memo.cc.430wm.406ws.210sg.FR 6 C.Â«-41 C e a xl'--~ uÂ«.1- t le.- 406 /,5.,uvu#ed- - 91]6 \As#L /(~ \U-evl curÂ¥ i<Lal.4 e~,ute- IF-7*AT - 96 ,,Ckble<- c-i,5 /4.â€¢k\f,- 2&~~'*, 4.-N~ 4-6*d, <206<5:, S L~&l tO.#3. \C,~44,St. s ~~~~L,Lc40~~-CL ,~~~~-tc< . fss la- (= Q.if,6, a.â€ž Le A- - '2>cir 403 lo, A:,2.g-,L, Sido,L 2Â«e- h.2-ine<-- 52 5, '9*1,4- â€¢enont -tbr,, ASLUU, dEXL.,6-2.OCD 2. Ve-wry 'Lâ‚¬.1.0'ls - 40 Ake *484, U..,.:,h, COUUâ‚¬.us, Cu.1 A W W diuc.,4444'-*aer, 16-1 Fi<46 Ace.,LY (O(53 WAasoN-.1 ....t he.Ers- U,uÂ»-6.e ef WAa-son PULfs~-lrtist,Su&405, 10(5.G.L AÂ©c,Pirses,AeuÂ«,CA , atio I L.L.â€žde. A. Clâ€¢.34â‚¬ n, ccn -'E.sk. 9559, As.p' n, 9 \62,1 5.k,4-0. 0..fj Al.o_,Ac -F-,in\-He - 1.u:u,-6 C~-4- CR.da \no Cm- luu.-1 13-4)62<_.aAÂ·A.~.c LO.Â£46<4, -101 S , U, 944"16AÂ·.,-Reu,U-ucil\e, 4.r-4., -7/1 16 C_.L. axies Be--4-Â· beu~c - -Buk Sff 74- Al,ecu , 9'\6\1 - 34_,uil Câ‚¬-49 AA. 4.-6 K>a,QNe W+AL#ke- 39-0 Wt*â‚¬L Si-Â·, 7-~4~0Â«Â·, 560.2 LE La,t-(23, $=PuL.- -d . <305.9 *4561 0_06 â€¢-s, i<It Cr#Â£6 9.0c.VX)Â·r.) CjÂ·44,u, Co 904Â©l r~(~SC~Uâ€¢UL. ~Â·e--~~-*65: 6LC, C~2. -7~ '' (Ficto'UG,ac. 3 -v-Â«\J) - 2.13 61 N. E\Â§40Â·u- 10Â£., C...LU<.640.c-Ci\, 606 41 50~07 Wce.in + - Go\EÂ· A-eg--0 out. , As ek n C 9,0 0 4.Â©,1Â£. boo-~AG. st~) civol93 \26Â· c.tace. A -ze@2 - 244 L.Ae.,,Â·43*r, 7 8Â£44\\IRED ,C A, 902-,0 450% Wedc SM,\ c~ Ma,AL.*.6 ~UkÂ·â€¢â‚¬Â· M.e-it -/tvu=.Neâ‚¬ 0* 25&\L,uusÂ©o.-Â·t V-LLEâ‚¬~,ECD,< 10396, Â·Aspen, 35\4\2. k\. urr, / 457-58 (9<4, d.us.i,LA,zie <u<' lec-l., rtiÂ«ch**#,cA, C~\/2-5 ~1$2~~f~I:~Â£ - A-\ .L ~i~.5 - t --D u). '2.2_Â·r,e.s 63 E rA,uv--~-~ses . 450-1 -11401 24*uer,CO, %-010 -7 8el e 5 ~ 86& - 3 1 \ U.) . U) o Y 4-47 st , As *cu -- ..fu.(4=u*L-~ e 'Ejeu,Ae.Â£Â·S L.w-&6- .30 1 L.-Aâ‚¬- 4-i.Je,7 As Q.eu- .36.-a-u-a B-:-: 2 ,#+Kal.fa_.- 1 ,-c,-u\Â·ctÂ·L- hle g id Si, , 52u.*.6 C.36Â£,Â»Â·fles. <,6 U...u,- (Ules - <\Ct cl S, ~bÂ·v-00..Ai,Dcu~ ,--~Â·e,g.d Â«- , SOZOL. C.odd,Lpl nâ‚¬. Ca}Â·Ar-e, SuL & Bct, \7\& Co.-Arke)Ucui kee.,, U.U),,l.Da244~Ax~,bc.1 700Â®g 12-(*f,*io ;. 4\.ko-.Â».4,-2~<4; 24431 - 51--0 94 , s.4 . f:*s<*~.~ -.34ui.u.- 6 5640.,20*4 4; rh a_C~t,~-E kAÂ£- 1Aa~60 T,- 2- 00.5Â·tit~e,i~~~~r.br''LA ,(1g~ , CluDOt.kq ( 36-2>~0t.eye~(,L\D Â·IÂ·vz,~,ecx~-~) C_Stio~..ple, f -142*'& to'~ce\L - 1 44 120 u.) n,Â·r,l 6-i-, ,~~bÂ·o-4.-Ge/,- , CO, 9 03.-CS l u.Le -KU\A ACCE- - Clu.L-4- \1.0, 4\95 *064. 04.4- Etiki,, iolle>us-GÂ·u,Â·3 sc, -Inell ti C.â‚¬u. bliner ; BÂ£) i- 6 64 \, A-Spia 1 91612- '5846 Gnetu-u):>ed , 3.c. 4 u. ina. , A.i,pw- i 9,6 8 730 r., i St.-'i; 5-u3 622 9 , 12*2,9 5 96, AÂ·Â·s~~,.0u \U.4-vÂ·u-Â¥ Ua-\7 ry, -- 80% \3740, A.5 â€¢pen Â©6.720-6*u-, 9.\:50 10, B t.JÂ·.8 Gien BUA.1 (_A. CA , 90013 tu*Le Leeter, 50 *). ace.o... Flted., -?aL..ciel, .Â¥ta,, 3348-0 ' C Odu.Â£: O.-6-0_XÂ·<-Â·t (13-<Â·8*-, 3\\3 -t,3â‚¬.-06+40~ 8104,~ LA,CA , Ctoot) 6Â·-~.AJAL 0-6 441,-HA â‚¬>-eile 44 - -30 53 .. . -4 - -30.--2 0 15, 64 3 â‚¬ 0 4 962 00.-44 C.t , - Q.521 36....uix .. MEMORANDUM To: Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission From: Roxanne Eflin, Planning Office Re: Landmark Designation: 406 W. Smuggler St., Public Hearing Date: July 5, 1989 LOCATION: 406 W. Smuggler St., Lots P & Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen and Lots 16 & 17, Block 33, Hallam's Addition to the City and Townsite of Aspen APPLICANT: Christie Ann Kienast APPLICANT'S REQUEST: Landmark Designation for the c. 1890 cottage at 406 W. Smuggler St. A Landmark Designation grant of $2,000 is also being requested by the applicant, which should be granted by Council at second and Final reading of the Designation Ordinance. HISTORIC EVALUATION RATING: "3" SUMMARY: This property