Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Case.CU.716 W Francis St.A31-91CASELOAD SUMMARY SHEET City of Aspen DATE RECEIVED• 5 1 DATE COMPLETE: PROJECT NAME: Belli. Project Address: 71 Legal Address: Lots APPLICANT: Joseph & Applicant Address: 70001 (504) 861 -4903 REPRESENTATIVE: Cinderella T Representative Address /Phone: PARCEL ID AND CASE NO. 2735 - 124 -08 -003 A31 -91 STAFF MEMBER: LL Aspen. CO 81611 -5 PAID: YES NO AMOUNT: N/C NO. OF COPIES RECEIVED 2 TYPE OF APPLICATION: 1 STEP: 2 STEP: P &Z Meeting Date 7 Z ( *PC �VVJ t ,„�wo- 121 CC Meeting Date PUBLIC HEARING: YES NO VESTED RIGHTS: YES NO PUBLIC HEARING: YES NO VESTED RIGHTS: YES NO Planning Director Approval: Paid: Insubstantial Amendment or Exemption: Date: REFERRALS: City Attorney Mtn Bell School District City Engineer Parks Dept. Rocky Mtn NatGas Housing Dir. Holy Cross State HwyDept(GW) Aspen Water Fire Marshall State HwyDept(GJ) City Electric Building Inspector Envir.Hlth. Roaring Fork Other Aspen Con.S.D. Energy Center DATE REFERRED /S / INITIALS: , FINAL ROUTING: _ City Atty"�K City Engineer Housing _ other: 4 G _Env. Health FILE STATUS AND LOCATION: r RESOLUTION OF THE ASPEN PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FOR CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL OF THE ATTACHED ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT LOCATED AT 716 WEST FRANCIS STREET, ASPEN COLORADO Resolution No. 91- /?/ WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public meeting July 2, 1991; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 5 -201 an attached accessory dwelling unit is a conditional use review requiring a public hearing; and WHEREAS, the Planning staff recommended approval of the attached accessory dwelling unit with conditions; and WHEREAS, the Commission amended the recommendation changing the conditions of approval to eliminate the requirement for a rolled curb and requiring a redesign of the access to the accessory dwelling unit. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Commission that it does hereby approve the conditional use for a 360 square foot attached accessory dwelling unit located at 716 West Francis Street with the following conditions that prior to the issuance of any building permits: a. a deed restriction shall be reviewed and approved by the Housing Authority, the applicant shall record the deed restriction with the Pitkin County Clerk, Recorders Office and Planning Department. The restriction shall state that the accessory unit meets the housing guidelines for such units, meets the definition of Resident Occupied Unit, and if rented, shall be rented for i periods of six months or longer. TO: Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission FROM: Leslie Lamont, Planning RE: Bellina Conditional Use Review for a Voluntary Attached Accessory Dwelling Unit DATE: July 2, 1991 ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- SUMMARY: The applicant proposes to remodel a single family home and provide a voluntary attached accessory dwelling unit. Staff recommends approval of conditional use for an accessory dwelling unit. i, BACKGROUND /PROCESS: The renovation of this Historically Designated structure was granted final developpQ,at.approval from the Historic Preservation Committee at their :June 26., %1991 meeting. The HPC granted a variance for combined side pard setback and a variance for the combined rear and front yard setback. An accessory dwelling unit is a one -step conditional use review by the Planning and Zoning Commission at a public hearing. The 1 Commission shall consider whether the standards outlined in Section 7 -304 of the Land Use Code are met when considering this applications for a conditional use. APPLICANT: Joseph and Delia Bellina as represented by Charles ,i Cunniffe and Associates LOCATION: 716 West Francis Street, Original Aspen Townsite 1 ZONING: R -6 APPLICANT'S REQUEST: To