Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Case.805 South Ave.0094.2005.ASLU.~-- THE CITY OF ASPEN City of Aspen Community Development Department CASE NUMBER PARCEL ID NUMBER PROJECTS ADDRESS PLANNER CASE DESCRIPTION REPRESENTATIVE DATE OF FINAL ACTION 0094.2006.ASLU 2737 073 35001/2 805 SOUTH AVENUE CHRIS BENDON RES. DESIGN VAR CENTURION PARTNERS 11.26.2006 CLOSED BY Angela Scorey on 07/31/2009 ...,. ~.. ,~ ~.. DEVELOPMENT ORDER of the City of Aspen Community Development Department This Development Order, hereinafter "Order", is hereby issued pursuant to Section 26.304.070, "Development Orders", and Section 26.308.010, "Vested Property Rights", of the City of Aspen Municipal Code. This Order allows development of a site specific development plan pursuant to the provisions of the land use approvals, described herein. The effective date of this Order shall also be the initiation date of a three-year vested property right. The vested property right shall expire on the day afrer the third anniversary of the effective date of this Order, unless a building permit is approved pursuant to Section 26.304.075, or unless an exemption, extension, reinstatement, or a revocation is issued by City Council pursuant to Section 26.308.010. After Expiration of vested property rights, this Order shall remain in ful] .force and effect, excluding any gowth management allotments granted pursuant to Section 26.470, but shall be subject to any amendments to the Land Use Code adopted since the effective date of this Order. This Development Order is associated with the property noted below for the site specific development plan as described below. Centurian Partners LLC Attention John Sarpa 300 Spring Street Suite 301 Asnen, CO 81611. Phone: (9701 544 3541 Property Owner's Name, Mailing Address and telephone number I ots 1 and 2 South and Gibson Subdivision (known as 805 South Avenuel Legal Description and Street Address of Subject Propeny The applicant has received variance approval from the residential design standard of buildin>; orientation (Section 26 410 040 A 1 1 to allow a portion of a sin¢le-family home to not be parallel to the street on Lot 2 and to allow the northwest detached residence's facade on Lot 1 [o not be parallel to Gibson Avenue. Written Description of the Site Specific Plan and/or Attachment Describing Plan Community Develonment Director Approval 8/1/06 Land Use Approval(s) Received and Dates (Attach Final Ordinances or Resolutions) Au ust 13 2006 Effective Date of Development Order (Same as date of publication of notice of approval.) Au ust 14 2009 Expiration Date of Development Order (The extension, reinstatement, exemption from expiration and revocation may be pursued in accordance with Section 26.308.010 of the City of Aspen Municipal Code.) Issued this 15t~ day of August, 2006, by the City of Aspen Community Development Director. ,. (1 , . Chris Bendon, Community Development Director ~~ ,~ MEMORANDUM TO: Chris Bendon, Community Development Director FROM: Jennifer Phelan, Senior Long Range Planner RE: 805 South Avenue Residential Design Standard Variance- Building Orientation DATE: July 27, 2006 SUMMARY: Centurian Partners, LLC, represented by Zone 4 Architects, has applied for a variance from the Building Orientation and Building Elements (entry door) requirements in the residential design standards to construct asingle-family residence on Lot 2 of the South and Gibson Subdivision and a variance from Building Orientation for the comer detached duplex proposed for Lot 1. The proposed application is attached as Exhibit "B". APPLICANT: Centurian Partners, LLC, 300 Spring Street, Suite 301, Aspen, CO, 81611. ZONING: R-6 (Medium Density Residential) REVIEW PROCEDURE: The Community Development Director may approve, approve with conditions, or deny a variance request from the residential design standazds pursuant to Land Use Code Section 26.410.020(D), Variances. STAFF COMMENTS: The two lots that are subject to this application is a recently subdivided corner parcel that was triangular in configuration. The building orientation residential design standard requires that both of the street facing facades of asingle-family or duplex be parallel to the adjacent streets. The streets adjacent to the property intersect at less than a ninety (90) degree angle. Staff believes that the proposed variance for the single-family residence on Lot 2 satisfies the review standards for granting a variance from the residential design standazds because the lot configuration creates a very constricted building area and would require non-orthogonal construction, which could be considered a site specific constraint. The Applicant has designed a structure where a great portion of the building is parallel to the street, meeting the intent ofthe code. Lot 1 is a corner lot that will contain two detached residences. The proposed design has facades that are parallel to South Avenue, but the northwest detached residence's fagade facing Gibson Avenue is not parallel to the street. The Applicant has argued that it would be impractical to construct a residence that is parallel to both of the adjacent streets, given the angle at which the streets intersect and has provided a porch element to relate to the Gibson 1 ~"* ~"1 ...., streetscape. Staff finds this variance to be necessary for reasons of fairness related to site- specific constraints. RECOMMENDATION: Staff believes that this application meets the applicable review standards for granting a variance from the building orientation residential design standard and recommends that the Community Development Director approve this variance request. APPROVAL: I hereby approve a variance request from the building orientation residential design standard to allow for the construction of the detached duplex and single-family residence at the property known as 805 South Avenue located on Lots 1 and 2 of the South and Gibson Subdivision , as represented on the plans attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and "D". 