will become Aspen's 97th designated historic landmark. PROCEDURE FOR REVIEW: Landmark designation is a three-step process, requiring recommendations from both HPC and P&Z (public hearing at P&Z level), then first and second reading (public hearing at Final reading) of the designation ordinance by Council. The designation grant is expected to be approved by Council at Final reading as well. HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION STANDARDS: The Standards for Landmark Designation are found in Section 7-702(A) of the Land Use Code. Any structure or site that meets one ( 1) or more of the standards may be designated as a Historic Landmark. Staff finds that the application meets both the criteria in both Standards E. (Neighborhood Character) and F. (Community Character). Standard E. Neighborhood Character: The structure or site is a significant component of an historically significant neighborhood and the preservation of the structure or site is important for the maintenance of that neighborhood character. Response: Located immediately adjacent to the proposed Hallam Lake district, 406 W. Smuggler is next to another . 0 designated landmark structure, and within a block containing two additional historic resources. The Planning Office finds that the preservation of this cottage is a critical element in the continued integrity of the West End neighborhood's historic character. The structure has received some modifications over the years to the front and rear, yet retains many of the original architectural elements and scale. Standard F. Community Character: The structure or site is critical to the preservation of the character of the Aspen community because of its relationship in terms of size, location and architectural similarity to other structures or sites of historical or architectural importance. Response: The Inventory file in the Planning Office states that the structure's architectural significance lies in its representation of a "type, period or method of construction". Planning Office records indicate the structure was relocated to the present site from its original location at 7th and W. Hopkins in 1973. We find that even though the structure's historical significance has been diminished due to this relocation, it is representative Of Aspen's Mining Era, illustrating the family/home environment of the average citizen in Aspen which was then dominated by the silver mining industry. RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Office recommends that the Planning and Zoning Commission recommend for approval Landmark Designation for 406 West Smuggler Street. memo.pz.406ws 2 . PUBLIC NOTICE RE: LANDMARK DESIGNATION OF 406 W. SMUGGLER NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held on Wednesday, July 5, 1989 at a meeting to begin at 4:30 p.m. before the Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission in the Second Floor Meeting Room, City Hall, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen, Colorado, to consider an application from Christie Ann Kienast requesting historic landmark designation for the property located at 406 West Smuggler Street. This property consists of Lots P & Q, Block 33, City and Townsite of Aspen. For further information contact the Aspen/Pitkin Planning Office, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen, CO 81611 (303) 920-5090. s/C. Welton Anderson. Chairman Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission Published in the Aspen Times on June 15, 1989 City of Aspen Account 0 0 May 30, 1989 Christie Ann Kienast (also for Glenn Beck) 406 W. Smuggler St. Aspen, CO 81611 Re: Landmark Designation: 406 W. Smuggler and 430 W. Main