Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLand Use Case.CU.1470 Red Butte Dr.A21-96 CASV' 'AD SUMMARY SHEET - CITY OF.' ~PEN DATE RECENED: 3/18/96 DATE COMPLETE: PARCEL II) # 2735-013-02-003 CASE # A21-96 STAFF: Dave Michaelson PROJECT NAME: Silverman Residence,Conditional Use ADU with Stream Margin Review Project Address: 1470 Red Butte Drive, Aspen, CO APPLICANT: Silverman, Dr. Barry Address/Phone: c/o Stan Mathis REPRESENTATNE: Mathis, Stan Address/Phone: P.O. Box 1912, Basalt, CO 81621; 927-3415 FEES: PLANNING ENGINEER HOUSING ENV HEALTH TOTAL $1050 $0 $0 $0 $1050 # APPS RECENED 12 # PLATS RECENED 12 TYPE OF APPLICATION: One Step P&Z CC CC (2nd readin ) es DYes DYes REFERRALS: o City Attorney gCity Engineer o Zoning IZ}Housing (~-J-~ "31~v ") o Environmental Health JL9. Parks o Aspen Fire Marshal o City Water o City Electric o Clean Air Board o Open Space Board o Other: DATE REFERRED: --..!J/l.IJqt; INITIALS: /CH o CDOT o ACSD o Holy Cross Electric o Rocky Mtn Natural Gas o Aspen School District o Other: , DATE DUE: ~2Ap./~) OrdinanceIResolution # Staff Approval Plat Recorded: APPROVAL: Date: Date: Book , Page CLOSED/FlLED ROUTE TO: DATE: INITIALS: ,."- '--" ... RESOLUTION OF THE ASPEN PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FOR THE APPROVAL OF THE SILVERMAN STREAM MARGIN REVIEW LOCATED AT 1470 RED BUTTE DRIVER (LOT 2, BLOCK 1, RED BUTTE SUBDIVISION) Resolution No. 96-11- WHEREAS, Dr. Barry Silverman submitted for approval to the Commission an application for Stream Margin Review for the construction of a new single family residence; and WHEREAS, the Planning staff received referral comments from the Engineering Department, Water Department and the Parks Department, and upon consideration of those comments recommended approval of the Stream Margin Review with conditions; and WHEREAS, the Commission reviewed and approved the Stream Margin Review with conditions by a 4-0 vote on April 2, 1996; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Commission that it does hereby approve the Silverman Stream Margin Review with conditions as follows: 1. Prior to the issuance of any building permits, a landscaping plan shall be submitted for review and approval by the Parks Department. Tree removal permits shall be required for the removal or relocation of any tree greater than 6" caliper. 2. The building envelope shall be amended to exclude the existing trees, as shown on the attached site plan (Exhibit "A"). No vegetation shall be manipulated outside of the envelope. 3. The trees adjacent to the building envelope shall be protected during construction by barricades at the driplines. 4. The building envelope shall be barricaded prior to issuance of any building permits. The City Engineer shall visit the site and approve the location of the barricades prior to any excavation or construction. 5. Silt fencing shall be used during construction to prevent runoff from disturbed soils from entering the river. Revegetation is required for any disturbed soil on the site. 6. If dedicating a fishing easement along the river, the easement shall follow the 100 year floodplain lline across the property from east to west and shall continue down to the property line in the river. 7. The applicant shall abandon the existing water line on the property if the new residence will not be constructed within 6 months after the existing residence is demolished. ....... ....~ , , 8. All material representations made by the applicant in the application and during public meetings with the Planning and Zoning Commission shall be adhered to and considered conditions of approval, unless otherwise amended by other conditions. APPROVED by the Commission at its regular meeting on April 2, 1996. ATTEST: PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: S:C:Utk ~ Sara Garton, Chair ~ ,..-- . i; . EXHIBIT A !':.< ':>tn.. 'l>I!.orloN ""-' ----------...~... . Rq..,R.INc, f=~ kJv~ 5 Cp/' oe.' E: 1'7'1.!7L' . .If ". "~"~'. ~"'~R_~,.. ----...:--~~,/.:e-----=. ____. ~ (-------- ~~. ., :...--" 1-1 _"~~_.. . . 1;="'-=-0:?:-;~:;'-'~:?~7-- ,.\~~~~." ._ '''-:: " / rJe>6'?". .~- ij /"'--:::::. ""~l'J.i1\lff - " I \ .:3 . ..,,.~ ~ ~ ,::'f~' \ ,-.-- ....".1_."_.::. ' --..........,j ~--. -----------..... -)--~- D ____ . ~~ ~~ ~~p~ """"""'~ - / . /~ '. . . . >-.. ....... # rt.4t.l,.~ , _ :.:.~" ""'~ , l"Jer.lS "!!:' _ _ ~ .---., --.... '.. ,rp~ \... -=- >-..., . ----/ - - -<::.. "" IS"....... /'----" , ~~ -c.......... -- \ .('-~'Z'J 1.7;. /.~--- ,'f I ./,~....... t&,~ ~~~ \ _.of~; f.:( /- "'" ....... ~ - - /: .~ ~i-l I -.... ~ ~:' i', , ~. ~_. --..u .'.// -- ~ I ... "'.irp, 00 ~~" tsoV",o", , - -> I : "'''I'-fi'O YI'- ,__ I I -1 ~ ,_ ~ -. \. ~,. OVelt.H^N , _~ 'N1! rTIoloJ _ . '" ~. . 't- I 11// i / J 1:' !"l~:' '~"'" Ij/ '. :..' ')' . .~; " .t. ".-- , , .i ". ~.. .. ,/( ," i .' , , , . . . . ~ ., . . I " ~ l , ~l ~ i l . . . t 7) ~I"!""""'" ~ / ~I -L__ \/~ 'dl ~-4- / ~...../ IIIB MEMORANDUM 'b, i~ C:,!' TO: Planning and Zoning Commission FROM: Suzanne Wolff, Planner RE: Silverman Conditional Use Review For an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) and Stream Margin Review - Public Hearing DATE: April 2, 1996 SUMMARY: The applicant is requesting conditional use approval to construct an ADU and stream margin review approval to develop a new single-family residence on the lot. The studio ADU is located on the main level of the proposed new residence, and contains approximately 384 square feet. Both the existing and the proposed residences are located within 100 feet of the high water line of the Roaring Fork River. The application packet is attached as Exhibit A. Staff recommends approval of the conditional use for an accessory dwelling unit and stream margin review with conditions. APPLICANT: Dr. Barry Silverman, represented by Stan Mathis LOCATION: 1470 Red Butte Drive; Lot 2, Block 1, Red Butte Subdivision ZONING: R-30 LOT SIZE: 30,056 square feet FAR: Allowed = 5400 square feet; Proposed = 5200 square feet BACKGROUND: REFERRAL COMMENTS: Please see comments from the Housing Office (Exhibit B). Verbal comments from the Engineering, Parks and Water Departments are included below; written comments should be available at the meeting. Housing Office: Cindy Christensen has reviewed the project, and notes that the unit has a private entrance and is located on the upper level of the residence. The Housing Office recommends approval subject to the following conditions: . The kitchen shall include a minimum of a two-burner stove with oven, standard sink, and a 6-cubic foot refrigerator plus freezer. . The unit shall be deed-restricted prior to building permit approval. Parks Department: The existing trees should be located outside of the building envelope. Any removal of trees will require a tree removal/relocation permit. A landscape plan shall be approved by Parks prior to issuance of any building permits. Silt fencing shall be used during construction to prevent runoff from disturbed soils from entering the river. Parks requests that the owner dedicate a fishing easement along the river. Engineering Department: No development shall occur outside of the building envelope. Construction procedures shall insure that runoff from disturbed soil does not drain into the river. Any disturbed soil on the site shall be revegetated. Water Department: Phil Overeynder requests that the applicant abandon the existing water line on the property if the new residence will not be constructed within 6 months after the existing residence is demolished. STAFF COMMENTS: Conditional Use Review - Pursuant to Section 26.60.040, the criteria for a conditional use review are as follows: A. The conditional use is consistent with the purposes, goals, objectives and standards of the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan, and with the intent of the Zone District in which it is purposed to be located; RESPONSE: A fundamental goal of the Aspen Area Community Plan is to "Create housing opportunities for 60% of the workforce to live up-valley of the Aspen Village Trailer Park". A short-term goal with the Housing Action Plan was to develop "650 new affordable housing units, including employee-occupied ADUs to achieve the identified current unmet need to sustain a critical mass of residents". Staff notes that an additional goal included the revision of the ADU program to require registration and deed restrictions of all ADUs. The ADUs, as depicted, exceeds the minimum net livable requirement of 300 square feet. The unit must comply with the Housing Guidelines and shall be deed restricted as a resident occupied unit for working residents of Pitkin County. The property is zoned R-30 (low density residential). Lands in the R-30 zone are typically located along river frontages in outlying areas of the City. B. The conditional use is consistent and compatible with the character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and surrounding land uses, or enhances the mixture of complimentary uses and activities in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposedfor development; 2 RESPONSE: In staffs opinion, the proposed ADU does not represent an incompatible use with the neighborhood. The Red Butte Subdivision Protective Covenants apparently prohibit accessory dwelling units. The applicant must resolve this issue with the homeowners' association. If the subdivision does prohibit the accessory dwelling unit, the applicant must provide a cash-in-lieu to the Housing Office. C. The location, size, design and operating characteristics of the proposed conditional use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, impacts on pedestrian and vehicular circulation, parking, trash, service delivery, noise, vibrations and odor on surrounding properties; RESPONSE: The unit is completely contained within the proposed residence. The unit meets the overall objective of livability; the unit is above grade, obtains adequate natural light, and has a separate exterior entry. The unit can also be accessed through the interior of the residence. One parking space is required for the ADU; parking is provided off of the driveway. D. There are adequate public facilities and services to serve the conditional use including but not limited to roads, potable water, sewer, solid waste, parks, police, fire protection, emergency medical services, hospital and medical services, drainage systems, and schools; RESPONSE: No additional infrastructure is required for the ADU above and beyond what is in place for the existing neighborhood. E. The applicant commits to supply affordable housing to meet the incremental needfor increased employees generated by the conditional use; RESPONSE: The ADU must be deed restricted for resident occupancy. If the unit is rented, it must be used to house a qualified working resident of Pitkin County. F. The proposed conditional use complies with all additional standards imposed on it by the Aspen Area Comprehensive Plan and by all other applicable requirements of this chapter. RESPONSE: The proposed units are required by Ordinance 1, and must be deed restricted. Stream Margin Review: Pursuant to Section 26.68.040(B), "No development shall be permitted within 100 feet, measured horizontally, from the high water line of the Roaring Fork River and its tributary streams, or within the Special Flood Hazard Area where it extends beyond 100 feet from the high water line of the Roaring Fork River and its tributary streams, unless the Commission makes a determination that the proposed development complies with all the standards set forth below:" 3 ._~ 1. It can be demonstrated that any proposed development which is in the Special Flood Hazard Area will not increase the base flood elevation on the parcel proposed for development. RESPONSE: The building envelope is located outside of the 100 year floodplain line, and the development will not increase the base flood elevation. 