1' ~ date l ~""'V 1~- Chris Bendon, Community Development Director ATTACHMENTS Exhibit A -- Review Criteria and Staff Findings Exhibit B -- Original Application Exhibit C -- Amended Single-Family residence Exhibit D -- Design of Detached Residential Dwellings APPRpVED uu o ~ coos cawua~m~ ~ o>~crc~ EXHIBIT A RESIDENTIAL DESIGN STANDARDVARIANCES REVIEW REVIEW CRITERIA & STAFF FINDINGS The Community Development Director may approve up to three (3) variances from the Residential Design Standards if the proposed application meets the following: a) Provides an appropriate design or pattern of development considering the context in which the development is proposed and purpose of the particular standard In evaluating the context as it is used in the criteria, the reviewing board may consider the relationship of the proposed development with adjacent structures, the immediate neighborhood setting, or a broader vicinity as the board feels is necessary to determine if the exception is warranted; or, b) Be clearly necessary for reasons of fairness related to unusual site-specific constraints. The following are Staffs findings in regards to the variances being requested by the Applicant. Variance Requested Building orientation. The front facades of all principal structures shall be parallel to the street. On corner lots, both street facing facades must be parallel to the intersecting streets. On curvilinear streets, the front facade of all structures shall be parallel to the tangent of the midpoint of the arc of the street. a) Provides an appropriate design or pattern of development considering the context in which the development is proposed and purpose of the particular standard. In evaluating the context as it is used in the criteria, the reviewing board .may consider the relationship of the proposed development with adjacent structures, the immediate neighborhood setting, or a broader vicinity as the board feels is necessary to determine if the exception is warranted; or, Staff Findine: The other residences in the immediate azea provide for an eclectic mix of building orientation; however, there are buildings, particularly along. Gibson Avenue, that orient towazds the street. As redevelopment continues to occur, there is the ability to create buildings with a stronger orientation towards the street. Staff finds that the exception is not warranted based upon neighborhood context. ~^. •_ ''1 b) Be clearly necessary for reasons of fairness related to unusual site-specific constraints. Staff Finding: The two lots that were created have some acute angles which create site specific constraints. With regard to Lot 2, proposed for the single-family residence, the south corner is at an approximate forty-five degree angle. This creates a very constricted building area and would require non-orthogonal construction, which could be considered a site specific constraint. The Applicant has designed a structure where a great portion of the building is parallel to the street, meeting the intent of the code. Lot 1 is a corner lot that will contain two detached residences. The proposed design has facades that are parallel to South Avenue, but the northwest detached residence's fapade facing Gibson Avenue is not parallel to the street. The Applicant has argued that it would be impractical to construct a residence that is parallel to both of the adjacent streets, given the angle at which the streets intersect and has provided a porch element to relate to the Gibson streetscape. Staff finds this criterion to be met. ATTACHMENT 2 -LAND USE APPLICATION 'Location: So~TN -6 C717~So>y • . su[~pV,SrcK.~ Soy So~U lY-r~utJ~ fFSI'r~ (indicate street address, lot & block number, legal description where appropriate).. _OOZ REPRESENTATIVE: Name: ZONE H MLU{ITELYS ~ LLL Address: Z34 Ef157 yvPK,ws #VS f~$PEyy Go fjlbl/ Phone #: .~I'y "" ~ ~td3Besr fl?P~~clnT-r Name: GL~'N21trn> P/tnTi~~zS ~ LLL Address: JGU SP121NG ST2f,EJ ~ SUITE ,30~ ~$I°E>,1,f.0 8/(o/J Phone#: 5yY -833 TYPE OF APPLICATION: (please check all that apply): ^ Conditional Use ^ Special Review. ^ Design Review Appeal ^ GMQS Allotment ^ GMQS Exemption ESA - $040 Greenline, Stream Mazgin, Hallam Lake Bluff, Mountain View Plane ~ Lot Split Lot Line Adjustment TING CONDITIONS: (description of exi ^ Conceptual PUD ^ .Final PUD (& PUD Amendment) ^ Conceptual SPA. ^ Final SPA (& SPA Amendment) ^ Subdivision ^ Subdivision Exemption (includes condominiumization) ^ Temporary Use ^ TexdMap Amendment ^ Conceptual Historic Devt. ^ Final Historic Development ^ Minor Historic Devi ^ Historic Demolition ^ Historic Designation ^ . Small Lodge Conversion/ Expansion • • Other. fstauNii-~rthr/E EbTID~gj/yZ fiKJ 5'rM~ 9 v ~ ~+rc , gS`fIKJPr S„vbl.E ~,I~y (LEd1DE'+~LF f}~D ~uT $~,,,-D+aJFr$ 70 13F *t?t.l S N Z: 7t6~.to-vyT~_ ves~+u~ -~ftrD~sn~ -Das~6xi s7~~t~2~D t/it2,H.