provide a 360 square foot accessory dwelling unit 100% above grade. REFERRAL COMMENTS: Having reviewed the application and having made a site inspection, the Engineering Department has the following comments: 1. It is preferable that no runoff from the buildings, driveways or parking areas go onto any public right -of -way. Per Section `Ir 24.7.1004.C.4.f of the municipal code, all but historical drainage must be maintained on site. 2. The applicant shall consult City Engineering for design considerations of development within public rights -of -way and shall obtain permits for any work or development within public rights- of -way from City Streets Department. A five foot wide pedestrian usable space must remain unobstructed between the property line and the edge of pavement. 3. The applicant shall agree to join any future improvement districts which may be formed for the purpose of constructing improvements in the public right -of -way. / 4. With reference to the adopted pedestrian walkway and bikeway system, curb and gutter is required for all new construction by City Code, Section 19 -98. Rolled curb is to be used at the edge ri5 of street paving in the West End. 5. The site plan should indicate a site for dumpsters or trash containers which is located on the applicant's property and not in the alley right -of -way. 6. There are existing lilac bushes which may be in the alley right -of -way. The applicant may want to consider removing the lilacs for improving the alley function. STAFF COMMENTS: Proposal - The applicant proposes to remodel an existing 4 bedroom, approximately 2878 square foot home. The remodel will decrease the number of bedrooms from four to two, add a two car garage, and provide a 360 square foot attached accessory dwelling unit. Conditional Use Review - Pursuant to Section 7 -304 the criteria for a conditional use review are as follows: A. The conditional use is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives and standards of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan, and with the intent of the Zone District in which it is in; and RESPONSE: The proposed attached accessory dwelling unit will be approximately 360 square feet. Although the dwelling unit is 100% above grade it is unnecessary for the applicant to request a floor area bonus. The unit will comply with the provisions of the Housing Guidelines. The unit will be deed restricted as a resident occupied unit for residents of Pitkin County. B. The conditional use is consistent and compatible with the character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and surrounding land uses, or enhances the mixture of complimentary uses and activities in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development; and RESPONSE: The proposed renovation and addition to the original residence is done in a traditional historic style reinforcing the original architectural character of the area. C. The location, size, design and operating characteristics of the proposed conditional use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, impacts on pedestrian and vehicular circulation, parking, trash, service delivery, noise, vibrations and odor on surrounding properties; and RESPONSE: The adu is attached to the main house by a mud room. The adu is designed to reflect the historic charm of the main house as well as creating a natural boundary for the south facing Victorian garden. The above grade adu should not have a negative impact upon the church located to the west of the parcel. The rear yard setback was increased due to neighborhood concern. D. There are adequate public facilities and services to serve the conditional use including but not limited to roads, potable water, sewer, solid waste, parks, police, fire protec- tion, emergency medical services, hospital and medical services, drainage systems, and schools; and RESPONSE: There are adequate facilities for this