2. Any trail on the parcel designated on the Aspen Area Community Plan, ParksIRecreation/ Open Space/Jrails Plan map, or areas of historic public use or access are dedicated via a recorded easement for public use. RESPONSE: Not applicable. 3. The recommendations of the Roaring Fork Greenway Plan are implemented in the proposed plan for development, to the greatest extent practicable; RESPONSE: Red Butte Subdivision is not located within the area considered under the Roaring Fork Greenway Plan, though it is located across the Roaring Fork River from the Rio Grande Trail. Parks has requested that the owner dedicate a fishing easement. 4. There is no vegetation removed or damaged or slope grade changes (cut or fill) made outside of a specifically defined building envelope. A building envelope shall be designated by this review and said envelope shall be barricaded prior to issuance of any demolition, excavation or building permits. The barricades shall remain in place until the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. RESPONSE: The applicant has designated an envelope on the site plan. Staff recommends that the envelope be amended to exclude the existing trees. The applicant agrees not to manipulate any vegetation outside of the envelope, and to barricade the envelope prior to issuance of any building permits. 5. The proposed development does not pollute or inteifere with the natural changes of the river, stream or other tributary, including erosion and/or sedimentation during construction. Increased on-site drainage shall be accommodated within the parcel to prevent entry into the river or onto its banks. Pools or hot tubs cannot be drained outside of the designated building envelope; RESPONSE: The proposed residence will not impact the river, and safeguards will be utilized during construction to prevent pollution of the river. Drainage shall be directed away from the river. 6. Written notice is given to the Colorado Water Conservation Board prior to any alteration or relocation of a water course, and a copy of said notice is submitted to the Federal Emergency Management Agency; 4 ,_.~ RESPONSE: Not applicable. 7. A guarantee is provided in the event a water course is altered or relocated, that applies to the developer and his heirs, successors and assigns that ensures that the flood carrying capacity on the parcel is not diminished; RESPONSE: Not applicable. 8. Copies are provided of all necessary federal and state permits relating to work within the 100 year floodplain; RESPONSE: All work will take place outside of the 100 year floodplain. 9. There is no development other than approved native vegetation planting taking place below the top of slope or within 15 feet of the top of slope or the high waterline, whichever is most restrictive, RESPONSE: Staff visited the site and confirmed that the property does not have a distinct "top of slope". therefore, no development other than approved native vegetation planting shall take place within 15 feet of the high waterline. 10. All development outside the 15 foot setbackfrom the top of slope does not exceed a height delineated by a line drawn at a 45 degree angle from ground level at the top of slope, RESPONSE: The attached site section shows the development's compliance with this requirement. 11. A landscape plan is submitted with all development applications, Such plan shall limit new plantings outside of the designated building envelope on the river side to native riparian vegetation; RESPONSE: The site plan includes the existing landscaping. A more detailed landscape plan shall be approved by the Parks Department prior to issuance of any building permits. Only approved native vegetation may be planted. 12. All exterior lighting is low and downcast with no light(s) directed toward the river or located down the slope; RESPONSE: The applicant agrees to comply with this requirement. 5 13. Site sections drawn by a registered architect, landscape architect, or engineer are submitted showing all existing and proposed site elements, the top of slope. and pertinent elevations above sea level; RESPONSE: See attached application (Exhibit "B"). 14. There has been accurate identification of wetlands and riparian zones. RESPONSE: The proposed envelope avoids any wetland or riparian areas. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval ofthe ADU and the stream margin review with the following conditions: 1. Prior to the issuance of any building permits, the applicant shall comply with the following: A. The owner shall submit the appropriate deed restrictions to the Aspen/Pitkin County Housing Office for approval, Upon approval of the deed restrictions by the Housing Office, the applicant shall record the deed restrictions with the Pitkin County Clerk and Recorders Office with proof of recordation to the Planning Department. The deed restriction shall state that the accessory units meets the housing guidelines for such units, meets the definition of Resident Occupied Unit, and if rented, shall be rented for periods of six months or longer; and B. Kitchen plans shall be verified by the Housing Office to ensure compliance with specifications for kitchens in ADUs. 2. The ADU shall be clearly identified as a separate dwelling unit on building permit plans and shall comply with U.B.C. 35 sound attenuation requirements. 3. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Planning Department shall inspect the unit to ensure compliance with the conditions of approval. 4. If the accessory dwelling unit is prohibited by the subdivision, the applicant must provide the applicable cash-in-lieu payment to the Housing Office prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for the residence. 