~.cE ~i~2 S~~cE- r-~+,w/ ~cvcr tacked the following? FEES DUE: S W 6 0 ication Conference Summary nt #1, SignedFee Agreement to Attachment #3, Dimensional Requirements Form o Attachment #4, Submittal Requirements- Including Written Responses to Review Standards ire larger than 8.5" a 11" must be folded and a floppy disk with an electronic rnpy of all written Word Format) must be submitted as part of the application. °T 1 nn n P(~.11 P~ new^,~ ., ATTACHMENT3 DIMENSIONAL REQUIREMENTS FORM Project: Applicant: Location: Zone District: Lot Size: Lot Area: Soo -- o -~ (for the purposes of calculating Floor Aura, tat Area may be reducxd for auras within the high water mark, easeme~s, a~ steep slopes. Please refer to the definition of Lot Area in the Municgral Code-) Commercial net leasable: Existing: N~~4 Proposed- ~/~~ Number of residemial units: Existing: 1 Proposed 2 - ~} Number of bedrooms: Exishng:~_ProposeaL• 7S'D Proposed % of demolition (Historic properties only): /V R DIMENSIONS: 2~ 3yaL 3 707 Floor Area: Exis[i~rg: ZG3o Allowable: N97S Proposed y 3 z ~ Principal bldg. height: Extstirrg.• 15' RA'noXAllowable: 75' Proposed.- T13 f~ Access. bldg. height: Eristi~: 10 =1l' Allowable: ZI ' /Z' Proposed- "T3D On-Site parking: F.~risting.• Z"3 Required.- ''f Mtw proposed- 7'IS~ Site coverage: Existing.- I 0 % Requned 7•/, Proposed Sa o Open Space: Extstirrg.• SEE Suavr•1Required.• N A' Proposed ?3l7 Front Setback: Existing.- Z`I. q t Required Im /5' proposed 10 /5 Rear Setback: Existing.- ^' 7y' Required.- 1 ~ 5 Proposed.- f o~jr Combined F/R: Existing: ^•l00' Required N /} Proposed N~Nr Side Setback: Existing.- ~, 4' Required.- 5 /b Proposed.- 10 !s Side Setback: Existing.- N At Required N~R ~# Proposed.- N Y} ~~ Combined Sides: Existing.- iV A~ ' Required N~ ~ Proposed.- N l~-~ Existingnon-co rmitiesorencroachments: StD~ yifrlD S8T0~lrtS H1tro~rPYfL {+ /4l,Ltl!!'S STrLtJGTU2t~~~ !=F-VCCt U7)LI'r'y ~rhlE- ~'LELYzrc Vf}rILT- R~~wrly b~paalse/ o~uTO 5~r3.1tttT Sr'tL~ ~ SFE s~2~Bv Variations requested: No~vE ~i~` TQIAv6c)1.t~2 L07 w~ F2eM+'f, ALT Frzow-/, i SIAE yk2D ~l~ ~•rl~ IRR~-U~ c.o-rs w/ t-rzH+rr, ~~rz/ t s I"y,~•, Ran S~E- CITY OF ASPEN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT C11Y OP ASPJ~I (hereinafter CffY) and G.E*--r~l s"~ (hcrcir4tftcr APPLICANT) AGREE AS FOLLOWS: submitted ro CITY an LLt. 2, APPLICANT »nderstands and agrees that City of establishes a fee stnrcnrre for Land Usc applientior~s and the (xaymcat t ro a deterntination oCapptirrtion completeness. 3, APPLICANT and CITY agtec that becrusc of the ! is mt possible at [his time to a50crtain the full cxtem of the c APPLICANT aM CITY fiuthcr agree that it is in the interest of the initial deposit and to thcrcaftcx permit additional ousts a be t APPLICANT agnxs additional costs may accnte following their hear will 6e benefited by retaining greater cash liquidity and will make CITY whet they are necessary as casts are incarrod. CITY agras it of tecavcrirtg its fall costs ro praC55 APPLICANT'S application m Onlittaocc No. 57 (Series of 2000) pnxtxsing fees is a condition prtxxdcru atutre or scope of the proposed projoct, it imrolvcd in proocssing flit appliCa[ion, es that APPLICANT make paymcm o[ an I to APPLICANT on a momldy basis. ard/Or approvals. APPLICANT agtxs he itional payments upon noudieation by the bC beneG~cd IhlDUgh the gr[21Cr CClfalmy 4. CPCY and APPLICANT further agree that it is itactit~bk for CITY staff to complete processing or preseM surticicm information tp the PL9nning Cotmnissio ardor City Cownal tp enable the I?laaning Commission anNor City Council to make legally roquined fudiags for jact cortsidcration, unless torrent billings arc paid in full prior ro decision. 5. 77nrefom, APPLICANT agrees that in consideration full fees prior ro a dcoermirtation of application oompictcnessv APPI amotmt of T fr60. ~ wltith is for ~,_ bouts of Connnu raordod casts exceed the initial deposit, APPLICANT shall pay additi the CITY for the proocssing of the application memioad above, inchdi per plarmcr lalur over Use initial deposit Such periodic payments shall APPLICANT further ~'J'~ that faihuc to pry snch aanted costs siuill I in no rase wilt building permits be issued omit all costs associa4ed with ~ CITY OF ASP)BN Sy: Chris Bendoa Community Devdoptna~t Dlrettor lOtaiGog ~ the t~T7!'s waiver of its rigW ro colka :ANI' stroll pay an itritial deposit in the ty I)CVdopmmt staff time, and R' actual Lit morality billings to CITY to reimburse post approval review at a rate of T220.00 e made wi[ttin 30 days of the billing dart. grounds for suspension of processing, and to procts5ing have ban paid. SP2( g.~upportlformstagrpayasdoc Inorot 7E 3a t RETAW FOR. PEP.l~~"~°--~ R'EGORD e•d des:zo so it noN ~o~.~' n ~ „~ ~ s a -`~ `'' o m ~ Av W '~`L a rAv a ~ 9~ °' p~ °' 2 M ~ v S e ~Vate,~Av . ~ a ~ m ,. c $ ~ t . 