St. Dear Christie: I hope you had a nice Memorial Day Weekend! I have tried calling a few times and have been unable to reach you, so... a letter instead! I wanted to let you and Mr. Beck know that we are progressing nicely on Landmark Designation for the two historic properties as stated above. The first step, HPC approval, went fine at the last meeting (May 24). The next step is Planning and Zoning Commission approval, of which the meeting is scheduled for July 5 (the earliest docket we could get on!). Since Mr. Beck is out of state, I assumed you would be assisting him on the local end! The P&Z meeting is a public hearing, which requires three things: 1) noticing in the weekly Aspen Times, which we take care of for you; 2) posting a large notice sign in a conspicuous front window of both properties (we have the signs for your here, just come by the Planning Office and ask for two), and; 3) mailing out a copy of the notice to all property owners within a 300' radius of each site, your job! Both notices Will be mailed to you under separate cover within the next two weeks. You will need to do a little research with the Clerk and Recorder's Office to obtain the names of all those property owners, and bring to the Public Hearing your "certi ficate of mailing", demonstrating that you have complied with the mail out requirement. You should retain all those undeliverable envelopes and bring them to the meeting. Following P&Z approval, you will be scheduled for first reading of the Designation Ordinance with City Council (please call me to determine when that will be scheduled). Second reading will .. follow approximately 4 weeks later at yet another public hearing, noticing this time handled completely through the City Clerk's office. I suggest you attend, if possible, all the public meetings at which your application(s) Will be under consideration. Please call me if you have any questions! Thanks for your interest in historic preservation. Sincerely, Roxanne Eflin Historic Preservation Planner og.kienast ATmCHMENT 1 ~ND USE APPLICATION FURM ~ 1) Project Name \~eÂ·VWQ- 6,0 Ci,"n 517 9 . A-\AAA, \Â£2. 4 U.(152.x a.1.-UL -~ . ' 2) Project location 406 0. -5.mu-1 gler b LoU -P, CA RIcx.\c. 336 , Â¢24.2 4-w-wwk câ‚¬ A.,0-u. a.~A Â£ a>Ag. \6 6 1-1,~Sle,<.9 1-6, \Xalict-iuk r-LAA. AL-. le:, e...sul :1 JCÂ·GrMS(*C. OF A:p< n (indicate street address, lot & block number, legal description where appropriate) 3) Present Zoning fluckent-2 4) Iat Size 1,0' K \ CD 5) Applicant's Name, Address & Phone # C~nY-4 5\-4.. flâ€ž- \cce...a.s + 4 0 6 0. 5 vn U.(11\â‚¬/< , Aeg,2- 0 , C..0(ove.Ao S \U>U , 30 3 - 9 1 5 - % C\21 0 6) Representative' s Name, Address & Phone # 7) Type of Application (please check all that apply): Conditional Use Conceotllal SPA - Conceptual Historic Dev. Special Review Final SPA Final IListoric Dev. 8040 Greenline Conceptual RID Minor Historic Dev. Stream Margin Final RJD Historic Demolition Mountain ,View Plane Subdivision k Historic Designation Condaniniumization Text/Map Amendmnt (MOS Allotment Lot Split/Iot Line GLOS E,oeâ€¢ption Adjustment 8) Description of Existing Uses (rimber and type of existing structures; approximate sq. ft.; runber of bedrocms; any previous approvals granted to the property). -VA C 1 60-0 stÂ· Bt. 42 , 4-L L.gi- 24Â·â€¢~ C Sa...d.~ G icaÂ¢,4Uxu. AAJALe,10.$ 4~011.-1.- D>i.ke-' 1-1,_ igc\O's . 9) Description of Develciment Application 1AO n C 1 E-h. rr /'-1 r.-1 1 u. M.\.1 . i MAY -8 10) Have you attadied the following? /Yl p Response tb Attachment 2, Minimum Submissian Contents a Ls L- Response to Attachment 3, Specific Sulmission Contents o Response to Attachment 4, Review Standards for Your Application