5, All new surface utility needs and pedestals must be installed on-site. 6. Prior to the issuance of any building permits, a landscaping plan shall be submitted for review and approval by the Parks Department. Tree removal permits shall be required for the removal or relocation of any tree greater than 6" caliper. 6 7. The building envelope shall be amended to exclude the existing trees. No vegetation shall be manipulated outside of the envelope, and the envelope shall be barricaded prior to issuance of any building permits. 8. Silt fencing shall be used during construction to prevent runoff from disturbed soils from entering the river. Revegetation is required for any disturbed soil on the site. 9. If dedicating a fishing easement along the river, the applicant shall contact the Parks Department to determine the appropriate location. 10. The applicant shall abandon the existing water line on the property if the new residence will not be constructed within 6 months after the existing residence is demolished. 11. All material representations made by the applicant in the application and during public meetings with the Planning and Zoning Commission shall be adhered to and considered conditions of approval, unless otherwise amended by other conditions. RECOMMENDED MOTION: "I move to approve the conditional use for an ADU and the stream margin review at 1470 Red Butte Drive with the conditions as outlined in the Planning Office Memo dated April 2, 1996". Exhibits: "A" - Referral Comments "B" - Application Packet 7 MRR 25 '96 03:26PM P.l ..,~, EXHIBIT A MEMORANDUM FROM: Suzanne Wolff, Community Development Dept. Cindy Christensen, Housing Office TO: DATE: March 25, 1996 RE: Silverman Conditional Use for ADU ParcellD No. 2735-013-02.003 ISSUE: The applicant is requesting to build an attached accessory dwelling unit (ADU). The unit is proposed to be 100% above grade, BACKGROUND: The size of the accessory unit falls Within the guidelines of the Code: Acce8110rY dwelilg un~s sI1aK canlllin not lees than three hundred (3110) sqUllre feet of allowable floor al8a and not mOle then seven hundred (700) &quare feel of alloWllble floor al'llll. The un~ ohall be deed restrloled, meeting lhe hgusinS 8uthorily's guldel"es for lesident occupied un1tlland "hllll be Imiled 10 flIntsl perlads of not IM8 than olx (6) monllla in dlWation, OWners of lhe principBl IMidenc:e shaO have the right to place a qU8lifled employee or employeeS of Ilis 01' her -Oil in the lICC...ory dwellng unit. The kitchen must also be built to the following specifications: KItchen _ FOI Accessory Dwelling Unilts and C8retllker DweI!i1g Units. a minimum of e two-bumer stove wftI\ oven, standard sink, and a &-cubic fool refrfgellllOr plus freezer, RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval as long as the following conditions are met: 1, 1he kitchen is as stated above; and 2. an accessory dwelling unit deed res1rictlon needs to be reoorded before building permit approval; this form is provided by the Housing Office, Irefi>moll&lvnnt1.adu MEMORANDUM To: Dave Michaelson, Planner Via: Nick Adeh, City Enginee~a From: Ross C. Soderstrom, Project Engineer IC5 Date: March 28, 1996 Re: Silverman Stream Margin Review and Conditional Use Review for an ADU (1490 Red Butte Drive; Lot 2, Block 1, Red Butte Subdivision, City of Aspen, CO) After reviewing the above referenced application and making a site visit I have the following comments: 1. Flood Elevation: Prior to issuance of the building permit, the developer of this property shall show that the elevation (mean sea level; provide the name of the datum used) of the lowest floor, including basement, will be at least two feet (2 ft.) above the base line flood elevation as certified by an engineer or architect currently licensed in Colorado. The bottom floor elevation shall be shown on the improvement plans submitted for the building permit. 2. Trash & Utility Areas: The submitted site plan does not indicate locations for these facilities although they must be provided in an accessible area on the subject property. Water and electric utility meters and service connection points must be accessible to service personnel in the completed project and not obstructed by garbage or recycling containers or other structures. Any new surface utilities requiring a pedestal or other above ground equipment must be installed on an easement provided by the property owner and not located within the public right-of-way. Any required easements for utilities shall be shown on the final improvement plans and the easements shall be recorded prior to issuance of the building permit. 3. Site Drainage: The new development shall not release more than historic storm run-off flows from the site and any increase in historic storm run-off flows must be first routed and detained on the site. A copy of the soils report must be submitted with the building permit application. The drainage pattern shall be shown on the final improvement plans submitted for the building permit. DRCM0596.DOC Memo - Silverman Stream Margin Review and Conditional Use Review for an ADU 4, Sidewalk Area: The property owner will be required to file an agreement to construct curb. gutter and sidewalks along the Red Butte Drive frontage in the future although none is planned at this time. A five ft. (5 ft.) sidewalk "area" should remain unobstructed by improvements including fences. landscape boulders, vegetation; e.g. any new trees must be located to provide space for and alignment of the future sidewalk with the neighboring sidewalk routes to (lither side. The pedestrian usable space shall be shown on the final development plan. The curb, gutter and sidewalk agreement shall be execuled and recorded prior to issuance of the C.O. for the project. i 5. Water Service: If a building permit for the proposed new construction for the site is not issued within six (6) months of this application approval, the existing water service line will need to be abandoned and removed from the property back to the corporation connection of the municipal water distribution system per Water Dept. requirements. An entirely new water service line would then be required when the new construction is begun. The existing water service line may be used if a building permit is issued for the site within the next six (6) months assuming that the line is in good repair and serviceable as determined by the City Water Dept. at the time of the building permit application. 