4' ~e P/ Rivers~e0 . ~6 SRC XITlCT• L19. AO. BO% ]609 ABPEN CC 81614 Pn 0]0.6 •a.96~1 F 9]0.6~4.941t November 14, 2005 Aspen Community Development Department 130 South Galena Street Aspen, CO 81611 Re: South and Gibson Subdivision- Application for an A inistrdtive variance from the Rcsidetttial Design Standards I hereby authorize Zone 4 Architects, LLC (234 East Hopkins Ave, Aspen CO R 1611) to act as our designated and authorized rcprescrttativc with reaped to eland use applicatiat being submitted to your office for our properties located at 805 So Avcnuc (Pared ID No. 2737-073- 35-001 and 2737-073-35-002). Zone 4 Architects, LLC is orized to submit an application for an Adminishative Variance from the Rcsidemial Design $ and auy additional actions rcgnicod in pursuit of these matters. Zone 4 Architects, LLC " also authorized to represent us in meetings with City Staff; boards, commissions, and the City until. Should you have any need [o contact me during the course of our review, plrue do so through the offices of Zone 4 Architects, LLC. Si arpa, Manager cnturion Partners 300 Spring Stroet, Suite 301 Asppi, CO 81611 (970)544-8336 zed d85rii0 SO iI you ARCNITE CTB LLO_ P. O. BOX 2508 ASPEN C081612 Ph 970.644.3641 F 970.541.8271 November 30, 2005 Aspen Community Developmert Deparhnent Attn: Chris 13endon 130 South Galena Street Aspeq CO 81611 Chris: The following is an appliption for an adroinisUative variance from the Residential Design Standards for a single family residence to be locxrted at the South & Cn'bson Subdivision located at 805 South Ave. The initial lot for Ure subdivision was triangular with acute comets to the northeast and southeast. The lot went through a subdivision request in June 2004, and created two lots that ran northeast/soutlrwest-with the single-family lot on the norihwestem portion of the property. After subdivisioq the lot was sold and the curreffi owners are now seeking to reconSgure the lot lines. This application reflects the proposed lot lines and areas. There are several site related features that necessitate this request, as well as censideration for other factors lrke neighborhood character, limiting the impact of the residence on the neighborhood and the other units in the subdivisioq and conditions of subdivision approval. The principal site related issues are as follows. 1.Due to the triangularly shaped lots, traditional.site planning becomes much more diffiwh, as signiflrant portions of the lot area become unusable (for orthogonal conshrrction) due to setbacks. This effect becomes more pronounced as building mass moves towards the froct setback. 2. An underground electrical line runs along Gibson Ave. within the boundaries of the property. If its krcation is accurate per the survey, the distance of the electrical line to the setback ranges from approx 6'6 (at southern corner) to 2'6" (at northern corner). While it is possible to build structures within close proximity to utility lines, it is not gwerally something that we like to do. 3. When this parcel was brought before councfl in 2004 for subdivision review, a condition that was included with the approval ordinance was to only allow one wrb wt to access all units. This requiremwt has effectively mandated that the ~~~ of dte buildings be organized to facilitate vehiwlar access through the common lot line. 'This parcel is the tip of a peninsula that has the Smuggler Mobile Home Park at its back, and is bordered by South Avewe and Gibson Avenue. As the attadred map shows, thecae is no unifiorm character or consistency to the fagade lines in this neighborhood. This property is located at the junction of 5 different caning types. Even if every property in the neighborhood were to be redeveloped, there would still not be any consistency due to the various lot sizes and street orie~ations. The streetscape along South Avenue is a more regimented and well-established pedestrian way than that along Cnbson Avemre. Gibson Avenue primarily nms through the R IS and R-30 mne district. At no point does die azchitecture engage the pedestrian along this route, nor would it necessarily have to due to the lot sizes. The area immediately across Gibson Avenue fiom the parcel is a rather unique urban experience. This uniqueness is created by the rehrtionship of the trail system and the topography that creates a permanent, unobstructed visual corridor looking towards Aspen Mountain. Due to the dominant presence of the mountain, and the hu•]c of built environment surrounding this area, pedestrian orenation is towards the mountain- not the streetscape. We are seeking a variance from the following standards for the single-family residence: 26.410.040 (Axl} Building orientation-The front facades of all principal structures shall be parallel to the shed. 26.410.040 (Dxlxa} Bwlding Elements (Entry door) Stred oriented entrance and principal window- entry door shall face the stred and be no more than 10'-0" bade from the from-most wall ofthe building 26.410.040 (Axl}Building orientation A variance from this criterion is required because the main building mass, which is located behind the first story element, is oriented towards the moumain and perpendicularly to the southern property boundary and fence line. The code states in Criterion (Axl) that the front facades of ALL principal structures shall be parallel to the sued. However, ubeer Section (A) the intentions of this code language is described. It crates that, "The intent of these design standards is to encourage residential buildings that address the street in a manner which creates a consistent `fa~ttle line" and defines the public and semi public realm. In ad~6tion, where fences or dense landscaping exist, or are proposed it is intended Hurt they be