The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutLand Use Case.HP.410 E Hyman Ave.HP-1975-07- & 56 : 1~ -(975 - 87 . 410 E. Hyman, Tom Mix Bldg. , - 40~-1 Block 88 1 -911 3D ten pule_r- 126 19- R Â« 14 P 6-5- IRM ,Â¥* It: -,4 k.? 7 P .. .. ASPEN/PITKIN COUNTY PLANNING OFFICE 130 South Galena St. MEMORANDUM TO: HPC FROM: PLANNING OFFICE (JPS) RE: TOM MIX BUILDING - EXTERIOR STAIR & WALKWAY DATE: SEPTEMBER 23, 1975 The Planning Office cannot recommend approval of the proposed addition of an exterior staircase and walkway in the arcade along the east facade of the Tom Mix Building. The recommended denial is based on the resulting impact on the overall character of the arcade space - not the physical design of the stairca#e or resulting building facade appearance. The intent of the historic district is to respect the character and integrity of Aspen's commercial heritage as a western, Victorian mining town. The proposed addition of the elevated walkway and stair will further enclose the arcade where an existing balcony already overhangs. As a result, 1) the sense of enclosure of the space is increased with exposure to the sky, light and air decreased. The resulting small enclosed pedestrian space is more akin to that of an Oriental or Middle Eastern bazaar than that of a town in the Rocky Mountains. 2) The proposed walkway is at a different height than the existing balcony across the arcade. This fact together with the intensity of arcade uses and activities and different architectural statement of the staircase and walkway will introduce an element of Â· visual clutter. -1- .. .. Page two Memo to HPC re: Tom Mix exterior stairs 9-23-75 The Planning Office recommends that the staircase be enclosed within the walls of the existing building. This solution will'~olve the need to provide access to the second floor, prevent an increase in the spacial intensity -of the existing busy arcade space and thereby maintain the remaining sense of open space which is an indigenous characteristic of Aspen's urban character. XC: City Council Sandy Stuller Clayton Meyring JPS/sbs HISTORIC JI-SFRVATION COMMITTEE REVIEW APFiICA\TION -1g:~,%%==-M==*,mâ‚¬M=Â£*#-MilbiVJ-m--m=m*-=m##=**N/em,iiÂ¥= .'2252/*25;131-~WHA//1/,Ali~/Ari.59/limi.6/*11*WAJ ~c 44/"*FJOB ~ 4,0 E \41 'hA evi .~ LEGAL DESCRIPT]ON LOT NO. A 4 N BLOCK NO. 88 ADDITION h- o v, w 5,4 2 ~ CLASS OF WORK: NEW~ ADDITION~ ALTERATION~ REPAIR~ MOVE ~ WRECK ~ k OWNER C ~ NAME Bly-14 Woo 4 45 0 C , ADDRESS 8 0 4 34 1 1 PHONE 6 4,-.0Â§/le~4&*FqSATijgi -Il?~t.=mIREE)92â‚¬afferramÂ·~â‚¬M:;0~~4 Cd,&1Â·.0*4**J/99152~a.Lamefbaak,alla-4'Â·%~..