6, Fisherman's Easement: The property owner will be required to dedicate and record a fishelman's access easement as specified by the City Parks Dept. prior is issuance of a C.O. for the project. Refer to the City Parks Dept. for specific details (i.e. alignment, width, etc.) of the easement. 7, Erosion Control: Prior to issuance of the building permit, the developer of this prope11y "ill be required to submit a construction plan detailing the construction techniques to be used, erosion and sedimentation control during and after construction. No disturbance shall be permitted of the existing vegetation on the stream-side of the development envelope shown on the site plans submitted for this review. The non-disturbance line shall be shown on the improvement plans submitted for the building permit application and the non-disturbance line, established with construction fencing prior to construction, shall be securely maintained until issuance of a C.O. for the project. 8, Improvement Survey: The submitted improvement survey needs to have the following items corrected or shown prior to issuance of the building permit: A. Complete an improvement survey plat per standards of 38-51 C.R.S. The improvement survey plat must be properly titled as such; signed in the Surveyor's certificate which evidences supervision of the survey and compliance with title 38, article 51, CRS, 1973; and stamped by a surveyor currently licensed in Colorado. The plat shall include the title insurance certificate number, date of issuance and name of the issuing title company. The title insurance certificate must have been issued within one (1) prior to the date of the improvement survey plat. 2 DRCM0596.DOC Memo - Silverman Stream Margin Review and Conditional Use Review for an ADU ---- B. IdentifY the probable location and reason for the lhree ft. (3 ft.) closure bust identified in the notes for the improvement survey. Show both recorded and measured bearings and distances for the property boundaries. C. Use a distinctive symbol to designate the fence along the northwest property line. Same symbol presently used for survey monuments and the fence line. D. Clearly identifY the type of utility boxes with arrowed notes or distinctive symbols. Same symbol presently used for all utility boxes. Existing utilities observed on site include electrical transformer, telephone pedestal, cable TV pedestal, electric meter pedestal, and fire hydrant. E. Provide the full dimensions of the curved portion of the property line along Red Butte Drive; Set a monument at the beginning of curve; incorporate the complete boundary survey data and correction of the 3 ft. bust in a revised plat map ofthe lot to be recorded prior to issuance of a building pem1it. F. Use three (3) distinctive line types to indicate the edge of water, mean high water and 15 ft. utility easement lines along the northeast property boundary. The submitted copy of the plat is too faint to clearly differentiate the three line types. Remove other extraneous lines or clearly identifY them. G. Use a font that clearly differentiates "I" from "I"; "2" from "Z"; etc. H. Provide full identifYing information for the two (2) spikes used to establish the basis of bearings. Also provide the bearing and distance of the tie from the nearer basis of bearings monument to the property boundary. I. Clearly and completely identifY the type of survey monuments found and set by type and recorded identifier, (i.e. "PLS #####" or "LS #####") along with defining distances and bearings. H. Use basis of bearings between two (2) City monuments within same city block, two (2) recorded subdivision monuments, or other recorded monuments, with distance & bearing to property boundary. 9, Improvement Districts: The property owner shall be required to agree to join any future improvement districts formed for the purpose of constructing improvements in adjacent public rights-of- way. The agreement shall be executed and recorded prior to issuance of the building permit for the project. 10, As-Builts: Prior to C.O. issuance the building permit applicant will be required to submit to the Aspen/Pitkin County Data Processing Dept. as-builts drawings for the project showing the property lines, building footprint, easements, encroachments, entry points for utilities entering the property boundaries and any other improvements. 3 DRCMOS96.DOC _~~_..~'__"'_"_"<'.'_"W____' Memo - Silverman Stream Margin Review and Conditional Use Review tor an ADU 11, Set-Back Encroachment: The proposed building footprint encroaches into the set-back area defined in the subdivision convenants on both the east and west sides of the property. The proposed building will need to be adjustec1 in orientation, size or both to fit within the permissible building area defined by the subdivision convenants. ! 4 DRCM0596.DOC -,. MEMORANDUM Via: /])'ave Michaelson, Planner Nick Adeh, City Engine~ Ross C. Soderstrom, Project Engineer )!t5 To: From: Date: April 8, 1996 Re: Additional Comments on Silverman Conditional Use Review for an ADU (1490 Red Butte Drive; Lot 2, Block 1, Red Butte Subdivision, City of Aspen, CO) In addition to the previous comments regarding this application, the City Water Dept. has made these comments (numbered consecutively with the previous comments): 12, City Water Service: Prior to issuance of the building permit, the property owner shall apply for an utility connection permit to establish municipal water service. It is the applicant's responsibility to construct a service line to the municipal water system. The property is not presently served by the city water system although it is within the City limits with municipal water service available in Red Butte Drive. 