used to defrne the boundaries ofpmate property without eliminating the visibility of the house and front yard from the street " The building mass, by virtue of the subdivision requirement restricting access to one curb cut, must be located towards the southern portion of the site to allow for the necessary driveway and turning areas to occur for the driveways bdween the units. The angle that is formed between the Southern boundary and the boundary along the street, is very acute. A tall fence currently exists, that runs along the entire length of the property that borders the Smuggler Park property. There are no plans to eliminate the fence with the new development. The "outdoor room" created by the landscaping and site walls will act to relate the residence to the sidewalk, and are confiderrt that those elements will act to create the type of public and semi-public definition that the code seeks to implement. The first story elemerrt, which is just over 22% of the total building width, is in full compliance with the Design Standazds and represents the front fapde of the building. Given the site specific requirements, the nature of the neighborhood context and its relation to the code, and respecting what is currently a unique pedestrian experience at the trailhead of for the Oklahoma Flats hail system, we feel that our design respects the intentions of the code while creating the best layout and design given the constraints of the lot. 26.410.040 (Dxlxa} The single family residence has been designed to sit with the majority of the entry level a little over 4 fed below the line of existing grade. The entry door is also located below the existing grade elevation. This has been done to reduce the house's profile to the strcetscape and open the view comdor for the duplex units behind. There is an enhy courtyard and stairs incorporated into the landscape leading down to tbe entry level. As the building mass is oriented Wwards Aspen Mountain, the front door and landscaping is perpendicular to the building (and therefore not to the stred). This oriemation allows for amore spacious exterior emery sequence, but the door is 16'_8" back from the float fagade and is not parallel to the sued. In summary, the Iteside~ial Design Standards were created to help gaud against residences that ignored the human environment at the streetscape and attempted to overpower the bulk environment around them. Key components were identified from historic models that would assure some degree of uniformity was applied to meding this outcome. Certain conditia~ns was aLgo identified that could compromise the architecture of a project and still Wert aceomplish the intent of the Stardads. We believe that the design of this residence manages to be respective of the pedestrian experience and the intent of the Standards, while maintaining a cohesive, quality design within the confines of the sRe. Thank you, Dylan M. Jahns,~, Principal Zone 4 Arehiteds, LI,C. i gg b~ 3~ ~~ G~ n ~ yb ~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~. ~~~ F O 7 O JN~Fo d> do }paF~ >j ~~ R ;_~ I- p NZHI~U 0 O~:F? Z m Z W F w _ o3a ~ ~~Z ~ mWa znQ ~pQ~o NF v 0 \\~ ~% ~ rp ,\ ` n~~ ..~, 7 '~.> :~ 9 / ~._'_ `~~ ' ~~.~ .-- ~~#~ g9 ~~ ~~~ ep as ~~'~ ~~b b~~"54 a~Qq~(~r9~ ~~z94 gg~Y ~~~~~~~ i~ Y~f ~ ~~~b~~ ~~~g~g~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~fia ~ ~~ ~$ ~n ~~~~~ ~€~~~ ~ ~~6a r .g i i i `~ i i E ~ 3. 1 i~ ~ ~+~ ~~ i~ ~~ ~' i ;< Q- ~ e;'' ~ ~ e i i ~, :, ..,, ~~ r S ~~ `' ~ ~. ~. ~ ~ ~ /~ l~a ~~/ / .' ~ ~ ~e i x / ~ /~ ~~, i / /~ > _ / ~ i ~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ __~__ \R // i \i r. ~ / i i -), ~ i . ~ ~~ ~ x 2"- 1~ ~C R~ ~M ~b n 1~ i i t~~ a~ ~ ~i i i i i i t~`~ 1 ~ '~~ 1' ` V ~~ ~~~ i ~i ~~,. f ~ ~~~ ,t~, ~~ ~~ ~ ~ .` \! ''i µ .r; . t~. '+~. ..t. ~_ ~; ~~ ~i ,, ,~ 39~, 1l~8 •e r ~1Aa .®~• ~~~) ~~s~ ®.~sm rt `. '. C1 `. s 0 ~,. yA~~~ ~@~ tb z~ ~~~~~ ~:~ ~ ~~~~~ 4~ ~yb~Cb s~ ~9 ~g~g gy~~fQy~~ cE9Y~F a xx ~g ~8 dd 8a cn ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ mk 33qg ~ ~a b d p€dC W~tl g ~~E $~~ ~~ ~~` a€~ ~~~ g~@ rY~ b~ ~~YS ~~~ ~~: ~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~A _. ~ ~ = b~ ee,, p ~~g:g a~ $G~~ ~en3 R m g+„a~ ~~ 9~:~~a ~~~9q ~° ~~~~~ ~~~R~ F ,!i Q d Z 7 C - 0_ ~ Q W N~Fo ~ ~ ~ a 0 ZOaF° Wmx,~Y F ~ Z W Z QN;F~ 0 oz~o~ NN~~z Y m ~3a Z ~~i Jt~f W~a a z~a I~Wao C H0~ ~ WU1t v ~C tl! N 4 R Y ~ g 6 6 p 0 ~gga § + ~ ~~ e b ~r ~ MMF, ip~ ggi ~ ~ R g ~, ~ g ~ 4 q ,' ~ \/ i~ / ~_ / / /, / / ` ~\ / / !\ / ~ ~€ ~~ ~a~ ~~ i r b 9~ ~g~~~ : ~ bi k I~ _ b 1 ~ 6 ~ Bpd§, ~9~~§f,~ ~ ~ ~ 9~ ^i ?31YS5 ~ ,~ ~ ,% b / K ~ i i i i '~~ ~ r _ d Ohl ,' ' f ss ~ X/ .1 ~~Y // ~~ i /~ f- ~ ~,'. 1 ~ / 1 ~ ~ .a~ U l '~ i ~~i / ~. i i i ~v' ,r . ~ ~~, ti i i f~ ~ 7 ~ s ~ i ~ / ~ :.,( ~ a~ ~ ~ ~ y < ,~~~ ro s z , i ~ i a .^ ~~ )~ +' 4~ ~. .' a iii ( ~ ~g ~ ~r R' ~ 3 ~/ 1 ro~ ~ ~ Q. i Qa~ k ~ !~ / / ~~ '. i ~_._ _- • \ ~~-` ~ ~ \ r' 2\ ~ ~ ~\~._- Q '\ \ b t8 V'• ` ~6 :8. ~ °e~~ W 6 ~. ,/'® , , ~ i s /k y0y /.1~ F ~~~' ~ii„~J X14.. b Z~~ ~1` ~a /sJ f;i~ t #~i a • oi# r 6t ~laa m®mm ~ 1~,~ ,~~:a® ~~ ~~ ~ \ ~ ~\ . ~ \ "=1 > n ;~~ ~ of ~ ~~~ i ' ag ~ i.. ~._iY_'T.~ % \ ~ \~ Y ~ \ bye. ~.._ ,.~~..' ~ ~\ \~~; \p~ \ \ 8 "~ bpi ~'~4. '~*,,~` ~4~ -\ ~.. .: ~\ ~ckb bz ~ ~ ° ~ .~ , ~~~~ €g~~a ~~~`~ ~ b pp~~~~ b ~~~ a 9 ~~ ,~ s b ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ b ~ygyjb a@a 4F4~' 8 ~m pp ~ R :~ gb:i _- -- - - ~~ ~ le~~i~ ~ d/ ~ / ~ ~ G. ~ ~ K ~ ~ ~~ ~ 11 ~ ~~ 1 a~ ~ a 1 / ` ~~ ~e ~~~ ~i ~~ ~~ ,. 