*7 :a~2 â€¢ rdfac=ZZLI ~ PRE-APPLICATION REVIEW p -El WORK WILL AFFECT NO CHANGE TO THE EXTERIOR APPEARANCE APPROVED: BLIDG.INSP. DATE LKE121222.IZILIZILEZE{32.~sEâ€žw,~'~~.I'Vz4~.=~6~G.~*sw*~--~~ ~ CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL . Al.4- affÂ£,uti, 42 0Â«A Yr-R *. A K Q#Â£'44 b)1 4,-Il*-lt. 'Â¥\,0 ~,u,L.Lu La~~t~;~* 17 Cru ~ PRE-APPLICATION APPROVED WITH ~ 1 . 0/L i - 1.5-74 ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY ~ CRATRMAI\93. P.C. DATE ajlÂ»uL k A 7,#- ~APPLICATION REVIEW PUBLICATION PUBLIC HEARING B==Bal<*le-5.-~Emi-i/la;a==-W--i#-#ki --&-mk*=DÂ£*5*-1~i=2S;aS~*=pi-iii4~ml.~~~~~1- ,9 APPLICATION APPROVED WITH Â¢ ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY .CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE Fil/,3,LAGV#~M.AIL-xÂ«fUWAZISER#MWAL*02/jatWW;NiIllqI*IMflgaMVICZ;FFE&296341'/,RI~AlIVÂ£9/9~,ti/B7f'~22/V/*-~PLTCNY/-15-I J)*Ol#,6~2<jZLI~JZâ€¢*i!2&Wik< ~ APPLICATION DISAPPROVED 0 ~ CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE p. ~ZIEÂ®NEÂ£ZA~5Â·2~22%@Mm~#iinÂ·22-3222*~1/â„¢WE@"AbiX-,iMmlÂ·~~~idELat15%-~~iNG~&942@06,zE&WikmGL~QgiAM#-81*EGPEÂ·.Â£FHEIiWJCIEsgma;all#!82&9*~cD~n~~4 ~ REASONS FOR DISAPPROVAL R ~ CITY COUNCIL NOTIFICATION OF.DISAPPROVAL DATE i. ,......=J'e5'."01'M'.i...42.hil'7'Wv="=Men*'q.mÂ£=n=W=g//="#/,W=M/"**/'WNp<.<*Ulm.=#AC4â€¢h-.2&7=8*.Fg9.TI=**i'#I-..=**Q/,////,W.r/"*.W*ap/N&B*aÂ£%: 4 COPIES: H.P.C. ORIGINAL - BLDG.DEPT.COPY - INSPECTORS COPY - OWNERS COPY - ...7 k I : Â·n T'â€¢t.J- Â· 7.....M~â€¢â€¢~i',..In'.m'- 4 .79-10* aâ€¢ . 461-, 11 # 2..9411 -- I - - ./ -/ ta><1â€¢50'T I P--1,54- ~ 13:'U.l UPI 1--4 69 --- L L tÂ» , 0,2--1 49*qi=i 0-- - C - 72 10*WEIÂ» 22-47 0 LA-M FLec . AUP\-T\AM - - 2- A- t>EN# -1 - q , 0 \':PLOt i -0 4=>094 0Uarr I ... ./ / 1 1 APAF:TWK--41* $ A-----*. In_..... . f 19Â¥ 1.-Irlig:+ 4 2670 )M-Â·10. 49111* i \ 1 \ G 2- ~ t..0:22Â·430-~'4Â·03Â»i\3042Â¢*NeNFaNSNNN>N>*63:20/*Q/BUM#/<*99/ff tz =t - 77. =t 1 --Â·------.- -110Â£*2 %*14Â»lor 24=2 K i f '1 0" 09-10 - P'-f 0--------1 fl- 1 -- 5----1~ : :~/51: 0\\\ C= url PLH-fliÂ« F.--1 / , Â»X19t_-Â·------(dij/15:Ttle'liti -/ - - .' .6 E*L-1 964[t-4 4=r,,25,:. -4.ENX< 0020:.20>0<. \>NXÂ»N.+=.2.2~..~ci-41 /It.4 .1 T \ ,/Mall-3461 w) - /' /3 (3\At 181 If, :t r-- /..........tool 4-u-13463 16*3*73 1 21 61 Mit ion ts I 1 ort-Â·e. 1/06 4 VALL i ' 1 T-27 A- d 0 ir.... * - - 1 1 (-- 1.-1,244 et' 14? 7 â€¢ l. FEÂ«. 1 1 &1+540- 2 AUÂ»:f' -~ f- 1 -1 T-~t~-1 :-1 I t-33- 1 new enclosed d.1*2 2 4.- -- -- + 44 H. 1 -T -13 6 crtic 1 +1- . -44.- 5 E---7 2---- 22_ -f- 1 1-4 i 1 17.Opt-+0. 41 - \ i ; 0*ial-1 f--1-LA f-BA -6â€¢qyviÂ«7 U*34-4207 1-1 t-+44 1 1 0 XI -523- d.7'Vt. eLAE> . ~~1 1 -41 ti'pi'***#-*#"JI,awlÂ®!~Pi#*â€¢n0ep.yÂ»ME,11~-AlrA,!Â¥P#.1~*#%0~Xaq.iA,U.,i,*178P 4 . 