13, Water Well Abandonment: The property owner shall abandon and properly cap any existing water wells on the property in conjunction with establishing municipal water service. Section 23-55 of the City code requires that all water uses within the City be connected to the municipal system. Therefore, any private wells located on the property may not be maintained for domestic nor irrigation uses. DRCM5.96.DOC - ~""', AT:rAOi!IDll' a. 'U\ND usz APPLICATION ~ ~) Proj~ NaIre SIL-VJ:j2,jv'}6hl_J2\ehIPeNC:e, 2) Proj~ IDeation \ 0 0 OR UE. - LOT '2. P.,l. ~e..\::' ~U.,.,.~ 6UP"t::>I\JI?IC~ ~ A~P~, ~O, (irdicaw street address, lot: & blodc number, legal. d=iption YIhere appropri,: ::e) Present Zoni.rx; ~ -I '1 4) Lot Size ~ ) 0 SCp Applicant's NaIre, Address & Phone i tJt:<" BARRY <o\l.,\JE.~HAt-.\ c10 ~TA-~' MA'Tt-i''7 Representative's NaIre, Address & Phone : ~,A.N HA:'1*\~ - P.D. fxx 1~1'2. ~ASAI.:T , ~ot...o . ~llD21 - C"f7-0~ Q"l1--M-/'7 J) 5) 6) 7) Type of Application (please check all that apply) : >< corditiona1. Use COrceptual SPA Conc:eptual. Historic O<!v_ _ Special. ReYies.! Final. SPA Final. Historic O<!v_ 8040 Greenline Minor Historic D:.-v. correptual. fOD Final. roD -K stream Mllgin Historic Cem::llition Motmtain vies.! Plane SUl:d.i vision _ His"...Dric ~ignation corxl.cmini.umization _ TextfMap lImerxJment _ Lot SplitjIDt Line Mjust::nent _ QQ5 AllobDent _ QQ5 ~an 8) Des=-iption of Exi.s'"--ing Uses (I'.l.1l:lb>.r arrl t:ype of exis'"--ing structures; approximate sq. ft.; rwm-her of l=lLuu=; arr:{ previaJS approvals granted to t.'1e prope..rty) - A ~r..>c.~ F'A~ll."(' ~e':ltb~e of)..PF1FUJX, ''2400 '='.~ WI1'H 4 ~DP-aaM~ AIJO A ,::e..,..ACf+E.b t:\A.MI'...E. of b4D ?,p. 9) Des=-iption of Cevelq:uent Application . 1\:tI.., I:, A'NAEl:l-Il"~1l0lV ~ A COJJDIT'IOk)Af... lJ~ To AUDW AN A.. b.LJ. oF' APPI2e:>>< ~e4 c::"f. 1'b t.OOA1'e:O WHrtIN -rr-Ie APr'l.I~url'".7 -Ae'opo:.e.D 5)2.00 "S.f: ~ID~ tJ0l.\1cf\ ~b\R6~ ~ SiREAI1 KfTR.'1lfJ ~evle:vJ 10) Ha,? yoo attad1ed the follC<Jirg? . V _ Response to Attachment 2, Minin:um s\lhnic:c:ion COrrt:ents -V Response to Attac::hmerrt: J, Specific SlIhnic:c:iOl1 COrrt:ents ~ Response to Attad1me.'!t. 4, Review Stardards for: Yoor Ap91ication -- .<'<"" '-- M4'R(!jj~ IGl4G, Atb pt:1\l 11='/'""i1J, \ l-.l taP~-.--Lcr-___ ________________ CQt1HJ)~~~I.Ie.JJ2.fr:L~ c:.1'TY DF ASFel-.! I~o t:::>. aAL.e.l--!t\_c::,T~t;~I A~PeJJ I ~Q_\-oO~90 __~I~tL A'1""11-J! DAVE l1jg-lA.eL,~N __..._~ ~:_SIL-V~~_~kICAllQ\_.l _l=t>B_~J2I11a.lAL.. _C6E:. ~P. ___ :mf.t>.10 Iv1AP-CtLN F,t:.\J/6UJ _ _n __ _ _ t:'e:AfLQp.\J t:. ~.. _n___~~ ~Jd~NT CJ>B..~Y ~lt..\{~~~J:BoPQs.es T9._ un __ . ____~Qk1Sht:rJ_rE._ e.>'-J~J"lNc..J':tc:~)$c. A~PnJ.:;rar~!-+f:;rz_qA\2..A.oYe__ _____. _~J+to F2-€D _~u]:..l?fl.,L\.)e, JH:. Mf~-<:i~~-rr.e :=AMe _. n_n__n___~Tl9~ H~ P-RoFOs~_"'(QJ:~t.)IL.1? AJ..Jet-L#5z,OO:!: ~,p. ____ _._~ee.PRCOM_ ..R..e:~J~~ _ l'HA-r_ ~IL..L.AL':O ft-JCl.D~_A~~e4 i_<;. r. _ __. ___A::rllQ HW_PC1..)~L.J.,.ltJCtJ..ltJJT LA, B ~.)RJ_Ij_~()ANI ::'CQ___ ________ ~__ ___~~_~1~~___~IQ_~~-rH~k2~ t..AI\JD U"2f,.tqAWL.,4r11g,l~_. ________....-"1}I...B_W~OJ.)~,II,. ~~JCP.z. ~C~J:.~ ~e,~fj~ ______n~~_ l~et...\Ci\~L..E. ~AbL~ 5cNOS EQ6~Mrr l'o .... .__... ... __~.ci11Ql'l~2~JQ\ .__. _._ _______________________ .--.---- -- ---- ______..... _ ______11-te R<ef'..~QJ~~Of.DCi~~_~~~.L:'1't::l__~e.C[1 ClJ2..4-7. 504_ n_S~t1A-~IIJRf.VIt::IJ.)~lJ.l)~e. PO~loN~ a:11tE. _._ ~. l o~ ;; .-, ., V'!\lE,.LO'PMEN'f ~_~6A"'t:.D WrrH reo FeeT o'f -n+e. _~~ Ft.oOO 'eQUNQj<.."T':.__ ~~E.. F-1f'JC Ai\'Acl-\E:D ~I) r-1ltJ1M0M We.M17~IO~ l1u:QB ~ '\ .>11 AAlI" ~ <I nt> AJIII~ :rHA tvl~JDN . ~__f,.~;.,if.Q__"-:[~ ~ .~s -mu~MIPl-.)_EQ.fLM-rAa1M~~~M ____~CillLf<.e.V(E'.W~__tb\EP~Y1 MIeN, FoR, ..vrrAcJ.+/'1ENT 4 ~ ~NDlfJorJAL. lJc;,e ~. '?) Rf:.?f'Ot'Y7E, tD M"A0~ME-JJi -----.--+~M_~~IN.__~YL@J_~rAl--\'9,ARD~OO~~~__ -.. ________.:lP_hrrAdtMWL_B - _Ci~DIl100A.L._~LBe.\J (~_~~A~L_ . --. ......------ ~~~~_EO&. _'tco~_COt_.J~lt7e,g&TIl!? ~\_(~.L..:rfttc;;._J,1,6t'"'f'mB._ -__uBP::jTB~GAR~ -.------..-------~lf(4 ..,------- ~ '20'1. ,~ /...."'.- 1=<uf?CIJ~f. '"iO A"T'iAc.HMI:.t-.lT + ~kO~--'T IN S~M 118~jt--l \) ~~E. rwoo 'fj;"I,}A'TfOJ..j ~l("'L.. fJar~E..J~.&l~W~~_1H~ OE\}EJ.OfMf.JJT -1f-*~ I~ ~oJ:ZE.\je.,L.CPH~ ~_'1l:t~fJ. '2,6'1'0 '1'f+f., 100 '-f'R. ft-DDD BDLHJDR"-t. .. -r11t:-_~klc.~T ro~_-roCtJt.1Pk'-C~I1!.tJ:ret-17 1.~~~_f)___. ~~~~ -rQ-Hrf}<~bIT&;r_____._~ ___n_______n__ t2~IJ~/.()jJME.J".)T oP COf-JDITIO~~Ld.J~____~___~__.____._~_._._ Al11t~ CD/JOJ-r(Or0At... U~~~~I$:rarr:~\.,3:L"[f_\'~-~-- _~__ AfRJl..2.Af?fA COM~~tte.N~I\jc. Ft-6N A~o_~tre...::rH~ ____~~_ (1J,.e,~r D~ -:tHf; '~lS 2a1~_QI~T~l~___ ___~__________ --------;l1H1~ _~Oli~~A<., ~ J-'=--CD~C;\$nNI_t..'tR__CPMf'A11B>~ ~~~_____ WIIH...1tlf,~~IAHB-~f2,I'{POQ____._____. _____ _.____ ~l}-\IS ~Q~bk_~__I'--j~'"J22...."'D_\"e.COf_.\c~ Q~1H:L~___~ -~~ ~4tJ~Q.,QJ.----n~_.____~_ . n_________ ~---_E2.~~-~~a(~-fI)Bl,t~fAalc,.}1Je6 ~H1S ~~AiL__ ___ t) 1H~_Am\c.AQL8a-~" -----_._.._-~---_.._"-_.---..._._--------_._._--- - -. -------,. -...------------------------------ -----------.. --- --- ------------ n____ -----~-=mI'iL~PJ11~;e-CtM.E't.IE~bl\1HA~t...8'f~--~t2-.-.-.~n- It.ICor.II\lQ~.A~x-r... I"'tI:'- -rU-~ U-l::I:l\ .It:c'^.l'IrlvI~~~I'\c..1l1~ /::r .0.1 Recorded 3:11 PM August 15 v", Receptioni Loretta BannDr Recorder ZZCO~4 ADDENDUM :"~'3!)3 " :202 AND AHENDMENT TO PROTECTI~'E COVENANTS OF RED BUTTF. SUBDIVISION The undersigned, pursuant to the provisions of Article XII of the protec~ivo CovenantG of Red Butle Subdivision dated Sep~ember 14, 1~60 and recorded September 23, 1960 in Boo~ 191 at page 598 of the Records of the Clerk and RecorQer of pitkin County, Colorado, constituting at least 75\ of the owners of the lots in said subdivision, hereby consent and approve the following addendum and amendment to said covenants. 