1 1~9 \! 2R ~ ~ j~ 4 ; 1 k .~~a ,.; ~~ a~`~i `~a~` a ~~i ~ .l W .. ~ a «_ ca s ,~. 3 y$ ]Rp~ ~ ~~4~~~~ Cyy 3B jt~sg b I ~ b3~ ~E i 3F p ~$ a , & ~~b ~ 3 a8 c b -~4Y§dba a3 m $~:~ ~~~ ~ r~~~ \ ~ `\ / ~ _ ~\ . w ~ E~ \~ /\~ ~~ ~ ~ •5\ Y ` ~'` /~ ,'i; \~~ ,atd ~ ~1D0 ~ '"~`[i~~'" ~~'~( p 1~~~ ~3i8 ~ ~~~ ~~ 3e.gn^~ °9~aF ~~~--F ^- _.a ~~ _ ..: 099'99^99c=' ~u T ~ ~ ~ a ;,`- ~~~ ` a ,~ <~ ,fl ~~ .2 _ ~, 1>. ~~'e' .,,~ ~... ~ _,_~._ ~ ~ ' i e b 5 e 3 j b f b Y CI ;~ . £ ~ ~ ~ ~ b s 9~9~ o c ~ ~ i Eg ~ 7 F u r x i ~`. FRS ~' ~. ., i J L2 r /O A _~ ~~ I %~~ ion i i /O ~. i i ~o 1 I 1 ~I / ~ i ~ i 1 i / i i~ i 1 i ~ ~\ ~~ / 1 i ~ ~ i ~ 1 i ~ / ~ / ~ 1 i ~ 1 i ~ ~ / 1 ` ~ 11 ~ `j ~% 1 ~ ~ 1 i ~ / ~ 1 1 1 1 1 ~ e ~~\ $\ Y ~ 1 ,,1 ~ \ / 11 ~ ~~ , ~ ' ~ 1 ~ ~ ~, ~` ~~ ~ ~ ~, ~ ~~ ~ ~ 1 ~ , ~ ~ 1 ('' ` ~' \~ _ ~ ~~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ i~~ ~1~ 1 i ~ ~ ~\ 1 ~i~ ~~ ~~~ \ ~ 1 ~ ~"~~ ~ / ` ~ ~` ~ "~ ~ ~~ i ', ~~ Y ~'~a ~ ,,~ ` ..~ P5 i ~ ~ ~' ` ~~~ ~ ~~ \ ~ ~~ \ ~ ~ '~'~~ \ 9,~ Y` \\ ~`\ \\ Z ~ ~ '~, a ~, ~ a `, ~. °~ ` ®,,= ' ~ ~ W ~.,,~~ ~ 3~ b N~SBi~ ~... 0 00 Y t J F O u r x 0 0 w J U ~~ b ~~ ~D ,, \ ''--~__ \ \G~ , " o .\~ \S, '~ \\ ~~R ~ ~' a 6- ~~ ~.. ~, O~ ~j I J _ _ _ . _ I I I I i I I q I O I I x I ~ I _______________ I -J x J W W J ~~~ ~ ~~ x~ ~ V~ ~\ ~~ ~, ~~j~~~ S~JJ ~. S \ ~ Pa, \ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~~ ~ ~ `~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ \ O` ~ \T' \ ~ x Z vI m N 0 m 'L' H 0 N O 1 W J Q U 0 N r W J Q H a w U z 0 U U iPY" ~~ O N YI MO W O ,\ D ~ J ~r >~ J W Q 2 ~~~ 7 1 s ;~Z,.. ,,,, _ ~(/ !i y~ a: `/1 ` .. '' 1 , r. t .. id I/ ~'. ~`CC~ }y '.. ~w ~^ A >= Y Y~~....... J.r '~'..i"~ N __ ~ ~ 'AID ? ;Y ,($~ __ K ' .~` I~ f ~\ -~: 4 ~~~.:1 ~,, ; ~,. ':j -_ r r a i~ ~~ ~ ,~i ~'`M L ., tl ~' Z~ ~' :- ~`. ti ~ ' r .v ' ~ ,` ',~~* w. =` \ \ f 1 ~ ~ 'h(~ 1 ~,~ '"i .., n i1 ~ s ~°`=k ~ ~,~ .~ 3 .t. -.., , ,,,_ , oy~ ~ ,,, , , 200&0301 23:14:37 (GMT) 16667290291 From: Stewart Title of Aspen COMMITMENT FOR TITLE INSURANCE SCHEDULE A Effective Date: August 11, 2005 at 7:30 a.m. Order Number: 44126-C4 "' 2. Policy or Policies To Be Issued: p, (X) ALTA (1992) Owner's Policy Amount: $4,595,000.00 ( )Standard (X) Extended Premium: $5,302.00 r oposed Insured: Centurion Partners GS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (X) ALTA 1992 Loan Policy Amount: $2,986,750.00 ( )Standard (X) Extended Premium: $100.00 Proposed Insured: Alpine Bank, its successors and/or assigns 3. The estate or interest in the land described or referred to in this Commitment and covered herein is: Fee Simple 4. Title to the estate or interest in said land is at the effective date hereof vested in: Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado limited liability company 5. The land referred to in this Commitment is described as follows. Lols I and 2, SOUTH & GIBBON SUBDIVISION, according to the Final Plat thereof recorded February 7, 2005 in Plat Book 72 at Page 12 as Reception No. 506797. County of Pitkin, State of Colorado. Statement of Charges Policy premiums shown above, and any charges shown below aze due and payable before a policy can be issued. Reissue Rate Tax Certificate $ 20.00 Form ] 10.1 (Owners) $ 150.00 Form 100 $ 50.00 Form 8.1 $ 50.00 Form 110.1 (Lender) $ 75.00 Examiner Name: Tom Twitchell 6iiY OF ASPEN ~~ PAID N0. q~~`~ ~ ~`~Y~6 WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO: Name: Centurion Partners GS, LLC Address: c% John Sarpa 300 South Spring Street Aspen, C0 8 ] 611 QPFY dF BEN DAl"EHp~PA1D REP ~ ~, o----------------_------- _._ _ __. ___ _ _. IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5905092. LVIR DRVIS PITKIN COUNTY CO 5 04.0E R 11.00 D 459.50 DF ~-~R. ~o ~'A~RRANTY DEED THIS DEED, made this 8th day of September, 2005, between Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado Limited Liability Company of the said County of Pitkin and State of Colorado, grantor, and Centurion Parhlers GS, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company whose legal address is c/o John Sazpa, 300 South Spring Street, Aspen, CO 81611 of the said County of pi~in and State of Colorado, grantee: WTTNESSETH, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of Ten dollars and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has, granted, bazgained, sold and. conveyed, and by these presents does grant, bazgain, sell, convey and confirm, unto the grantee, his heirs and assigns forever, all the real property, together with improvements, if any, situate, lying and- being in the said County of Pitkin and State of Colorado described as follows: Lots 1 and 2, SOUTH & GIBSON SUBDIVISION, according to the Final Plat thereof recorded February 7, 2005 in Plat Book 72 at Page 12 as Reception No. 506797. County of Pitkin, State of Colorado. also known by street and number as: 805 Gibson St., Aspen, CO 81611 TOGETHER with all and singular the hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging, or in anywise appertaining, and the reversion and reversions, remainder and remainders, rents, issues and profits thereof, and all the estate, right, title, interest, claim and demand whatsoever of the grantor, either in law or equity, of, in and to the above bargained premises, with the hereditaments and appurtenances. TO HAVE. AND TO HOLD the said premises above bazgained and described, with the appurtenances, unto the grantee, his heirs and assigns forever. And the grantor, for himself, his heirs, and personal representatives, does covenant, grant, bazgain, and agree to and with the File Number: 44126-C4 Stewart Title Df Aspeq,nc. ...514519 _... _..... _. Warranty Deed -Photographic Record (Extended) TRANSFER DECLRRRTIDN RECEIVED 09/08/2005 Page 1 of 2 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5ie 6 e9 easel R 11 ._00~p 459, 50.