1 1 1 T-T rd-4 33 - 49,1<2, / F&-- SECTION! A f ~-- 1 1 1 5 i P19 'fl 1---------- -11 , 4 U. 11- A- ----- ER * . e . 1 4 1. 1 1 t------7W -1-1-72-1.1 11 1 T _ _ F *#WEpipkbi,AF~r<Hy.p:M; =.% . IiiÂ¢I ' 11 11 1 1 1 4 1.1 \ S IL i 1 197/ H 1 r J 11 exist. ing SIJa C,2 4 : .Â» 1-4. *thâ€ž:.CoÂ©c - n 4 1 U -t_-3.1 1-1 Ch 2-1.-1 }f~; 11 - -li , n49'r \ 6 -r .=I-- 1! 2 1 U< 14111-14 & -27 1204-/Wrl %4 -4 --1 .-I -1 j Â»9Â»â‚¬~ThAÂ»*re.-4 - t. . 4. 1 :I.' I 1 1/ :â€¢I .-6 .' 'I #'.. ....' ~ I. l . I' ll.:I-e:*I..: -'...I-l-.I '.4. .'I. *** I # N- I / M 41&- I~~~ 6 1 1 1 1 1 . 1 r..1- --p ,-k -3- 1- --1 - L" 11 'll.\\ r;i--=/;=li- jil 1-,1,4 M f~I.,Â¢754- - i.- 1. - ' il 7-~ 11 - - --. , 1 ;34 1 : ti litil 447 WI 5101 - Fâ‚¬*PWAL,16 -R; AX<CAÂ»Â· ~/- . '414 1 1 b L 9. 57ttal Â»LAP - L.-- - .I-.-.-- - --â€žI ......... LOWER FLOOR P_AN ASPEN HISTORIC- PRESERVATIAN COMMLTTEE EAST E_E /ATIOIN 1.-==Fil -- 1 1-~spâ€¢ MIRMAN -101*2*,2,~DATEN - 6 -1 4 APPROVED*.~p n ~---DENJED 1/4'1 7 11.071 CONDITIONS: 23 ~ a:76 : *P Â¢919 \ . / TOM 1/17 54 1 LIZ_11\4 4 'e,25 04\/1 ~ UIUTe 1< 4. Fwrl: diul 0 1 fL X 7/00 2 444 00\ 21 w.e .PUM 1441/ Wo>al.rE 17> -,15/fo ~55< atal U)\-0,6 1>9 0 10* 4841 1-47146 EPLD. \2Â«%4 \ j~~ F/(/ 6 1-:Al- Idle:14 014'10::# 29/0/1 057-137- T Ffely, Pty - 11 A 44' L !l t- 1=>(1Â« cx;Ma -*F 4ft. Wlits 7 2 *-, 1Â»1711-01 220* . 1 1 -- ,-- - -9 n 04 *,4-jET.'; - ----- - - .....:. --1--f---.-E- Fr& ' 1-11.-au , --- e ~-1Â£:1 vual \Al- J lili LL k - --- 1 goÂ¢r. 4%%4 I c.222*rlr44 - .._._-5*I.-i 8&5::r E>(101- O 44 11 fu - -* 4 ---*-I...._.__.. M -- . -1 1 T--4 44<40110 - reiv - enclosed -_space 9 Apr. 4 ----Â» 1 - 7-7# ..7.- . %- . -r---- 1 -- + --- - .-' 1 53-5/~, --- UY -----.--* 1 - t j existing // 1 \\ I . 1 1 4 ..).-i --'--9.-- i 1 -,F 1 21-Al-N -__.ELOÂ©_R_ 2--1-1 N . F - --7- ------ - 1 4#4|i ===. 1'--0 U 0 . . . . . 1 e Â»11 --0 0 1 ..... +--1 11= - l 1 - 2 ==0 1 1 1 1 Â«21Â«--LOUT<z~~Lit-ELL-->EPTU-_Â«f 1 =Â°--7 --C)71 222--3--3 Â»00Â«--- - 0 FlÂ»t-*9Â« Â·--IY ----- - -- ----- -- 1----- ---- - .-'r . -I-~ -I * *.+- ri - .....N. - .. I Bel El&*.I ' --1 1 Ill i - ~ - 1 1 jÂ®%1 + C-1 rI-~r-4 ~ 1 f.0,69â‚¬> & IUMâ‚¬% 650*70't-4 -n ./ -*-- / 1 1-- + A l Alt_E 3 _-_ELE_VAT]QU Â· i -\/<.8-2 1 1-33- .N 1-Wi-*8142 -20_M____ -_--[yl-- ~-- X_- E-l] i-_L-P]--111_4 93&247--\Akir-0-1 2015.kll loo 7.._ .__pÂ· U,toc\P:ES,~z -21---------3 , fÂ·43\AP: 00â‚¬ 022% 3421 t:+79*A 0060Â«.1.-go \ 4* 410-2- 84*&14*4 045'. \ 9,00:. \19 1'101 ~.,~~\\ Â«Z- ' -- - titaN LdAC U 6 +947[-bi ,~ 1 2) 11 11 It It It 11 11 1 1 4\ --- --I .- I ... ....--- ....... I Iii .-- - 1 -1 - V - - ---4-1 . -i--2$=r=tr+-4,;x * ~_ 1 ; 1 ' 1 1 -- - tz:-7-j . 