proposal. E. The applicant commits to supply affordable housing to meet the incremental need for increased employees generated by the conditional use; and RESPONSE: The proposal includes an affordable unit for employees of Pitkin County. An increase in employees is not expected by the provision of an accessory dwelling unit. F. The proposed conditional use complies with all additional standards imposed on it by the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and by all other applicable requirements of this chapter. RESPONSE: The conditional use meets the requirements of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and other requirements of this chapter. The proposal is well within floor area requirements and does not seek a floor area bonus. The applicant requested and was granted, by the HPC, a side yard setback variance and combined front and rear yard setback variance. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the conditional use for the attached accessory dwelling unit with the following conditions that prior to the issuance of any building permits: a. a deed restriction shall be reviewed and approved by the Housing Authority, the applicant shall record the deed restriction with the Pitkin County Clerk, Recorders Office and Planning Department. The restriction shall state that the accessory unit meets the housing guidelines for such units, meets the definition of Resident Occupied Unit, and if rented, shall be rented for periods of six months or longer. b. all representations that are made in the application and those 3 reviewed and approved by the Historic Preservation Committee and Planning and Zoning Commission shall be complied with. C. the applicant shall demonstrate to the Engineering Department that the historic drainage patterns shall be maintained on -site. d. the applicant shall consult City Engineering for design considerations of development within public rights -of -way and shall obtain permits for any work or development within public rights - of -way from City Streets Department. e. a five foot wide pedestrian usable space must remain unobstructed between the property line and the edge of pavement. e. the applicant shall agree to join any future improvement districts which may be formed for the purpose of constructing, ell improvements in the public right -of-wa - 7 rolled curb shall be mot -zd * *h f *reet ^ °°i n^ g. the site plan shall indicate a place for dumpsters or trash containers which is located on the applicant's property and not in the alley right -of -way. ATTACHMENTS: Site Plans /�W: o P at i a� 0 IP J 5 ) 6 4 �L 4 �j M livi E ti VV i EXHIBIT 'D' - irl. GO MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN LIEN r HCLL 4 A. 0- V- my VO44 ;1 I , Fvq W LIAU Y4rC44C-f4 - -TLJL-f , / Vlt4ff4r, Furalo Wall - irl. GO MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN �I u A IZ C: - r I PAIM OWN M' N 77 ZL A --I rn Q T'� T' I i c h Z I I I •: I i n ' A n i C 3 �.w J 2 m Z IK m r w 'oi oi l pp e' s �o� n z O y m r w 'oi oi l pp e' s �o� II I fi� --- - -- T � - - -- z �I i J I 0 I ZI �-- � I I� +�,r ..., ,�,.a L r a s 0 i II 1 I P ' I 4 _ 0 T X z s I e). W I f�K � Sai 1A &H r WeLL I G�,AGE WGLL 02 � f�NcH 8 V J r 41NIN6 �M LIVIM& Ra7M - Irv. c;o MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN its ^ —, •_o^ MLYoIG 1 o 8 V J r 41NIN6 �M LIVIM& Ra7M - Irv. c;o MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN its ^ —, •_o^ MLYoIG -� -��, �o � ..., i I I I I I I X9.00 BASEMENT FLOOR PLAN I I MEMORANDUM TO: Housing Director FROM: Leslie Lamont, Planning Director RE: Bellina Conditional Use Review for an Accessory Dwelling Unit DATE: June 5, 1991 Attached for your review and comments is an application from Joseph & Delia Bellina requesting Conditional Use approval for an Accessory Dwelling Unit. Please return your comments to me no later than June 14, 1991. Thanks. r "\ ASPEN /PITRIN PLANNING