1. The purpose of this addendum and these amendments is to protect and continue the single family residential character of said subdivision. 2. Use of the lots in the subdivision shall be exclusively restricted to single families. A single family is hereby defined to mean a group of persons living tOgcth~r in one ~ellinq, =ain- taining a co~n housekeeping unit, and related by adoption, blOOd or marriage and shall include domestic servants and gratuitoUS guests, except that two unrelated persons so dwelling together shall alse qualify as a single family. 3. No more than four motor vehicles may be parked a t anyone time on a regular basis on the premises of any lot for more than 48 hours, and no heavy equip~~nt or vehicle exceed:ng 3/4 ton capacity shall be parked on any lot in the subd~vision for morc than twelve hours. 4. Garages shall not be constructed to accommodate more than three motor vehicles. 5. AnY acce~sory usc, defined as a use that does not change the basic character of the subdivision as one restricted to single family use, shall be conducted in enclosed portions of allowed stru,.:turOS in ordor not to presont an annoyance or nuisance to j . J . H 'I ";, li .1 .. ~ { I , I \ l i . .i , I , . '. -,' ~;~~;~mi~~~~'~'~~U~i;1 ~t ~~~, I,' " ',I! ! ! ! I '1,' " ! ! i i " , , ! ! , ,,", """"" 'l~ .. ;=f'jI..ii . .:::'!! i 1 i , : ' : : ' : : ': ! i i i ' ~~~ .~~~ , ! , Ii: , :, !": :, ;. ".:::,:". ' 11, iJ i! 'i i~~ ! i I! ! i ! i i ! ! !~ i~i~ ! ! !~j ! i :~ . . '." ,i '1IjJfUIJj~JU!iJii~Jii~;imjib1~1~1~ ;~~ii1~1~~'ii',i"~'1~1'~~i);i~~ tI il' II Jill' II i i i i : : ! ! : j i : i ! : ; ! i . ; Ii : ..,. ~ "1- I ! I , ! r ! ! : ! ! r 1 : ; , : 1 ~ : . i I . ! . I '; I ! H ~'H i I j ! I , I iJ 1 J ! , J ~ :! i j i i ~ 11~ I ill lolJ '. :! ,8 fr : ;~ is ii Ii ! i J11JJmJdbim · ~imUiJi tI .~ ~'~""";'3~"'-I'~':!~~~1~~;~ \ ~ ,'~i,,~ I '~'~:i' I' !~l i ii,: 'i i 11 I' ! ( ill 'II' i1'llll! ill I j I '. t 1 .>> i_I! 'I.!! 1 I'" /I '\"'f\ I d.lll. i ,~ ! " ' i ii' jJ i ; i " ! i U ii' ~ "., 'd ,81' "a_d II . I~;j_ , /! 1. iMiin~~!~~t!~~~~~!Jl~jM~H MOOT '"TOM . . ': ~.~' . llOO() a ~ ~ :2 ~ if> IU ~ .~ u ff~ ~Jii- r !Jl~ - cC & .. ~~c~ 5JS!.s - Vincent J. Higens President PITKIN COUNTY TITLE, INC. 601 E, HOPKINS, 3RD FLOOR ASPEN, COLORADO 81611 303-925-1766 : 303-925-6527 FAX Christina Davis Vice President 300' OWNER'S LIST Pitkin County Title, Inc., a duly licensed Title Insurance Agent in the State of Colorado, hereby certifies the following list is a current list of property owner's within three hundred feet of LOT 2, BLOCK 1, RED BUTTE SUBDIVISION, as obtained from the most current pitkin County Assessors Tax Rolls. NAMES AND ADDRESSES TAX SCHEDULE NUMBER -------------------------------------------------------------------------- JEANETTE OGILVY 1490 RED BUTTE DR, ASPEN, CO 81611 2735-013-02-004 ROLAND FISCHER GERTRUDE FISCHER / 12035 APPLEWOOD KNOLLS DR, LAKEWOOD, CO. 80215 2735-013-02-002 DONALD LEFTON I ROBIN FISHER & LON TABATCHNICK 3250 MARY ST, MIAMI, FL. 33133 2735-013-02-001 MARTIN KELLER FLORENCE E. KELLER 13880 WIDE ACRES RD. GOLDEN, CO, 80401 2735-013-02-006 CHUCK BELLOCK MADELEINE MORRIS ION 1400 28TH ST, BOULDER, CO. 80301 2735-013-02-007 .. TIMOTHY J, FORTIER LISA A, FORTIER 1465 RED BUTTE DR, ASPEN, CO, 81611 2735-013-30-003 SHIRLEY G. CLEVELAND 1445 RED BUTTE DR, ASPEN, CO, 81611 2735-013-30-002 ZURCHER p, PAEPCKE HAMILTON A, PAEPCKE DU BRUL A, PAEPCKE 300 FAMILY FARM RD, WOODSIDE, CA. 94062 MARJORIE B. STEIN STEIN & ZULFER TRUSTEES P.O, BOX 1047 ASPEN, CO, 81612 PARK TRUST LTD, P.O, BOX 9405 ASPEN, CO. 81612 -, L.o " "c. \q r -....;f---a" AUTHORIZED SIGNA - 2735-011-00-002 2643-354-00-001 2735-024-00-001 o () GARfilElLD & HIECHT, roc. ATTORNEYS AT LAW RONALD GARFIELD' ANDREW V. HECHT" MICHAEL J. HERRON*** DAVID L. LENYO MATTHEW C. FERGUSON' KRISTI S. FERRARO**** VICTORIAN SQUARE BUILDING 601 EAST HYMAN A VENUE ASPEN. COLORADO 8161 I TELEPHONE (970) 925. I 936 TELECOPIER (970) 925.3008 PATRICK D. McALLlSTER***** .alsoadmittedto New York Bar ualsoadmitledto DistrictofCoJumbia Bar 0.. also admitted to Florida Bar ....also admitted to Pennsylvania Bar .....also admitted to Pennsylvania Barand New Jersey Bar February 6, 1996 To Whom it May Concern: Re: Lot 2, Block 1, Red Butte Subdivision, According to the Plat thereof recorded on September 16, 1960 in Ditch Book 2A, at Page 259 The undersigned represents Barry Silverman and Judy Silverman who, on December 18, 1995, purchased the above-referenced propertyo An Owner's Policy of Title Insurance has not yet been delivered by the title insurance companyo Based upon the Title Insurance Commitment issued by Pitkin County Title, InCo and the Deed to the above property dated December 18, 1995, the undersigned hereby certifies that Barry Silverman and Judy Silverman are the owners of the above-referenced property. Very truly yours, GARFIELD & HECHT, P.c. ~ ~o L----- Michael J. Herron MJH/cac c:\mjh\sllvermn\lot2\concernltr <"'"0 January 28, 1996 To Whom It May Concern: I, Barry J. Silverman, authorize Stan Mathis to represent me regarding the Stream Margin Review and the Conditional Use Application for my property at Lot #2; Red Butte Subdivision, Aspen, Cplorado. 1) !Y(hj 9/, I ' \0\'tl1~..:1 , V v.__.^'-. Barry J. Silverman 03/18/1935 11:38 97~92714J5 STAN MATHIS F'AGE 04 / """" ASPEN/PITKIN COMlVfUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPAR'fl\IIENT A2reement for Pnvment of City of Asoen DevelODment Application Fees CITY OF ASPEN (hereinafter CITY) and 2?a-?-~ < 5: /c; er m ~ (hereinafter APPLICANT) AGREE AS FOLLOW: : 1, APPLICANT has submitted to CITY an application for ~.4~$~~~~~ (hereinafter, TH PROJECT.. 2. APPLICANT umj~rstanJs and o.gn:~s that City of Asp<:,n Ordinance No. 53 (So::rit:S ll! 1995) est:lolishes a I't:t: ,fructure tor Planning appli"::Hi,>ns and the payment of all pfl')C~ssin~ re~~ is a comliti,)n pr':CeJem to a dekrminacion of application completeness. 