„x.. grantee, his heirs and assigns, that at the time of the ensealing and delivery of these presents, he is well seized of the premises above conveyed, has good, sure, perfect, absolute and indefeasible estate of inheritance, in law, in fee simple, and has good right, full power and lawful authority to grant, bazgain, sell and convey the same in manner and form as aforesaid, and that the same aze free and cleaz from all. former and other grants, bargains, sales, liens, taxes, assessments, encumbrances and restrictions of whatever kind or nature soever, except The grantor shall and will WARRANT AND FOREVER DEFEND the above-bazgained premises in the quiet and peaceable possession of the grantee, his heirs and assigns, against all and every person or persons lawfully claiming the whole or any part thereof. The singulaz number shall include the plural, the plural the singulaz, and the use of any gender shall be applicable to all genders. IN WITNES3~GVH)yREOF~e grantor has executed this deed on the date set forth above. William B6fie ringer, Managing Mem~r of Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado Limited STATE OF6eiordrlo FWRI D1{ COUNTY OF Rit{f~l pgpE The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this S day of 5EP1{~$l= R ~11.t by By: William Boehdnger, Managing Member of Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado ~ Limited Liability Company My commission expires ~.oy~ Witness my hand and official seat. Notary Public: ~ja°j'' ~ SEAt. _'' ~ S. K 43.~r~^~, OFF1 ~i f . r ~~t X03 y p' M ~,~~~ C1AL SfA1. Madeleine S.16e~ D.D.# 373,390 y Eipires NutasAr$~ ~'o~ber l3tY.,7AU~ NBC ~. ,~,'::,:`. ~~GAL SEAL ~ • ~ a~ 1~~-•.Mkte S Kel ~`' FOr ~~~p"' ,,,,, ~ hr ~..~.~ 373390 r .2:-::.:~, ~ l~e,,a sae Fllc Number: 44126-C4 Stewart Title of Aspm. Inc. Wamnry Deed - Photogradhic Record (Exlmdedl Page 2 of 2 ~i7'1't?F ASPEN ~~ ~PND ~l>slos ~ ~~~6 WHEN RECORDED RETURN TO: Name: Centurion Partners GS, LLC Address: c/o John Sarpa 300 South Spring Street Aspen, CO 81611 OITY aF ,q~Gp~ D~1'YEHAETf PAID REp ,~. `ll~m5~ ~ .~ YY~L Y _'.. \ 71~ ~I~~,~~ I ' S~r~ 2 G 2Gfl5 ~~ IIIIIIIVIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVIIIIIIVIIIIIIIIIII 09908 2005 04:0E NiY CO R 11.00 D 459,50 V~'A`R-RANTY DEED THIS DEED, made this 8th day of September, 2005, between Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado Limited Liability Company of the said County ofPitk;nand State of Colorado, grantor, and Centurion Partners GS, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company whose legal address is c/o John Sarpa, 300 South Spring Street, Aspen, CO 8l 611 of the said County of Pitkin and State of Colorado, grantee: WITNESSETH, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of Ten dollars and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has, granted, bazgained, sold and conveyed, and by these presents does grant, bargain, sell, convey ` and confirm, unto the grantee, his heirs and assigns forever, all the real property, together with improvements, if any, situate, lying and-being in the said County of Pitkin and State of Colorado ' described as follows: Lots 1 and 2, SOUTH & GIBSON SUBDIVISION, according to the Final Plat thereofrecorded February 7, 2005 in Plat Book 72 at Page 12 as Reception No. 506797. County of Pitkin, State of Colorado. also known by street and number as: 805 Gibson St., Aspen, CO 81611 TOGETHER with all and singulaz the hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging, or in anywise appertaining, and the reversion and reversions, remainder and remainders, rents, issues and profits thereof, and al] the estate, right, title, interest, claim and demand whatsoever of the grantor, either in law or equity, of, in and to the above bazgained premises, with the hereditaments and appurtenances. TO HAVE. AND TO HOLD the said premises above bargained and described, with the appurtenances, unto the grantee, his heirs and assigns forever. And the grantor, for himself, his heirs, and personal representatives, does covenant, grant, bazgain, and agree to and with the File Number: 44126•C4 _--. Stewart Title of Aspen. Inc. 51451 g - _ _... _ -,-.... Wartanty Deed-Photographic Rewrd (Extended) TRANSFER DECLRRATION RECEIVED 09/08/2005 Page 1 of 2 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 0 90 519 z . IR DRVIS PITKIN COUNTY CO 8/2005 04.0E R 11.00 D 459,,,,5,0.... grantee, his heirs and assigns, that at the time of the ensealing and delivery of these presents, he is well seized of the premises above conveyed, has good, sure, perfect, absolute and indefeasible estate of inheritance, in law, in fee simple, and has good right, full power and lawfil! authority to grant, bazgain, sell and convey the same in manner and form as aforesaid, and that the same aze free and cleaz from all. former