OFFICE 130 S. Galena Street Aspen, Colorado 81611 (303) 920 -5090 FAX# (303) 920 -5197 June 5, 1991 Cinderella Norris Charles Cunniffe & Associates 520 East Hyman Avenue, Suite 301 Aspen, CO 81611 Re: Bellina Conditional Use Review Dear Cinderella, This is to inform you that the Planning Office has completed its preliminary review of the captioned application. We have determined that this application is complete. We have scheduled this application for review at a public hearing by the Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission on Tuesday, July 2, 1991 at a meeting to begin at 4:30 pm. The Friday before the meeting date, we will call to inform you that a copy of the memo pertaining to the application is available at the Planning Office. Please note that it is your responsibility to post the subject property with a sign for the public hearing and to mail notice to property owners within 300' of the subject property. If you have any questions, please call Leslie Lamont, the planner assigned to your case. Sincerely, Debbie Skehan, Office Manager NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS RE: BELLINA CONDITIONAL USE REVIEW FOR AN ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held on Tuesday, July 2, 1991 at a meeting to begin at 4:30 pm before the Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission, 2nd Floor Meeting Room, 130 South Galena Street, Aspen, Colorado to consider an application submitted by Joseph & Delia Bellina requesting Conditional Use approval for a 520 sq. ft. attached Accessory Dwelling Unit. The property is located at 716 West Francis Street, Lots N & O and the West 15 feet of Lot P, Block 15, City and Townsite of Aspen. For further information, contact the Aspen /Pitkin Planning office, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen, CO 920 -5090. s /Jasmine TVCre, Vice - Chairman Planning and Zoning Commission . xxTnatr -tF�rr 1 , `�.. -IAND Use APPLICATION FOPM .. ,. 1) rmject. Nate Bel l ina Residence 2) Project location 716 West Francis St., Lots N & 0 and the West 15 feet of Lot P Block 15 City and Townsite of Aspen. (indicate street address, lot & block number, legal descripti whex appropriate) ' 3) Present Zoning R -6 4) lot size 7500 sq.ft. s) Applicant's Frame, Address & Phone # Joseph & Delia Bell ina ' Suite 810 One'Galleria Blvd Metairie LA 70001 (504) 861 -4903' 6) nepresentative's Name, Addzess & stone # Charles Cunniffe &Associates 520 E. Hyman, Suite 301, Aspen, CC 81611 (303) 925 - 5590 7 Type of Application (please chock all that apply): Oorditi_onal Use ConeepWal SPA _ Conceptual Historic Dev. !ll-- special Paview Final SPA _ Final Historic Dev. 8040 Green line stream Margin •. ._... � Minor Historic Dev. Historic Demolition Historic Designation („4QS All otment Final FUD mo mtain View Plane _ subdivision ' i rd i na tion 2tct/Map T•^"Malen _ lot split/lot Line _ Cm2s lion. _ Adjustment 8) De<¢iption of Odst•ing Uses •(number and type of cnst ; approodmate sq. ft.; rrtmber of bedrooms: any pxevicus approvals granted to the- property)- 1 Residence, approximately 2878 sq ft of existing FAR 4 existing bedrooms 9) Description of Development Application Alterations and addition to 2 story residence including 2 car garag and an attached accessory dwelling unit. lo) iLave you attached the follwincf- Response to Attadtment 2, Minimum Wxmi<c CUcttent- pesponse to Attadtment 3, Specific S db —icn COtterlt: Iaesponse to Attachment 4, rteviev Standards for Your Applicatican �Y �4 iu b To Basalt EXHIBIT 'C' N a °j► ( u U n.' ♦ t x�.. '� % Music p �� i Hallam ,A aro °„ pIR!'l_ICP`T 1 Af�ATle%M 7 Y 6 W. FRANCIS ST. a Aspen NDa" MuW 80001 9S Aeo s a of To VICINITY MAP CHARLES CUNNIFFE & ASSOCIATES /ARCHRECfS P.O. BOX 3539. ASPEN. COLORADO 81612 TELEPHONE 303 /925 -55911 CHARLES CUNNIFFE &ASSOCIAT - 9 /ARCHITECTS 520 EAST HYMAN, SUITE 301, ASPEN, CO. 81612 303/925 -5590 CHARLES L. CUNNIFFE, A.I.A. May 