3. APPLICA.:'<JT and CITY aeree that because: or the size. nature or scope of the proposed proj,,~t. it is not -possible elr chis timt" to :lscertain the full ex-tent of the costs involveu in proct"ssing the application. APPLICA;..iT and CITY further agree rhar ir is in rhe intere~t nf the rurti~s ro allow APPLICANT ro make payment of an initinI d~rl)sit ilnd to th~reaftt:r permit adi.litional ,'osts to be billed to APPLlCAI"T on a monthly basis. APPLICAI"T a~ret's he will be benetited by n:tJining greater cash liquidity and will make add~ional payments upon notitic:ltiOI1 Iw the CITY when thev are l1t"cessarv as costs are incurred. CITY agrees it will he benefited through the greater certainly of rec,wering it.~ full cosrs to process APPLlCA;..iTS applic:lticlIl. 4. CITY Jnd APPLICANT further agree that it is impril<.:ticable for CITY staff to complete proct'ssing or present sufficiem infQrmari('n fO the PlanniOIl; Commission and/or Citv Council tn enahle [he Plannin!! Cnmmission and/or City Council to make legaliy r~quired tindings for project arproval. IInless Current billings are paid in full prior tn decisiOlL 03/18113% 11: 38 37B327~A.1.5 STAN MATHIS F'AGE 05 5. Therefore, APPLICANT agrees that in consideration of the CITY's waiver of its right to collect full fees prior to a determi"'ltion of application completeness, APPLICANT shall pay an initial deposit in the amount of S /o60_#J.1 which is for L hours of Planning staff time, and if actual recorded costs exceed me initial deposit, APPLICANT shall pay additional monthly billings to CITY to reimburse the CITY fur the processing of the application mentioned above, including post approval review. Such periodic payments shall be made within 30 days of the billing date, APPLICANT further agrees that failure to pay such accrued costs shall be grounds for suspension of processing. CITY OF A.SPEN q;(: BY~ \~ 4.- .. '. Jauson Community Development Director APPLICANT '17 P"J By: jJ CVv\"1-"~'r;.,.~ Me> Date:~ Mailing Address: 2 ""--- ASPEN/PITKIN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 130 South Galena Street Aspen, Colorado 81611 Phone (970) 920-5090 FAX (970) 920-5439 MEMORANDUM TO: City Engineer Housing Director Parks FROM: Dave Michaelson, Planner RE: Silverman Stream Margin Review & Conditional Use for ADU Review Parcel ID No. 2735-013-02-003 DATE: March 21,1996 Attached for your review and comments is an application submitted by Dr. Barry Silverman. Please return your comments to me no later than March 26, 1996. Thank you. . , ASPEN/PITKIN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 130 S. Galena Street Aspen, Colorado 81611 (970) 920-5090 FAX# (970) 920-5439 March 21, 1996 Re: Silverman Stream Margin Review, Conditional Use for ADU Review Case A21-96 Dear Stan, The Community Development Department has completed its preliminary review of the captioned application. We have determined that this application is complete. We have scheduled this application for review by the Aspen Planning and Zoning CommissIOn at a Public Hearing to be held on Tuesday, April 2, 1996 at a meeting to begin at 4:30 p.m. Should this date be inconvenient for you please contact me within 3 working days of the date of this letter. After that the agenda date will be considered final and changes to the schedule or tabling of the application will only be allowed for unavoidable technical problems. The Friday before the meeting date, we will call to inform you that a copy of the memo pertaining to the application is available at the Community Development Department. Please note that it is your responsibility to mail notice to property owners within 300' and to post the subject property with a sign at least ten (10) days prior to the public hearing. Please submit a photograph of the posted sign as proof of posting and an affidavit as proof of mailing prior to the public hearing. If you have any questions, please call the planner assigned to your case, Dave Michaelson, at 920- 5100. Sincerely, /', ~.. . Uu,Lci\....;!a ~tt--J Rhonda Harris Administrative Assistant PUBLIC NOTICE RE: SILVERMAN STREAM MARGIN REVIEW AND CONDITIONAL USE REVIEW NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held on Tuesday, April2, 1996 at a meeting to begin at 4:30 p,m. before the Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission, Sister Cities Meeting Room, City Hall, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen, to consider an application submitted by Barry J. Silverman, requesting approval of a Stream Margin Review and Conditional Use Review for an approximately 384 square feet Accessory Dwelling Unit within the proposed residence. The property is located at 1490 Red Butte Drive, and is described as Lot 2, Block 1, Red Butte Subdivision. For further information, contact Dave Michaelson at the Aspen/Pitkin Community Development Department, 130 S. Galena St., Aspen, CO (970) 920-5100. s/Sara Garton. Chair Aspen Planning and Zoning Commission 1D /~.- . ) .' , / \ ) \J J \ , .. ~ Aspen/Pitkin Community Development Department 130 South Galena Street Aspen, Colorado 81611 (970) 920-5090 2155 - 013-0'2. -L)63 City Land Use Application Fees: 00113-63850-041 Deposit -63855.042 Flat Fee -63860-043 HPC ---.--.--------- .63885-268 Public Right-of-Way ________________ -63875-046 Zoning & Sign Permlt~_______m_ MR011 Use Tax In"'i() ()O . County Land Use Application Fees: 00113-63 gOO-033 Deposit -63805-034 Flat Fee -638)0-037 Zoning -63825-038 Board of Adjustment Referrld Fees: 00113-63810-035 00115-63340-163 00123-63340-190 00125-63340-205 00113-63815-036 County Engineer City Engineer Housing Environmental Health County Clerk Sales: 00113-63830-039 -69000-145 County Code Copy Fees Other a!~~~ FL 33f3() Phone: Total~{)"5n, ()() Date.2,Jn Check: 1')8() Project 61 hl<"fl:110 VI {Ill -I ~r Ynn~ln Case No: '!:J~ - OJ,,, No. of Coples_