1-14Â«t- k Â»14-01--P~-7' - 9 ~ / 1/4 L 1100 $ 1 8*<941-04 4 v le- yv\- 41.0, 6541--RE Nly 1-0430> kÂ»I l--0- --1\ Â»fl-- FE- 01--4k--IUEâ‚¬3-25Â¢5+ ~ \ >L-=20 4->a \1* ptÂ»Wl---Â·14Â»' --~~ Â·2-4 -L-eful-23-1-174_40 \ \7 \ 4- .. HEEN / Mfs-23< - > i 0 1 1 1 -----t vuy- M 'T - 9 ' 0 \ 1 F: 41 1 j !1 1-,1110:!11â€¢llt:12#timme 1 -1 1 111111,11 i .111111IMF.1 - + 1 CE- 4 t tt,H 1 , 1 , M i 1 -I 4 1 -1 r '- Â·-Â·- 7 f *->- --- - "--- 064.2 .-0-5- vÂ«102 FEAbdic ----- 7 ..i. 9 1 :i $ .1 2 Â»rTRUGFI-JiA 6 +9717 / 2 19 K ". ; y 16. j. \2. { F. A ''17 1 1 4 _ju k ~ ~ *,i; - ~I + b # ./1 C 4 P, ,/ *- -7- > 0 0 41 ~ It :*f . Wn , 1 \. 1 2 111#47. :0.3 - 11.4:i= ,,-1,-it;Â·;.:i.:Ii P.1 314. '~11:0 1:!111112].11=I p ~. ~1;11!fit~11114-\ < .~ \\ \> 1|ill, i : 10. I:Mi':1,11'11 1 lit 1,1111111 -ili| d' liliÂ· 111 ; 1 11. * 1* \\30 4441*21 tonfX qu< . }_1- ,â‚¬1-E? ;â€ž- M _- ------ 0 9 1 t~4;14,i~ IL# '64 6 - .11- ... 1 fl:27[ 4 A A 12.-1-tf 74 Â¥14:, Â£ 6.~8 ~:I:*,11-4%!* .. I i~ ., 0~* Â·\ A 1 -- 0 li - I.A. I-- . â€ž ," ,na. 1 4*, '1 ~ 4,<04 -1-* . \ ..T. i. 111; 411 -- - UU-t Â«1-tjt--kA _ ~_--- i-*4~_-: ' (40 N - ---1/4 ---= - !11~im p > 4 - 6 3 4 1 - T INÂ£/' 11'1 4,1 b-Lb i U EAL, - , 1 11'lili .iii - r; , / lociAÂ«-97 - f < 1.\ *1: i, i -1 = - ID -. Ill . 1 . \44. 4 L ' I h-r =Pi< I-- >6011â€¢Wim'Ir 44 A.,1.1 1 - 4 1 NW 1 ..7.v-,mr . 11 1[ ic# 7 J F2-Fl#Nk '11 ' ~~. -' C 1 141 1 1 Â· 4 b 11 i -,flf; -U 1 111 1 . 1 .fl 1 1 Â£ 1 '51 C 11 N . i , 1 1 ..; 11~1~Â·41 1 9 I 1---~ ~ 3-1 614 4 11; 4 1.~ 1, ' . 2 4 1 1 1 -,=Mil, 1,1 / 11 1 'g t 1 i --- - 4 '1, ii 1 i:~ 1,4~ bil lir 1 1 -lilli .J.. ///MN// m ...........1 - ix>ev txtR L A#:6 Fret:< â€¢001 r-1 1*41.ifY 0 42- 6,-f- 1 37 9-4 tga.L--12 VAN- 1 0 1-4 1 1.-2111 L--1 621 uarg-14 1/4 11 - t | - d57 1| 1/4 " 1 1- /Dll - . F-KELI [%/11 NARTY - 259/U WN>56' 0 kay.<-1-62:12. I ds'11:25 ,Â»4<04-41 -7-*00 1- 45*' Â»-7'9 8,\*C KN\1 OOP Â»0900 - -1- O M 1%4 17. #Ul LCil P-4 621 A K o /1, CP 1Â» 0 0421 Â»44-e #552Â»4 (t'YOVAP-r70 _ UX 4902-â€¢ 0Â¥**Al t*/1 ly 1-4Al,1--Â»Ir, b*~u =4 In 5 ~ + 01â€¢t 439412= K-1 (8647tp-90 eN>Gz- $ 1 20- ,zaÂ» 4*1. 0,\415 , HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE REVIEW APPLICATION . 0- OF JOB 410 E.,Hympn St. (Tom Mix Arcade) LEGAL DESCRIPTION LOT NO. 'M & N BLOCK NO. 88 ADDITION Townsite CLASS OF WORK: NEW ~--~ ADDITION~ ALTERATION~ REPAIR~ MOVE ~ WRECK ~--~ OWNER Birkwood Assoc. NAME ADDRESS Box 3421 PHONE PRE-APPLICATION REVIEW 1 - ~~~~ WORK WILL AFFECT NO CHANGE TO THE EXTERIOR APPEARANCE APPROVED: BLIDG.INSP. DATE 2 - ~~~ WORK WILL RESULT IN CHANGE TO THE EXTERIOR APPEARANCE % W74 9-5 - 75 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 91*~t 44Â®t -4 t 0-6-u<-A, A -_Ll_ ' -tÂ«IA,14 AULA,0- - PRE-APPLICATION APPROVED WITH ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY 1 CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE APPLICATION REVIEW PUBLICATION ~ PUBLIC HEARING APPLICATION APPROVED WITH ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE ./ b 1 W 1 11 CA 1 1 -1-73/ APPLICATION DiSAPPRPMED 4.1 K.