and other grants, bargains, sales, liens, taxes, assessments, encumbrances and restrictions of whatever kind or nature soever, except The grantor shall and will WAILRANT AND FOREVER DEFEND the above-bargained premises in the quiet and peaceable possession of the grantee, his heirs and assigns, against all and every person or persons lawfully claiming the whole or any part thereof. The singular number shall include the plural, the plural the singulaz, and the use of any gender shal] be applicable to all genders. IN WITNES3~DVH1'iREOF. the grantor has executed this deed on the date set forth above Wiliam $trellringer, Managing Mem'bFr of Gibson Avenue, LLC, a STATE OF~olorado FWRI Dot COUNTY OF F~fitin DApE ~f The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of SEP1{'~ $~ R ~1U by By: William Boehringer, Managing Member of Gibson Avenue, LLC, a Colorado ~ Limited Liability Company My commission expires ~`Oy p~ Witness my hand and official seal. J 1~ 1 >,l~Q J ~LQ kQ 1 A ° P ,~ SEAL Notary Public: ~a°f" ~ _'• S. KelAr °T •Y~ a„u ~~~"'~ OFFICIAL S~ •:• A~deletne S, l4elly y '°' D.D.# 373,990 • e: ~,m M„" y' (bm"ssi°n F.~ees No~a~letl4~ ~!tr~e-N+b~c 1Ztk,2o0~ H.~C 3a`~"•> • '•-FICIAL SEAL •~ k K ~:~~: .* •f Or nC,P: ~ li..,~ ,,,, ~h ~rr;r<,,,, ~, Wo~nbg,18, 20QB Flle Numhcr: 44126-C4 skw+n tine prASPep. Ine. Wamanry DeW - PhoWgrophie Afford (Fxtendedl Page 2 of 2 ~~ti~ c~~ ~; ~' .-~, `a. i ~- ~~~~~ A p O N I T E C T 8 LLO. P. O. BOX 250& ASPEN Co 81612 Ph 970.544.3541 P 970.544.&211 June 6, 2006 Community Development Department 130 South Galena Street Aspen, CO 81611 I apologize for the time it has taken to get you this material regarding the South and Gibson Administrative Residential Design Standards variance that we met about on January 13, 2006. At that meeting we discussed the revised design of the single family residence and the detached duplex street facing facade elements. It was determined in that meeting that the revised single family design (on file) met the intent of the code for primary masses being oriented to the street, and the south eastern living room element was a not a principal mass and is heavily impacted by site constraints, and therefore could have a street facing faFade that was not parallel. There were no other variances being requested. The massing and orientation of the detached duplex units was also reviewed. It was the determination that the facades along South Avenue for both units were in wmpliance with the orientation requirements. The 1" story element, for both units, is the principal building elemem facing the street. The effect of this massing is more cleazly illustrated in the 3 Dimensional model images (attached) than in plan. There was also discussion regarding the North West duplex unit and it's south facing fagade. This fagade faces Gibson Avenue, but is not parallel to the street and is setback from the road. Because of the triangular shape of the lot, Gibson Avenue is a secondary front street that is oriented at an angle from South Ave. Due to the unique site condition for this lot and the secondary nature of this portion of the house, it was determined that the fapde could maintain an orthogonal relationship with the residence and not be parallel to the street. A single story porch element would be added to address the street frontage, and an unage of which is also attached. Thank Dy .Johns, Principal Zone 4 Architects, LLC. 0 0 _ ~„ 4 t ~\ -- \\ . - ,~ 1 ~-~- 1 !W' ~~• / J ' O ~,, .~ ~ y4 / S / o / 1~ gyp/ / ~ ~ ~ / Qy ' 4 ~ / ~ / A // /~ / ~ / ~ i ,,„",. I a. i 7~ 1 1 1 1 ~ ~ Y ~ ~~ ~ , ~` `\ 1 ,1 ~ ~~ \ 1` ` 1 1 1 ~.~ ` a ~i~ ~ \ ~ `~ ~~ `1 \ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ \ ~ `~ 1 ~ ~`` ' ~i ~ `~ J ' / ice ~ \~ ~ ' ~~ ~ 1 Y' ~. ~~'_ ~ 1~ ~ s~~\ \ \ \ ~ \\ 3 1'~' ~,\ I ; i ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~. / ~~ ~~~~W) ~~ ~~ , , ~~ b N~ '~_ 58~~ K ~ I ~/ d i/ '~ / ` 1 1 A ~` / ' 1 / ~ 1 T \\ ~~ a° ~~ a= \~ \ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ \\ ~\ ~` Z o Q ~ ~ i ~ J ~~ a O M ~ \ ``` W II ~ ~`~ r ,~ ~ ~ \ ~ ~~ \ \~ ~ W J ~ \ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ Q U ,~ bra rI `~ /~ O W Cfl W 6 F O W F 0 ~. w w S O- i ~i I 'II II II 'Il it I I III 'Il II I 'Il H II 'I I II II 'I I II II II II 'I I II II 'I I II II ~I I II II 'Il II II 9c ~n Q$ W W ~s 9~ W 1~U wU R~ 33r pu ~3a yw ?~ '~c ~6 as '36 r b~ ~. 'r ~r d® r d`s mx d° d'e ®~ ~ D"e ~ 49 ~ R~ Q~ 4. - ~- .... ._ Eie Er& geed pdevigate Fgm Repays Pa~at Iab F~Ip `.s. R+ro x . >.I ~ ~ ~. ` `3~~;~ J' ~,, Raarg ~istay ~~oaAias ~ Sub Pames~ Valuation ~ Pu~kc Lament ~ Customs Request ~ Aaacbments Man ~ Ro~Rag Status ~ Ardt/Erg i Parcels ~ Casten Fads ~ Feed ~ F~Summan 1 $ctens ParrA Type ~$~ .__AsP~ L~itJ Use GtAw .. .. Addrars 8055OUTH AVE J Cdy PEN Pemd p Stile CO ~ Zgt 87677 ~) Mesta Pamd~ ,._~ RorRing4l~ AFpGed .12/01 /2~ Project ~ J SteNS Perxfn9 ^~ At+pov~ Dasaiptbn RE4UESTING RESIDENTIAL DESIGN STANDARD VARIANCE FOR SFR Issued ~- Fna ~~ ': Submeted ONE dARCHITECTS 54435dT Cock I""'"°a Days r-_ 0 Espkes 11 /26/2006 ~'" Vises on t!e vim? Prime IDS 1~365dd Last Name CENTURION PARTNERS, J Fast Name _ Phone ~(9d9)2%L6800 Owrin lsApF6caM? AppicaM _. .__.. _. _. :::: Last Name CENTURION PARTNERS, ~ Fpst Name~~ 3660 NEWOPPORT BEACN DR SUITE ~ NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 BEACH CA 92660 `~' ? ..-