14, 1991 CONDITIONAL USE GENERAL APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS A. Letter of Consent by applicant is attched as Exhibit 'A' B. The street address and legal description of the parcel of the proposed project is; 716 West Francis Street Lots N & O and the West 15 feet of Lot P Block 15, City and Townsite of Aspen C. Disclosure of Ownership is attached as Exhibit 'B' D. A Vicinity Map for the area in which the site is located is attached as Exhibit 'C E. A Site Plan locating the attached A.D.U. is Exhibit 'D' F. Floor plans and Elevations indicating the proposed development, and proposed conditions are attached as Exhibit 'E' G. STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE The proposed development consists of additions and alterations to an existing two story residence including a two car garage and an attached Accessory Dwelling Unit. This proposed development will have little effect on the original historic structure with the exception of 4 gable dormers which have been added to the second floor to provide adequate headroom. The new elements, a 2 car garage with master bath above, and a mudroom connecting the main house t a 520 sq.ft. Accessory Dwelling Unit are situated at the north end of the property. There is also a full basement under the main house which requires light wells with egress to be provided. One of the light wells extends beyond the setback. However, the H.P.C. Committee found, that in order to meet their concerns and requirements, as well as those of adjacent property owners, that would not be a problem and we received unanimous approval. The proposed renovation and addition to the original residence, done in traditional historic style, reinforces the original Architectural character while at the same time providing a much more useable dwelling by modern standards. In keeping with the character of residences in the surrounding neighborhood, this renovation clearly enhances rather than detracts from the Victorian flavor prevalent through out the entire west end. CHARLES CUNNIFFE &ASSOCIATES /ARCHITECTS 520 EAST HYMAN, SUITE 301, ASPEN, CO. 81612 303/925 -5590 CHARLES L. CUNNIFFE, A.1 A. The small studio A.D.U., attached to the main house by a mud room, reflects the historic charm of the main house as well as creating a natural boundary for the south facing Victorian garden (which screens out the alley) . A wrap around porch along the west facade of the main house which dies in to the A.D.U. further enhances the garden atmosphere. As indicated by Exhibit 'E', the proposed F.A.R. is well within code requirements. We meet all setback requirements with the exception of a light well projecting into the easlt setback (as previously mentioned). There are adequate public facilities and services to serve the conditional use A.D.U. This development not only meets the goals, objectives and standards of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan, but also clearly enhances the character of the immediate vicinity. c: \wp5 \clients \9101 \app.req CHARLES CUNNIFFE &ASSOCIAi'&J/ARCHITECTS 520 EAST HYMAN, SUITE 301, ASPEN, CO. 81612 303/925 -5590 CHARLES L. CUNNIFFE, A.I.A. EXHIBIT E -8 BELLINA RESIDENCE PROPOSED CONDITIONS Lot Area F.A.R. Allowable A.D.U. Basement Main Level Upper Level Total Floor Area 7500 sq.ft. 3450 sq.ft. 520 sq.ft. 62.4 sq.ft. 1452 sq.ft. 608 soft. 2642.4 sq.ft. Maximum Height Parking Allowable Site Coverage Actual Site Coverage 17' -6" 3 Spaces 4875 sq.ft. 3137 sq.ft. Recordedat dciock_ #329932 02/01/91 1407 Ree $5.00 BK 630 PG 961 N Reception No. - -- 5i lVi e. Davi pitkin Cnt: Clerk, P-7 4.00 01 1 IT QUIT CLAIM DEED "i'x ' ■ y XHI 40 a de �' THIS DEED, Mathis a,� day r of Jruory .1991. O• �W! brtxeen JCHa R. dcn l "PY lu C ::G.fY . K. diii l iY - i O I nr the cmmi ,d FStkin amt state of CntoreJn, granuMsC and '_ I• 1 _I IRC CtiPIT.,L CCRFOHarI01t O' a x, , i xhnse legal dJrta i+ P.O. BOX 207, !