~fe.,2~> 1-./ J ' kikkj ~ CHAIRM<) H.P.C. DATE REASONS FOR DISAPPROVAL CITY COUNCIL NOTIFICATION OF DISAPPROVAL DATE 4 COPIES: H.P.C. ORIGINAL - BLDG.DEPT.COPY - INSPECTORS COPY - OWNERS COPY - .. HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE REVIEW APPLICAT.ION . ADDRESS DF JOB 410 E.,Hympn St. (Tom Mix Arcade) _EGAL DESCRIPTION LOT NO.' M & N BLOCK NO. 88 ADDITION Townsite CLASS OF WORK: NEW ~ ADDITION~ ALTERATION~ REPAIR~ MOVE ~ WRECK ~ OWNER Birkwood Assoc. NAME ' ADDRESS Box 3421 PHONE PRE-APPLICATION REVIEW 1 - ~-~ WORK WILL AFFECT NO CHANGE TO THE EXTERIOR APPEARANCE APPROVED: BLIDG.INSP. DATE 7 - ~ WORK WILL RESULT IN CHANGE TO THE EXTERIOR APPEARANCE 9 K-M 9- 5 - 75 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL TA--Lize,z-18,Miparaia-2,23Â£,4-wigi,4...1...w...,#52~2â€ž-a.,waY:,AiT..3,24~5-:IL12aSMI,ZPS221Â·'Zia-*Digrinâ€žir,Eaz,f~.F-is:qzlijjf&347TE5Tx0 -mitt~197*Â£01â€žimiâ€ž.-6~YEjg.~cymAw,2:RA,1.1 PRE-APPLICATION APPROVED WITH Â· : ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE EE=&12:GZAeL-SA&9~viFT-w.ifga~,9=liST~&*WiN-~m~SfSa,58~~7~e~Ell.,Â¤2-C,f5~ 1/SVIi)ffi~PTAY,~li1~dvit-Fgh#jitqfflilleifliligli 643&~ APPLICATION REVIEW PUBLICATION PUBLIC HEARING : APPLICATION APPROVED WITH ~ ~ ABOVE CONDITIONS IF ANY ~ CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE i 1 &/0/Â£/XV:-L.l;:&-#.Z.*=--Ilp~'.rT'=./R'll//Ill/2U......./.W#.<F/.-/.W/,I.E/h..#ij..... r./3/Â·17,Â¤FEN....i5Â¥~5=E'l~ I.I.--7*/Im./.Ill--./u/=h,i APPLICATION DISAPPROVED â‚¬ CHAIRMAN H.P.C. DATE DUSair.*iNVELOiLd-~U/N/"61"Illil/i-2- -_ ~ :7321'NIM-*rET/.hllSi5liltia2tz/:C%,~r~1~,NE:588092(#Me-in REASONS FOR DISAPPROVAL CITY COUNCIL NOTIFICATION OF DISAPPROVAL DATE 4 COP]ES: H.P.C. ORIGINAL - BLDG.DEPT.COPY - INSPECTORS COPY - OWNERS COPY - 9 I - , k l ! -3/ , 4 1 4 1 i i I 1 Â·,14 fily:~+5~~â€¢jU.m'Â· 1*rr'~ .. LEGAL NOTICE Notice is hereby given that the Aspen Historic Preservation Committee shall hold a public hearing on October 28, 1975, 1:00 P.M., City Council Chambers, to discuss the final plans for an exterior stair onto the Tom Mix building, more particularly described as: Lots M & N, Block 88, City and Townsite of Aspen. Plans are on file with the Deputy City Clerk and may be inspected during regular business hours. /s/ Kathryn S. Hauter City Clerk Published in the Aspen Times October 9, 1975.