•.S ?'t, C010rnd0 8161 yy .0 7 ! or the County of PS t k l n and Staw of Colorad,. grantee(s), i 4 �1 aa a p L. K WITNISSEI N. Thai the gmmo,11k tor ..din consid+rmi,n of the um of TEI\ DOLLl1i3 - Yd1d1 AM II j the receipt and 1ums iency or which it herth) acknowledged, have notowd, mkuwf • wild. eovi W QURCLAIMED. W by Li E i I d,e.e present, do rtmi.e• release, ml:. a piny and QUIT CLAIM unto the golnw'tA 1 t 1 8 lairs. atamsola W aulgna, M W forever. all the right, title, mterrm. claim and demaial which the gnmorlw) his Vein W an the teal properly togNhu with i improsements• if any, snuaie. lying and being in the County of Pitkln and state of 1 Colorado, descrihed an fuilown: j Lots N and 0, and the 'West 15 feet of Lot P, II Block 19, CITY i.iD 1OWNS1T:: OF ASFLh County of Pitkin, Stete of Colorado t. I 'z , al.n known by svu,r .nd number aw. 716 W. Francls btreet, "pen II. TO IIAVE AND TO HOLD the unw. together with all and +insular :he appurtenatw wo es and privileges lher ea belonging W to I anywim lhereuMU appertaining. andallthemnar. right. title. inkiest aralclairo whata .Oftbrgrantnrlal either In lwvaequltyb f' the only proper use. berklit W brhouf of the gnnarvA I t 1 S brim W wsigm forever. f INWffNFSSWHEREOF. ThegramonsihaVE e,lnvlM this JeeJ ,n the Jarc .et fattA nhne. 1 jl Jo ,n H. Lfesitty Rohyri K. Beatty' by JohnH. 1, Mnnlr„ n ««�w.,no ,e I-..« . R '� IN CU s STATL OF COLORADO, w i %a. ti 'x counlyof FStkin 11 The RwepJng lnslromem wt, ackmxkrlgcd brkae me dJs aV' dayof Jnru#ry • t ., '' by JOHI; R. B:,R "rY AI'L, ,;Cal. .1. do :•f5Y �.. . , :G :uwsY lA Fi,C'f r titi FOH HOJY,1 N. dG/•. I ,+ �• My commisskm expires S '' 3 93 . l4 . Witness my hand W official seal co x C , PUD •IrCf llensrr,Irt,eA �f.!ty W." I` Frcco ,I, \0. 1,1y. grx lAl. ylge.l.om W ", � .` W.mre PNaowua.qu w.w.V,lw�nu. u•w.vC �w•, rq. — leY J � j '91 02/14 10:01 '$303 -920 -2465 JOHN R BEATTY Q1002 'EXHIBIT 'B -2' JOHN R. BEATTY 716 W. Francis, Aspen CO 81611 February 14, 1991 Planning Office, City Of Aspen, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen CO 81611 Dear Sir /Madam: Re: 716 W__ Francis Asp en IRC Capital Corporation is the owner of Lots N 8 O and the West 15 feet of Lot P, Block 15, known as 716 W. Francis Street, Aspen. This is to confirm that pursuant to the terms of the contract executed between IRC Capital Corp and Joseph Bellina, Joseph Bellina is authorized to make application for development and planning approvals with respect to the above property. Please note that this authority is subject to the contract,, and that IRC Capital Corporation is itself in no way bound by the terms of any application or representations made and in the event that the contract does not close will not be bound by any approvals obtained, representations made or undertakings given. Sincerely, John R. Beatty President CHARLES CUNNIFFE &ASSOCIATES /ARCHITECTS 520 EAST HYMAN, SUITE 301, ASPEN, CO. 81611 303/925-5590 w � EXHIBIT" 'A' CHARLES L CUNNIFFE, A.I.A. February 8, 1991 To Whom It May Concern, As potential Owners of Lots N & O and the west 15 feet of Lot P, Block 15, or 716 W. Francis St., Aspen, we authorize Charles Cunniffe & Associates /Architects, 520 E. Hyman Ave., Suite 301, Aspen, Colorado, (303) 925 -5590, to represent our interests in the development, and historic designation of the above mentioned property. Sincerp3)y, Josep,�' &ki Bellina 1 Ga� esia Blvd., Suite 810 Metr��rie, Louisiana 70001 • 4 CHARLES CUNNIFFE &ASSOCIATES /ARCHITECTS 520 EAST HYMAN SUITE 301 ASPEN CO 81611 303/925 -5590 May 14, 1991 CHARLES L CUNNIFFE AIA Leslie Lamont Planning Office 130 S. Galena St. Aspen, Colorado 81611 Re: 716 West Francis Aspen, Colorado Dear Leslie, W1410 Please find enclosed an application for Conditional Use for an above grade attached Accessory Dwelling Unit. If you have any questions, please contact us. Sin Cinderella Norris Project Manager